Observations of an ex pat: Trump the pushover

Donald Trump likes to portray himself as strong man. A hard, tough man who stands up to the rest of the world, tweets it like it is and puts America first. The evidential facts tell a different story.  Trump is increasingly becoming the puppet of anti-democratic strongmen such as Turkish President Erdogan, Hungarian Prime Minister Orban and Russia’s Vladimir Putin who use the American president’s craving for acceptance to manipulate him for their own ends.

Trump grew up in the New York borough of Queens when it was the first stop for the latest generation of immigrants struggling to survive in the land of opportunity.  The denizens of Manhattan looked down on Queens and all who dwelt there. Trump was determined to show the descendants of the Vanderbilts and Astors.  He would make billions; marry super models; become a reality TV star; plaster his name in 40ft high letters across giant skyscrapers and, finally, become president of the United States.

He wasn’t a strong man. He was a failed businessman who suffered six bankruptcies and was shunned by the New York aristocracy he courted. His life has been one long struggle against a debilitating inferiority complex. And like so many second-raters who seek justification through the accumulation of power and money he has sought the advice, approval and company of those who are truly powerful and ruthless. Nowhere is this more evident than in Trump’s policy in Eastern Europe.

On 13 May Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban had a 45-minute meeting with Donald Trump in the Oval Office. A meeting at the White House is no small matter. It is a much sought after honour which implicitly bestows on the visitor the presidential seal of approval. His audience was opposed by Trump’s national security advisers but pushed by Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney. The security advisers made it clear that Orban should be blocked because he has politicised the Hungarian judiciary; taken control of the media; changed the electoral system to favour his party, adopted a strong pro-Russian stand; is rabidly anti-immigrant and euro-sceptic.

The State Department, National Security Council and others thought that Orban’s basic values and actions conflicted with American values  and could send the wrong message to America’s traditional allies and Congress. But Orban’s values did not conflict with Trump’s. He was keen to meet a strong personality who could get things done. As David Cornstein, Trump’s  Ambassador to Budapest said: “I can tell you, knowing the president for a good 25 or 30 years, that he would love to have the power that Viktor Orban enjoys…..”

Orban took his meeting opportunity to attack corruption in Ukraine. Mind you, there is a lot to criticise. Transparency International ranks Ukraine 120 out of 180 on its country by country corruption scale. Some 67 percent of the population have said that they have had to pay bribes at some point or another to police, health workers or education officials. Volodmy Zelsnky, who was swept into office 17 days after Orban’s White House visit, came to power on a strong anti-corruption ticket.  Mind you, Orban’s administration has its own corruption problems.  Transparency International ranks it at 64th out of 180 countries,

But the Hungarian Prime Minister had a hidden agenda in Washington. His real aim was to create conditions which would lead to Ukraine to hiving off its southern Zakarpattia province which is dominated by ethnic Hungarians. Since the end of the 19th century Zakarpattia has bounced between the Austro-Hungarian Empire, Hungary, Romania, Czechoslovakia and finally, after World War II, the Ukraine, which was then promptly absorbed into the USSR until independence in 1991. Orban claims that the roughly 160,000 ethnic Hungarians are being oppressed by the Kiev government and would like to see Zakarpattia annexed by Hungary in the same way that Putin has annexed the Crimea and Eastern Ukraine.

There is no real evidence to support Orban’s claims of oppression. Hungarian language and culture is taught in Ukrainian schools in ethnic Hungarian areas and many ethnic Hungarians have dual Hungarian and Ukrainian nationality. But Orban needs to keep feeding the fires of populist nationalism to stay on top at home and so he stokes the flames wherever and whenever he can—including with President Trump at the White House.

