Is Gordon safe?

Martin Kettle’s article in The Guardian – suggesting that the week beginning 12th October is make-or-break week for those Labour MPs who’d like to oust Gordon Brown – has sparked a fresh bout of Labour leadership speculation. The Economist’s Bagehot is having none of it:

Labour MPs have had their chance. And it wasn’t in June 2009 or in October 2008. It was in 2007, when almost all of them lined up, baa-ing, to endorse Mr Brown. They were too numbed by more than a decade of unthinking obedience and by cowardice to do anything else. That is a fact and a failing that, however uncomfortable it seems, they will have to live with between now and the general election—and, if it proves as calamitous as seems likely, for a long time afterwards.

A fair observation – but is it an accurate one? Might Labour have time for one last putsch; and if Mr Brown was elbowed aside (or, more unlikely still, voluntarily departed) would it be enough to save the party from a landslide loss at next year’s election? What do LDV’s readers you think?

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in News.


  • Silent Hunter 6th Sep '09 - 3:00pm

    I think the more relevant question would have to be . . .

    Is Gordon SANE?

  • I think if he goes at that time there’ll have to be an election unless Johnson puts forward a comprehensive and radical democratic reform package. The public aren’t wearing a fag-end Labour Govt elected on the false premise of `don’t vote Lib Dem to let the Tories in` and `end of boom and bust` what will they think of a new coronation or an internal election while in power? It’ll also see them out of office for a generation. People keep saying that Labour can pull it out of the bag. I don’t buy it – they are down to core vote and that won’t win an election. They are out for a generation.

  • Well the story doesn’t seem to be going away does it?
    So he can’t be perfectly safe. But who knows the future?

    Oh and Silent H this may be of interest:

  • Malcolm Todd 6th Sep '09 - 3:35pm

    I think you’re wrong that Brown departing voluntarily is even more unlikely than a coup – I think it’s the only way he’ll be out before the GE. I don’t think removing him would do the Labour Party any good – there’s not enough time for a new leader to find his/her feet (assuming that there wasn’t a mass electoral revolt at a second midterm change of PM, which I think is likely), and there’s no grand conciliatory measure that can rejuvenate the Labour Party now. In 1990-92, it wasn’t just Major replacing Thatcher that made a difference, it was the substance and symbolism of Heseltine coming back into the centre of government. Even Mandelson’s return isn’t nearly so resonant, and anyway that fox has been shot.

  • Stanley Theed 6th Sep '09 - 6:29pm

    As a Liberal Democrat I would like to see Labour try to get rid of Gordon. Whatever the result it could only damage them. If, as seems likely they lose office at the next election Gordon should then stand down or be removed. From the poll figures it seems that the Tories will win and presumably they will. However Dave and George do not exactly inspire confidence as prospective Prime Minister and Chancellor and much can happen before people complete their ballot papers.

  • Andrew Suffield 6th Sep '09 - 7:53pm

    It’s a toss-up whether a new leader could give them a chance – but I think by now even Labour realises that Brown is going to be the second Labour PM in history (after Callaghan) who never won an election. It would be ironically appropriate for Brown to complete the pattern by getting kicked out of office.

    I am disinclined to think that another midterm PM would be possible – the disarray in the Labour party’s ranks would leave them wide open to a Tory-led confidence vote, which would effectively hand Cameron the election. If it happens it’ll mostly likely be a “Brown serves out the end of his term but somebody else stands in the general election” thing. Probably couldn’t win on that basis, but it might mitigate the damage enough to keep them from falling into third place.

    Still, anything can happen in Parliament.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Nonconformistradical
    "the stunt did get coverage on mass media and the point of it was explained in the footage I saw." Quite. e.g.
  • Chris Moore
    Nonetheless, in spite of the whingers and purists on here, the stunt did get coverage on mass media and the point of it was explained in the footage I saw. I...
  • Laurence Cox
    Ed Davey falling off the paddleboard reminded me of when we exposed the pollution of the River Thames. That was just Sarah Ludford and Dee Doocey, the former ho...
  • expats
    Chris Moore 28th May '24 - 1:40pm...And it’s a total travesty to say all we get is gimmicks....But in any case, it seems like it’s the gimmicks that have st...
  • David Allen "The Liberal Democrats have pledged to put environmental experts on (water company) boards..." Let's hop...