Tag Archives: james mackenzie

Is the Basic Income Guarantee an idea whose time has come?

Way back when I was first involved in politics, the ideas that everyone should have a basic income and that tax and national insurance should be integrated were mainstream SDP/Liberal Alliance ideas.

The Greens have in recent years been the only party to advocate such a change but during the General Election, Natalie Bennett was unable to convince people that it was affordable.

This week, think-tank Reform Scotland has come up with a costed scheme to give every adult a basic income of £100 per week and every child £50. The authors, Liberal Democrat Siobhan Mathers and Scottish Green candidate James Mackenzie, acknowledge that there would be a cost, around £2 billion in Scotland, £12 billion across the whole UK and that personal taxation rates would have to rise by about 8%, but that nobody earning under £26,000 a year would be worse off. However, with 2 children, a £100k household would be over £1200 a year better off

It’s certainly radical, with those on lowest incomes gaining and those on £100,000 without children being around £2,200 a year worse off, but isn’t that what a progressive tax system is supposed to do? There is a question, though, around whether a £100k household needs to be mae £1200 a year better off courtesy of the state.

The report argues that there are seven big advantages of such a scheme:

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged , , , , , and | 25 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarLiz Green 29th May - 11:22am
    David Raw, the site is owned by a private company registered in the Isle of Man. They bought it off Thames Water about 10 years...
  • User AvatarMatt (Bristol) 29th May - 11:17am
    George, thank you. As an avowed social democrat, I'd be interested in your thoughts on a philosophical issue raised by the Cummings farrago: As you...
  • User AvatarJohn McHugo 29th May - 11:04am
    Alice, thanks. I will follow the link.
  • User AvatarPaul Walter 29th May - 11:03am
    Tony, To answer your question: "In order to increase our diversity we need a better functioning complaints system?" The answer is "yes". As for you...
  • User AvatarGwyn Williams 29th May - 11:00am
    Following on for @Peter Black’s comment. Who are the members of this panel? How are they appointed? What was the vetting process?
  • User AvatarToby Keynes 29th May - 10:49am
    For anyone who's missed this, latest government guidance is: "Ask Yourself - What Would Dominic Do?"