Migration and the future of the EU

Bach’s cantata “Brich den Hungrigen dein Brot” got the nickname “the refugee cantata” in 1732 when Protestant refugees fleeing a clampdown in Salzburg arrived in Leipzig. The title translates as “Bring the hungry your bread”. It was to be taken literally. It’s a reminder of how much forced migration has shaped European history.

As an island, the UK has escaped the experiences of invasion and moving of borders which have shaped so much of the history of the European mainland — though I suspect that one of the things fuelling both pressure for Scottish independence and the Scottish affinity for the EU is their experience of domination from London.

My Scottish great grandfather who moved from Perthshire to Essex was an economic migrant. My surname is an old Huguenot name — brought by people fleeing genocide in France. Others of my forebears had the name “Woodward” — anglicised from an old Dutch name. I’m not sure if fleeing near-starvation made them “refugees” or “economic migrants”.

At the moment we are facing a huge migrant crisis because of people fleeing Syria. There’s a sense that the EU authorities should “do something”. A few months ago a similar pressure over Greece led me to think that the EU was being grumbled about aswe grumble about goverments, so it was now being treated as a federal government. The migrant crisis adds to this. There might be parallels betwen frustrations with Brussels and with Westminster, though I am concerned that this might lead people to vote “no” to the EU where they simply grumble about Westminster.

We are bound up with the situation on the ground in Syria. Part of the problem goes back to the way the European powers divided up the Ottoman empire at the end of the First World War — where wiggly European borders reflect centuries of development, the the curiously-straight borders in that part of the Middle East reflect political expediency a century ago. Part of what is going on in the Middle East now reflects the problems that brought. Part of the Syria crisis seems to be about Russia and Western powers vying for influence. The fundamentalists of ISIL/Daesh are unsavoury, but at least part of their behaviour — and what is motivating people from the EU to go and join them — is a reaction against the Western tendency to equate “Muslim” and “terrorist” in a mis-placed fear of the “other”. The Syria problem is very much “ours”, even if the solution is a mix of aid to people in the refugee camps and accepting our fare share of refugees.

But this is just a fore-taste. The much bigger migration issue, where we are all involved, will come from global warming. In that context, I’m not sure of the difference between the “economic migrant” who reads the writing on the wall and leaves in search of a better live, the person who waits and becomes a “refugee” when their home becomes uninhabitable and the “asylum-seeker” who flees the repressive regime that comes to power when resources are scarce. It might be better if people migrate sooner rather than later, so they don’t arrive bearing the trauma of becoming “refugees” or “asylum-seekers”.

At our conference in Bournemouth Ed Davey was right to lament the present government’s attitude to global warming. We need to be working with our European partners to reduce our CO2 emissions: neither the problem nor the solution respects national borders.

In the face of climate change, “fortress Europe” (or “fortress Britain”) will never be impregnable. Our moral authority will be undermined if we have not worked together to combat the problem we have helped to create. Migration will need a constructive approach across the whole EU to share the benefits and burdens of migration. If the EU gets the balance right this will lead to more international connectedness, stability and trade. If we get it wrong, the result will be resentment, sometimes vented as terrorism.

The choice seems to be between working together in the EU in a way that delivers peace and stability, and a “Little Englander” isolationism that may be seductive but is more dangerous than people realise.

* Mark Argent was the Liberal Democrat candidate in Huntingdon Constituency in 2019 and blogs at markargent.com/blog.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Europe / International and Op-eds.


  • Eddie Sammon 2nd Oct '15 - 6:57pm

    Some good points on the blurred lines between economic migrants and refugees “I’m not sure of the difference between the “economic migrant” who reads the writing on the wall and leaves in search of a better live, the person who waits and becomes a “refugee” “.

    I’m not comfortable with linking negative attitudes towards migration and multiculturalism with terrorism though. This seems to be the done thing at the moment, but I just think it risks creating excuses for people joining Daech and terrorism against the UK.

  • Richard Underhill 2nd Oct '15 - 7:06pm

    In 1955 diplomats negotiated the end of four power occupation of Austria on the basis that Austria had been invaded by Hitler’s Germany in the Anschluss. The Soviet Union therefore withdrew from eastern Austria, Austria declared itself neutral and Hungary had a border with the West. Hungary’s brutal communist regime faced a rebellion, which was supressed by tanks from the Soviet Union and their satellites. Large numbers of refugees poured over the border into Austria and dispersed around the world.
    The Soviets were wary of another rebellion in Hungary.
    In 1989 a Hungarian minister took press and media to the border with Austria and made holes in the Iron Curtain. East Germans poured through into Austria and continued into West Germany. Subsequently the Berlin Wall was demolished. and Germany’s long-stated ambition for re-unification was achieved. The entire government machine packed their bags and moved from Bonn to Berlin.
    An independent contested a parliamentary by-election in Hungary and won.
    Hungarians who know their history know about refugees, so it sad that the current Hungarian government is taking the attitude it does.
    The Liberal Democrat News welcomed democratic progress in Hungary, but the editor noted arrogance among the Hungarians.
    Mr Orban’s party, FIDESZ, had an age limit for membership of 35 years. until the members got a little older.

  • Richard Underhill 2nd Oct '15 - 7:09pm

    i actually knew the Hungarian who won the by-election. He stayed at my house once. We met again in Budapest at a congress. i was also country officer for Hungary pee CIPU.

  • Eddie Sammon 5th Oct '15 - 1:50pm

    Just to modify my initial comment: I think it’s fine to link alienation to terrorism, but I think I see too much blaming of other things for terrorism besides the terrorist. The terrorist needs to take responsibility and we shouldn’t create a culture of excuses for them.

    Obviously I don’t think this article is “creating a culture of excuses”, I just disagree with the emphasis a bit.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Mohammed Amin
    I live in both Manchester and London, splitting my time between them. I cannot remember how I first became aware of the Mill. However after just a few weeks ...
  • Guy
    There's plenty for teachers to strike about at the moment - picking solely on pay is a massive mistake. To me, this dispute has been a long time in the making a...
  • David Evans
    Peter, Indeed you may be right, but indeed Peter Watson may be wrong. All in all, I think my point still stands. I would urge you both not to judge so...
  • Martin
    Mick Taylor: For issues of intimidation and harassment there are other considerations that involve the care and protection of innocent parties. You do have to a...
  • Anthony Acton
    Why are the LD leaders not shooting at an open goal on this? It's the one national issue where the public would expect the party to lead. If fear of anti EU sen...