In the wake of the BLM movement, Police and Crime Commissioners need to be leaders in building the relationship with minority communities

Embed from Getty Images

Here’s how they can do it:

On May 25th, George Floyd was brutally murdered by American Police Officers, sparking protests in the USA that then spread across the world, including to here in the United Kingdom where protesters highlighted racial disparities in stop and search statistics and UK complicity in the slave trade.

In 2012, the first Police and Crime Commissioners were elected across England and Wales with responsibility for producing a crime plan, managing the police budget and most importantly, bringing a directly accountable figurehead to policing here in England and Wales. It is the latter point which makes the 2021 set of Police and Crime Commissioner elections that are being held in the shadow of the Black Lives Matter movement, so important.

When the Black Lives Matter protests in the UK begun, they highlighted above all else, a deep-rooted anger about the very real inequality of treatment that minority communities have faced when it comes to criminal justice issues. It is because of this inequality of treatment, that minority communities rightly need to feel they can trust the police again.

This anger is exacerbated by stop and search statistics that show BAME communities being disproportionately targeted, undermining those communities’ trust in the police. Whilst at the same time, hate crimes are consistently rising. This has created a situation where a mutual trust between the Police and minority communities is vital part of the challenge of tackling the number of hate crimes.

As Police and Crime Commissioner have been since 2012, the publicly accountable faces of policing in England and Wales, the responsibility of building the trust between minority communities and the police falls to them to show leadership on.

As one of the candidates for Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner in Essex. I have set out a three-step plan to begin the work of tackling racial injustice in the criminal justice system. These steps are by no means the finished article, but they encompass the crucial first steps of listening, acting on concerns and being proactive on known inequalities.

The first step to fixing the relationship begins with community engagement. I have begun putting together the Essex Hate Crime Commission headed up by a Commissioner for Community Engagement. This body will be comprised of leaders from the religious, LGBT+ and BAME communities. This group would work with the PCC to build bridges between the communities and the police, helping foster an atmosphere of mutual trust. It is crucial that this body is independent of the office of the Police and Crime Commissioner and is empowered to speak truth to power.

The second aspect is acting on the advice of the Commissioner for Community Relations. The ability to provide good policing to minority communities is greatly bolstered by those communities genuinely being listened to when they raise concerns. In areas such as stop and search usage, the views of minority communities are clear, the problem lies with the fact that these issues are consistently unaddressed. If the Commissioner listens to their advice and acts upon it in relation to a crime and policing plan, it will go a long way to repairing the relationships between minority communities and the police.

The third leg of the plan is acting quickly to address known inequalities. For this I want to turn to racial inequality in drug offence sentencing, this issue has been widely reported on, yet no leading figures in the criminal justice system have managed to address it. One way of addressing it is the adoption of a non-prosecution policy for personal drug use. This can be implemented in the crime plan that the Police and Crime Commissioners will be drawing up in May 2021. The impact of this will be working around the ingrained sentencing disparity that sees far too many minor crimes being faced with penal sentencing. By implementing a policy such as this, a Police and Crime Commissioner can make genuine inroads into addressing the concerns of minority communities in relation to policing.

This three-step plan is by no means the end of the challenge Police and Crime Commissioners face in winning the trust of minority communities, but any PCC using it would be demonstrating that they are serious in tackling the issues faced by the communities we seek to represent.

* Callum Robertson is a teacher and former Chair of the Young Liberals

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • You should know that there have been and still are a range of programmes and policies in place aimed at preventing people who are caught in possession of small amounts of illicit drugs for personal use from being prosecuted, not least the Drug Interventions Programme which was implemented by the Blair government. These programmes have some merit, the problem is that when people become dependent on illicit drugs their dependence usually ends up outstripping their legal finances, causing a very significant percentage of that population to resort to crime to fund their drug use and that’s where arrest and prosecution starts to be the normal disposal. Calls to legalise all or various illicit drugs may arguably have some benefits but it’s hard to see how this would impact on drug related crime by dependent users who lack the the finances to fund their habit. Even if we moved to prescribing drugs such as heroin and crack, no doctor would prescribe a dangerous amount of medication, dependence by it’s very nature leads to the desire / need to use more of the same to get the desired effect.

  • Michael Sammon 10th Sep '20 - 11:49pm

    Well done Callum, I think you would be first class for Essex Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner. They better be listening!

  • John Marriott 11th Sep '20 - 11:03am

    No, Police and Crime Commissioners need to be abolished and replaced with a democratically accountable body not dissimilar to the old Police Authorities.

  • jayne Mansfield 12th Sep '20 - 5:49pm

    I agree with John Marriott.

  • Michael Bukola 13th Sep '20 - 12:55pm

    I stood in one of the Basildon seats at the last election and could see for myself the challenges faced by BAME communities with antisemitism in Canvey Island or Islamophobia in Vange with a petition to stop an old pub being turned into a mosque. I would suggest a route and branch review of the Stop and Search policy across Essex closely followed by an examination of taser usage against BAME suspects as well as a review of deaths in custody of BAME suspects and the suitability of Custody suite facilities in terms of dedicated Nursing staff on-site or nursing staff on-call.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • David Franks
    It is all so frustrating. What do ordinary members have to do to get the 'leadership' to shout about our clear and distinctive position on relationships with th...
  • Tim Rogers
    In general I agree with this although perhaps longer than I would have gone for. It explains why brexit has,is and will fail and cool level headed thinking is n...
  • Peter Martin
    " if nothing is done about the taper rate GBI will suffer from exactly the same problem as UC does now" The UBI also has an effective worsened "t...
  • Ian Shires
    "Thomas Price", thanks for this excellent article. There was much that was good in Ed's speech to conference, but there was something that was sadly missing. Yo...
  • Russell
    Martin, you jest, but I happen to think that illegal wars like the 2nd Iraq war (the reason I started supporting the LDs) do have consequences. If I'm wrong the...