If Alex Cole-Hamilton were to slap me, he would, rightly, face the full force of the law. If he were to slap his 5 year old daughter Darcy (which would never happen), he could do so with the full support of the law, which allows “reasonable chastisement.”
That is an inconsistency that he has been campaigning against for years. Today his work and that of many others was rewarded when the Scottish Parliament voted to give children the same protection from assault in law as adults, becoming the first country in the UK to do so.
I’ve known Alex for almost two decades. In that time I’ve teased him on many occasions, always with justification. But there have been many more times when I have been proud of him and today is one of the biggest. One of the reasons I spent a decade trying to get him elected was that I knew he would be an amazing advocate for Scotland’s children.
He’s been working to change the law on physical punishment of children for a long time. And he had an uphill battle trying to change party policy. In 2013, we lost by just 9 votes. Three years later, the result went the opposite way – and overwhelmingly. The proposer of the amendment in favour of keeping the law as it is changed his mind during the course of the debate, persuaded by the arguments. This move ensured Lib Dem support for the Bill today.
Today’s Bill was originally brought by Green MSP John Finnie but it had cross party support across Holyrood – except from the Conservatives, of course.
Here is Alex’s speech in favour of the Bill.
Physical punishment is not consequence free. It can cast a long shadow, affecting self esteem and mental health long after the childhood years. I am delighted that Scotland’s children of the future will have the same legal protection as I have from assault.
* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings. You can find her on Bluesky at caronmlindsay.bsky.social
Follow @libdemvoice.org on Bluesky
Like us on Facebook
Subscribe to our feed
Sign-up for our daily email digest
How Chancellor Reeves torpedoed the economy
The Disneyfication of Haley Mills
Survation now put Andy Burnham 10 points ahead in Makerfield
Michael Meadowcroft: A Liberal of Intellectual Rigour and Uncommon Integrity
Chris Cory
Ruth Bright
BigTallTim
Daniel Walker
Richard Good
3 Comments
There is another form of abuse. When I was older my mother told me about a time that after her shouting at me I said ‘let Daddy smack me’, was obviously less bad than being shouted at! She remembered it years later.
Personally I support this ban, and yet I meet so many people who say something like; “when I was a child and I did something wrong my parents gave me a good thrashing and it did me the world of good.” My personal experience was different, I would never hit a child given what it did to me.
What bothers me is just how unpopular this policy is likely to be. Really we should not judge the policy simply on personal experience, myself included. What does the research say? Some parents get so angry that what some might consider (not me) to be “reasonable chastisement” of their child can easily turn into a serious assault. I think parents need to know the alternatives to disciplining their children and given that they do not always learn what they are from their parents then I think that parenting should be taught in schools. I know that is another minefield given the different ideologies on how to do that but I suspect we can find out how this is done in other countries.
Well done John Finnie and all who supported him.