By-election update: A very near miss

ALDC Master Logo (for screen)

This week saw nine by-elections in principal authorities – Argyll & Bute, Cornwall, East Dorset, Harrogate, two in Herefordshire, Kings Lynn and West Norfolk, Oxford and Redditch.

In Harrogate Clare Skardon held Hookstone ward for the Liberal Democrats with 51.7% of the vote; an increase of 9.1%. Cllr Skardon successfully managed to squeeze all her opponents’ share of the vote: the Conservatives acquired 32.1% of the votes (-1.8%), UKIP were third with 12% (-4.3%) and Labour came last with 4.1% (-3%). Cllr Skardon puts her victory down to a strong local team with a good record of action in the local area. Residents had benefited from years of service from longstanding Cllr Reg Marsh and were keen to keep a full Liberal Democrat team serving the area. The Labour vote was encouraged to vote strategically and UKIP’s campaign failed to gain traction despite their increased attention which included canvassing for the first time. The Conservatives pumped a lot of resources into their campaign but a visible Liberal Democrat poster campaign and leaflets highlight a wasteful plan to spend £9 million on new Council offices helped to depress the Tory vote. The local Lib Dem team also focused on getting literature out before postal votes were sent out to maximise their local support.

A by-election was held in Colehill East ward (East Dorset DC) after the death of Lib Dem Councillor Don Wallace who died in May. Cllr Wallace served for 41 years on the district council including as Chairman between 1995-6. He died in May aged 95. Barry Roberts retained the seat for the Liberal Democrats with 59.3% of the vote (+8.7%). The Conservatives were runners up with 26% (-5.6%) and UKIP came third with 14.7% (-6.4%).

John Ault missed out by just one vote from taking a seat from UKIP in Mabe, Perranarworthal and St Gluvias (Cornwall UA). The Conservative victor won 406 votes to John’s 405. The intensive campaign run by the local Liberal Democrats easily out delivered their opponents’ campaigns and involved over 10 leaflets and knocking on every door three times. The 10-mile long rural ward is true blue territory and includes three villages and the University campus at Penryn. John, who works at the University, actively engaged students in his campaign: his nomination papers were signed by ten students and 20 year old Tom Fidler was his agent (as well as being one of the students he teaches!). A very localised campaign focused around the loss of a bus service and cuts to the mobile Library helped boost the Lib Dem vote by 9.5%. Running a positive campaign focused on local issues stood in stark contrast to UKIP who ran anti-EU stories. As a result the UKIP fell from first to third and received 21% (-7%). Labour and Mebyon Kernow also stood coming fourth and fifth respectively.

For all the detailed results see the ALDC elections 

* ALDC is the Association of Liberal Democrat Councillors and Campaigners

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in News.


  • paul barker 18th Jul '14 - 4:27pm

    Looking at changes in vote share we had an average rise of 4%, Labour & Tories were down by 1% & 2%. The big losers were UKIP down in all 4 seats where they stood both times, an average fall of 7%. UKIP often get very good results when they stand for the first time but seem to have problems hanging on to their voters, a demonstration of the limits of pure Protest.

  • Paul do not forget to look at ALL the results yesterday:
    Kings Lynn no candidate
    Redditch 2.9% votes 40
    Hereford no candidate: 14% last time
    Oxford County Council 3% 39 votes
    Leominster no candidate

    Pretty chilling

  • Kevin Tillett 18th Jul '14 - 6:08pm

    For the record theakes, there was no election in Hereford. The 2 elections in the county were in Leominster and Ledbury, both in the N. Herefordshire constituency.

  • Worth saying Kevin that it was not so long ago that Leominster was one of the Party’s best English seats and now we have no candidate

  • Kevin, does it matter, the point is this used to be an area of Liberal, Lib Dem strength, now!!:

  • Simon Oliver 19th Jul '14 - 12:37pm

    Here in Redditch we have about five activists and chose not to campaign in the by-election. On a 22% turnout our vote is just 40 in Church Hill, but that compares to 79 on a 38% turnout in May, so it was comparable, while both the Green and UKIP votes collapsed. I interret that as holding steady and we went from 5th to 4th while UKIP went from 1st to 3rd.

    The town is now a three-way marginal where those three parties fight hard, with us a poor fourth and expecting anything more at this point is fantasy.


  • Simon, absolutely you represent the situation as it is in so many areas, constituencies and wards of the country.
    Fantasy is the word I use for those who try to say okay, we are alright and it will be a lot lot better next year. We know it will not. The party as a whole is in a hole and it continues to dig, at this rate we may reach Australia!.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • expats
    Peter Davies 2nd Dec '22 - 8:08pm..........or to put it another way, Labour lost 9773 votes, Tories lost 14583 and we only lost 1366......... or, to put it a...
  • Merlene Emerson
    Thanks Mark for this tribute. Shocked and saddened by Robert's sudden passing as he was still so alive and full of ideas for new projects. I joined the World Tr...
  • Martin
    Alex Macfie and Nonconformistradical: As I wrote, the underlying voting dynamics in a byelection are not always straightforward, however in general and certa...
  • Peter Davies
    or to put it another way, Labour lost 9773 votes, Tories lost 14583 and we only lost 1366....
  • Nonconformistradical
    @Martin I suggest you go and look at some past results for Chester - it's a long time since we've had a decent result there. See