Tag Archives: equal votes lobby

Alistair Carmichael MP writes…Electoral reform can happen, but it will take concerted action

When I joined the Liberal Party in the 1980s, I was optimistic that the UK would replace its unrepresentative voting system in the not too distant future. Fast forward to 2021 and we remain stuck with First Past the Post and, at first glance, little reason for optimism.

The current set-up has never been ideal for the UK or indeed any modern democratic society. First Past the Post results in governments elected by a minority of voters, with policies supported by a minority of the electorate being imposed on the majority. This leaves far too many people feeling excluded and unrepresented. With a distorted link between voters and MPs, how can the UK call itself a representative democracy>

The answer, as we know, is Proportional Representation (PR). Replacing First Past the Post with a fair alternative will make our democracy truly representative. Pluralism is a key tenet of democracy. As a liberal and a democrat, I recognise the need for a voting system that allows multi-party politics to show itself rather than be hidden by the illusion of First Past the Post. Proportional Representation provides a framework for multi-party politics to flourish and voters to be represented.

We have all heard the tiresome arguments against PR, all the more worn-out considering that the UK is now the only democracy in Europe to use the outdated First Past the Post system for its main elections. The myth that reform would end the constituency link is nonsensical, considering the range of systems that can preserve and even strengthen it by improving voter choice both at the ballot box and in between elections. Those resistant to change also argue that a switch to PR would be a risky, unnecessary experiment. Considering that Proportional Representation is used in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, and is well established across Europe, this doesn’t stand up to scrutiny.

All major opposition parties apart from Labour support Proportional Representation for UK-wide elections and groups like Make Votes Matter are pushing the debate in the right direction. The establishment of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Electoral Reform is the latest boost in the campaign, ensuring a strong coordinated voice in parliament to champion the need for change.

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged , , and | 52 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • George Thomas
    My wish is that Andy Burnham says that there aren't any savings to be made on welfare spend, there will be changes which generate flexibility but every penny sa...
  • John Reed
    An excellent overview, thank you Vince. The larger developers do seem to have considerable power to control the housing market. They have land banks, large cash...
  • John Reed
    An excellent overview, thank you Vince. The larger developers do seem to have considerable power to control...
  • Alex Macfie
    AI can't even judge whether text is AI generated — even deciding something is AI because it uses proper punctuation. My em-dashes are human generated. ——�...
  • Alex Macfie
    AI is indeed massively over-hyped, as @John C and @cim have pointed out. It is a bubble and it will burst, and once the dust has settled AI (or machine learning...