Trump, was all ears. Partly because he admired strong man Orban and partly because he knew that Hunter Biden had been working for the Ukrainian natural gas company Burisma. The sequential line of thinking could easily have gone like this: Orban convinces Trump that Ukraine is riddled with corruption; Trump knows (or learns) that Hunter Biden worked for a Ukrainian company; ergo the younger Biden must be corrupt;  Ukraine needs military assistance; Trump holds back  the assistance until Zelensky agrees to launch a public inquiry into corruption by the elder and younger Bidens; the whistle blower toots that the president is using government money; to extort personal political gain; Congress reacts; Trump doubles down; Ukraine and Zelensky is dragged into the mess and is further destabilised and Orban grabs the chance to protect Ukraine’s ethnic Hungarians.

Trump loves a strong man. Trump listens to strong men who get things done because they are unfettered by democratic chains. What he fails to understand isthat these ruthless populists have a slogan similar to his: Hungary first, Russia First, North Korea first, Turkey first… They care nothing about the American president or the American people.

 

* Tom Arms is membership secretary for Tooting Lib Dems. He also broadcasts on foreign affairs for US Radio, regularly contributes to Lib Dem Voice, lectures and is working on a book on Anglo—American relations which is due to be published next year.

Read more by or more about .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

8 Comments

  • Richard Underhill 25th Oct '19 - 9:38am

    Trump’s first wife was responsible for some success, plus an inheritance from his father.

  • Richard Underhill 25th Oct '19 - 9:44am

    Expats: Typo? Royles Royce?

  • nigel hunter 25th Oct '19 - 10:38am

    Zakaparttia read the czchek’s of Hitlers time. Trumps love of strong men will lead him into trouble if he is not curbed. Other strong men do not like other strong men standing in their way.His ‘wanting to be loved’ tendencies could be his downfall.Do we want WW3 cos of a spoilt child? Latest, A court case against Muller and Russia he aims to win at all costs.Dangerous.

  • Perhaps the US should reintroduced an improved version of Sedition Act that also applies to the Executive branch after this presidency. Had a Sedition Act existed, Trump would have already been impeached and probably removed as well. Because what Trump is doing is textbook sedition.

  • The worst thing is that no matter what he does, his hardcore base a.k.a the deplorables (yes, the unconvenient truth is that term is correctly used) still support him. They have been thoroughly brainwashed by Fox News. Democrats should ignore them and instead focus on first, rallying their own base, and second, winning back and independents and the former Blue Wall, but getting the Democrat base to turn out and vote must be prioritized first and foremost.

  • John Marriott 25th Oct '19 - 2:34pm

    One of the most damning verdicts on Donald Trump came recently from former US Defence Chief, General James Mattis. Referring to the Commander in Chief’s bellicose language recently and alluding to the ‘medical condition’ that helped him avoid the Vietnam draft, Mattis said; “He earned his spurs from a doctor”. I gather that arch hawk and former US Ambassador, John Bolton, also avoided the same draft on ‘medical’ grounds. Then Trump had the gaul to say that he didn’t consider the late Senator John McCain a war hero “because he got caught”. Hypocrisy doesn’t do it justice, does it? I suppose it’s a case of “do as I say” and not of “do as I do”.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarDavid Raw 17th Nov - 7:58pm
    @ David Allen Do you mean the former man leader of the Liberal Democrats, Sir Vincent Cable, David ?
  • User AvatarDavid Allen 17th Nov - 6:37pm
    "The petition states “Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn are running scared of debating the woman leader of the strongest party of Remain.”" No need to...
  • User AvatarJohn King 17th Nov - 5:59pm
    Should Sal Brinton have said "the two persons who want to deliver Brexit", then? Two men is just normal speech, no need to read anything...
  • User AvatarPaul Pettinger 17th Nov - 5:58pm
    @Joseph Bourke, you’ve followed closely what the Resolution Foundation have said, but not Ed Davey, who is advocating an even more fiscally conservative approach (aspiring...
  • User AvatarSteve Trevethan 17th Nov - 5:53pm
    On national involvement with railways. Yes, comparisons are invaluable for enabling progress. Might it be more efficient to look sideways as well as backwards? In...
  • User AvatarThomas 17th Nov - 5:30pm
    At the very least, the privatization of prisons and probation must be reversed completely and totally. For utilities like electricity and telecommunication, I would prefer...