Tag Archives: david torrance

Salmond’s bizarre public dig at critical commentator Torrance shows Scotland had a lucky escape

A couple of weeks ago, Alex Salmond picked a fight with the BBC’s Nick Robinson. Cue a mob descending on the BBC’s shiny new Pacific Quay HQ in Glasgow demanding that the journalist be sacked. In fact, much as it pains me to admit it, Robinson was actually in the right on that occasion. Salmond hadn’t answered a question he’d asked. He’d spent several minutes giving  a rambling answer about the first part of his question before lambasting the BBC for publishing a story that the Royal Bank of Scotland would move its HQ from Scotland in the event of a Yes vote. It was quite bizarre to see hundreds of people demand that a news station takes the Government line. Where else would you see that?

Yesterday, political commentator David Torrance, who is probably one of the most fair minded people around, wrote a pretty critical but in my view accurate article about Salmond for the Herald. Torrance had written a well-received biography of the First Minister some years ago. This is what he had to say yesterday:

But then blatant hypocrisy never seemed to bother Mr Salmond. The Liberal Democrats, another party which wasn’t spared his tribal warfare, were pilloried for reneging on their no-tuition-fees promise after the 2010 General Election, yet three years previously Mr Salmond had ditched a manifesto pledge to eradicate all student debt, even though it had arguably captured a significant chunk of the student vote.

And in spite of lofty rhetoric about being “positive”, divide and rule was a hallmark of his style, as was phoney outrage.

Anyone not perceived as a threat was treated with charm and thoughtfulness, but for those who fell outside that category condescension, pettiness and often downright rudeness were the order of the day.

I can think of no other politician who behaved as badly as often and, more or less, got away with it.

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged , and | 24 Comments

Danny Alexander and David Torrance discuss the Independence Referendum

imageIt is an hour and six minutes of your life you won’t get back, but it is actually worth listening to this conversation between Danny Alexander and political commentator David Torrance as part of Dundee University’s Five Million Questions project.

David has just written a book on Federalism so it was obvious he was going to be quizzing Danny on that subject.

It’s also available on You Tube here. Enjoy. It’s much better than a lot of the hot air around the independence referendum.

Posted in LibLink | Also tagged , , , and | Leave a comment
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User Avatarexpats 21st Feb - 12:50pm
    Why argue? They are dyed in the wool Trump supporting evangelical Christains and you aren't; what possible use to either of you was 'spending days...
  • User AvatarDan M-B 21st Feb - 12:44pm
    "dropping defectors into unwinnable seats where they had no personal vote and throwing so much focus and resources in their direction was stupid;" This. Have...
  • User AvatarPeter Hirst 21st Feb - 12:22pm
    Graham, it's all a question of what you focus on. Jesus lived in by our standards a barbaric age. It is all to his credit...
  • User AvatarChristopher Curtis 21st Feb - 12:14pm
    I think you are being too generous to the Johnson regime. Your summary is much more coherent than the government. There is no master plan,...
  • User AvatarFrank West 21st Feb - 12:10pm
    Given the complexities of getting the better of the welfare system and the way it is often gamed then I don't think there is a...
  • User AvatarNigel Jones 21st Feb - 12:07pm
    There has never been any doubt in my mind that a majority of people fear major 'uncontrolled' immigration. Currently 70% want immigration reduced, but that...