NEW POLL: time to disestablish the Church of England?

140 years after Gladstone helped reunite the Liberal Party around the issue of disestablishing the Anglican Church of Ireland, the issue of the link between Church and State has once again reared its head. The Telegraph yesterday reported that the Government is considering

a report being drawn up in Downing Street on ways to reform a key element of the established Church, the 1701 Act of Settlement, which bars a Catholic from ascending to the throne. David Cairns, a former Roman Catholic priest who resigned as a minister at the Scotland Office two months ago in protest at Gordon Brown’s leadership, said … “It is simply untenable in this day and age that should the heir to the throne want to marry a Roman Catholic he would have to renounce his rights. It’s absurd.

“But you can’t just unpick that one thing. You have to think through the consequences. If Prince William married a Catholic what happens if their children are Catholic? You can’t have a Roman Catholic head of the Church of England. So you have to have some way of resolving the issue of the head of state being the titular head of the established Church. If the Archbishop [of Canterbury] himself is raising the prospect of disestablishment why not do something about it?”

I was brought up in the nonconformist Christian tradition, and it has always seemed to me utterly bizarre that the state should have any say over matters of personal faith; that the appointment of bishops and archbishops should be subject to government approval is the ultimate hubris (admittedly the Church of England’s founder was not known for his demure modesty). And that the Church, which presumably is in the position to appeal to the Highest Power of all, should seek instead to pray in aid man-made government suggests a worrying lack of self-confidence.

Of course, the reality is that church disestablishment is a minority interest; historical anachronism though it is, it’s hard to point to a particular malignancy, a social ill, that would be cured through the separation of church and state. I guess for me it’s more a case of “I wouldn’t start from here” – disestablishment is, in my view, the right thing to do, the neat thing to do. But it’s not going to get me impassioned.

The case for the continuing establishment of the Church of England was espoused by a Liberal Democrat very recently – Alan Beith, speaking last month at the Liberal Democrat Christian Forum’s inaugural Gladstone Lecture, put forward the view that:

… disestablishment is not a necessary feature of a diverse and multi-cultural society, and if the purpose of disestablishment were to make religion less significant in society, that would not justify it. Indeed, if that were to be the result, it would be most unwelcome to many of the groups in whose interest it is being pursued – I know of no evidence that significant numbers of Muslims, Jews, Hindus or Sikhs are at all interested in getting the Church of England disestablished, and it is no longer a popular view with nonconformists or Catholics as it was a century ago. … in current conditions disestablishment might pander to the view that religion in general needs to be banished from society, painted out like offensive graffiti by council workers, almost literally in some cases. It is that sort of view which produces “winterval” and “happy holidays” instead of Christmas, and takes down crosses in crematoria.

But what’s your view, dear reader? That’s what LDV is asking in our Christmas week poll: Do you think the time has now come for the Church of England to be disestablished?

Here are your options:

>> Yes, the link between state and church should be immediately ended
>> Yes, in principle, but it is a minor issue
>> No, it is important to retain the link between church and state
>> Don’t know / Other

As ever, feel free to argue more nuanced points in the comments thread below…

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Voice polls.


  • The Winter Solstice happened last night, and the only people who seemed to be celebrating it properly were down at Stonehenge in the cold and the mud.

    Just what does the Winter Solstice have to do with Jesus, Bethlehem and a child born to a married virgin?

    “Winterval” is a ghastly English/Latin hybrid smacking of the sickness of political correctness.

    There are two Basque words for “Christmas” that speak to the festival’s ancient meaning: NEGUMUGA “winter boundary” and “ZUBILLARO” “log season” (one burns logs to celebrate the passing of the lowest point of the sun).

    If that offends Christians, Moslems, atheists, or whomsoever, then stuff them!

  • The establishment of the Church of England (in England, but not in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland) tells me, a non-Anglican, that I am a second-class citizen.

  • David Morton 23rd Dec '08 - 2:33am

    From the article and thread why is disestablishing the Church of Scotland not worth a mention ? Or a Poll ?

    All i would say on the subject is that establishment has done much over the years to protect England from proper religion. If it ever hapened as one day doubtless it will the secularists will wish they had been careful what they wished for.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Zachary Adam Barker
    A very interesting and engaging article. I hope that our party will become more ambitious about policy planning with regards to Space related issues. I find...
  • Zachary Adam Barker
    It is appalling that this state of affairs has been allowed to continue for so long. It is even more appalling that there are those who take it upon themselv...
  • John Waller
    Chris and Dominic, please read what Patrick Cockburn says....
  • Simon R
    @Steve Trevethan. That article you quote looks very twisted to me. The UK and the US did NOT torpedo a peace agreement between Ukraine and Russia: The 'peace ag...
  • Chris Moore
    Dominic, it's important that we hand over the Baltic States as well and Georgia and Poland. Otherwise there will never be peace. And as Steve and John poi...