Tag Archives: social workers

A “mending” not a “minding” service

With so much media and political attention on social care there is a danger that social work, which is a very undervalued resource, may be further marginalised. This article attempts to demonstrate that social work and social workers are vital to a “mending” rather than a “minding” service.

In the late 1960s and early 1970s social work was regarded as a valuable resource and social workers seen as “agents of change”. Since then, social workers have been increasingly regarded as “gate keepers” assessing the eligibility for practical help and rationing of services.

The Seebohm Report which led to the establishment of Social Service Departments in 1971 recognised the value of social work. It did not, however, create the “one door to knock on”, it promised, as a multi-disciplinary / inter-agency response is often required. This was subsequently recognised with the establishment of Area Child Protection Committees (post Maria Caldwell), Mental Health procedures, “Community Mental Handicap Teams”, and Youth Justice Teams etc.

The undoing of much of the public sector was down to the Thatcher years and more particularly, in respect of Health and Social Services, to Sir Roy Griffiths and his mistaken belief that people were motivated by and could be controlled by money. This led to the introduction of the contract culture with the purchaser / provider split which Sir Roy thought would create a level playing field to facilitate a mixed economy of care thereby forcing quality up and prices down. It has subsequently been proven to have had the opposite effect and led to over-prescription taking away the ability of carers to react in situ to changing need. It led to greater fragmentation with different components of a “package of care” bought from different providers.

Social Workers were deployed on the “purchasing side”, assessing the need for specific services (often responding to “presenting problems” rather than the “underlying problem”) which led to several social services departments providing “minding” rather than “mending” services with an ever-increasing workload of dependent people.

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged | 4 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • David Warren
    David has a big task rebuilding support for our party in Wales after we finished 6th in the recent Senned elections. Even in 1951 the nadir of UK Liberalism ...
  • David Warren
    @Chloe, I agree! The Democrats in Congress need to pursue a positive legislative agenda and invite Trump to use his veto if he dares. As for AOC as a nominee...
  • Jana
    I work with a number of neurodivergent young people and have helped produce good practice guides for employers on providing reasonable adjustments to all employ...
  • Jana
    Congratulations. Now please go on the front foot and demand that significant extra powers be transferred to the Senedd - not just control of policing and the Cr...
  • Jana
    “….the state doesn’t owe anybody a living.” I disagree with this - the state has an obligation to those veterans who were injured serving their count...