What is your big budget ask?

Just imagine your phone rings. You pick up and the voice on the line says: Hello, Philip Hammond here. I’m just looking for some ideas for my Budget. What is the one thing you want me to do?”

How would you respond? What is the one thing you want to see?

I know we could all rattle off about two dozen things, but you only have one. Be disciplined. When I asked on Twitter last night, the first person said what I was going to say:

My alternative would be funding to extend Child and Adolescent Mental Health services to 25. Going through this transition is pure hell. You have kids who have lost half their secondary education to mental ill health due to waits in getting seen and then they end up going from well-supported and organised CAMHS services to next to nothing at a time of other huge transitions in their lives at 18.

A smattering of the eclectic responses:

This is particularly topical:

And finally, this is the Lib Dems. There’s always one.

What would you like to see on Phil’s Spreadsheet?

* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings

Read more by .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • Reverse all the cuts to benefits made since 2015 and restore the real value of out-work benefits to their 2009 levels and scrapping the bedroom tax.

    If I was allowed a second, introduce a voluntary Job Guarantee scheme for those unemployed or on ESA for more than 1 year, which provide jobs tailored to the needs of the person and their future well-being.

  • @ Michael BG Spot on, Michael, but you and I know it’s not in their DNA. There’s a strong Benthamite punishment element in their thinking about ‘the undeserving poor’.

  • I’m with Lisajane Ellis, “Borrow to invest”…No matter what we want/need it has to be paid for,,,
    Although a book entitled “What to feed your free Unicorn” is a good second choice…

  • Raise all benefits except Pensions/Pension Credit, drop all the compulsory “Interviews, Training ” etc. Cut staff in “Job Centres” by half, scrap Signing On.
    I reckon these measures would mostly pay for themselves by savings on Wages & Rents for swanky Offices first & later by rises in Tax Revenues. The War on Benefits is a major factor in holding Wages down in a time of Low Unemployment.

  • @ Paul Barker “Raise all benefits except Pensions/Pension Credit”.

    Why ?

  • What’s the argument for corporation tax? Surely if you want to tax those at the top then do more with a dividend tax? Don’t see a point in corporation tax when it hits SMEs the hardest while they’re the backbone for our economy. Would be in favour of scrapping corporation tax, higher dividend tax, couple capital gains tax with income tax, and bring national living wage up to a proper one, one that you can actually live off of.

    Bit disappointed in Vince that he’s not pushed for something that’d encourage business/SMEs. Feels more New Labour than actual liberal, pro-business and pro-worker policies.

  • Glenn Andrews 22nd Nov '17 - 3:24pm

    Replace the million council houses lost……. with council houses.

  • Red Liberal 22nd Nov '17 - 3:42pm

    Stop Brexit. That’s the only fiscal policy that makes unquestionable sense at the moment.

  • Not even a mouse of a budget – It’s a dead mouse of a budget.

  • Peter Hirst 23rd Nov '17 - 5:09pm

    Mine would be a 50% discount to bring all homes up to a minimum environmental standard regarding insulation, heating and power use.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • User AvatarJoeB 17th Oct - 12:41am
    I never failed to be impressed by the sheer energy of Merlene and hats off for taking a crack at breaching the edifice that is...
  • User AvatarJoeB 17th Oct - 12:09am
    A wag once commented "It is difficult to make predictions, especially about the future." In 1798 Thomas Malthus predicted that population growth would bring famine...
  • User AvatarLorenzo Cherin 16th Oct - 10:10pm
    Democracy needs more consultation and representation of mainstream opinion.
  • User Avatarsuzanne Fletcher 16th Oct - 10:08pm
    Well yes, Mark, but I was thinking of all the work one person had to do as well. radical idea - post them all on...
  • User AvatarMark Valladares 16th Oct - 9:54pm
    Suzanne, I entirely see your point, but can see an advantage to having them all in one place, especially for non-Liberal Democrat readers and those...
  • User Avatarsuzanne Fletcher 16th Oct - 8:53pm
    Dear Mark, but if the press office sent to people who asked for them ( and I presume someone at HQ is clever enough to...