Opinion: Coalition questions are premature

Have the media gone collectively insane?

Take this, from the BBC:

A keynote speech by Lib Dem leader Sir Menzies Campbell has been overshadowed by speculation over his strategy in the event of a future hung Parliament.
In his speech to the party’s spring conference he set out “five tests” for a Gordon Brown-led government.

A party official suggested it was the first indication Sir Menzies would be interested in forming a coalition if the Lib Dems held the balance of power.

Ed Davey, Sir Menzies’ chief of staff, said the briefing was “unauthorised”.

“The tests Ming set for Brown were about his likely government in a few months’ time and not about some post-election situation,” he said.

The very idea that a spring conference speech two years out from a General Election would be used to lay out a negotiation position for a future coalition government defies belief. If Menzies Campbell even has a strategy for forming a coalition government, he wouldn’t announce it out of the blue in a spring conference speech. Menzies Campbell and his team knows that talk of coalitions is electoral suicide. “Vote Lib Dem, get Labour” is every bit as damaging as “Vote Lib Dem, get Conservative” to our chances across the country.

He wasn’t talking about coalitions, he wouldn’t talk about coalitions – it’s a story whipped up by a misguided and quite possibly misquoted “senior press officer“, and a mischevious press who have missed having a good Lib Dem kicking conference story.

Read more by or more about .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

3 Comments

  • Alan_Beddow 4th Mar '07 - 10:39pm

    I agree, this was throwing down a gauntlet to Brown and I did not see this an an overture at all. Earlier in his speech he clearly stated that Brown was involved in the very decisions Ming was challenging in his 5 tests.

    This is simply media spin.

  • Labour Lily 4th Mar '07 - 11:15pm

    “Vote Lib Dem, get Labour” is … damaging

    Too true. The thought of being associated with you lot would put a lot of voters off.

  • After Ming Campbell’s speech today ask people on the doorstep this question during the elections in May:

    Who do you think would be better to lead this country?

    The insubstantial, shallow PR man from Eton who was an economic adviser to the Tory Government on Black Wednesday and followed Tony Blair, Gordon Brown, Iain Dincan Smith and Michael Howard in voting for war in Iraq?

    Or the former Olympic Athlete and QC who was one of those who lead the opposition to the war in Iraq – who even as he was undergoing treatment for cancer came to the House of Commons to vote with every other Lib Dem MP against the war?

    erm? case solved.

    I think the Lib Dems have got a gem,

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • Tom Arms
    I meant to say that the UK supplies the nuclear warheads for its deterrent....
  • Tom Arms
    There are some areas where the US is likely to dominate for a very long time. Space is an obvious one. Ukraine would be up the proverbial creek without America'...
  • Ruth Bright
    @Paul is surely right, do we have age breakdowns for stats on members and active supporters?...
  • Tom Bailey
    Alex Macfie says: "He [Farage], has just seized on one case of supposed “anti-white bias” by the police (the only one available)" So the 3 decades of Brit...
  • Alex Macfie
    @Simon Robinson &c: Please stop pretending Nigel Farage is acting in good faith. He has just seized on one case of supposed "anti-white bias" by the police ...