Why hasn’t David Cameron sacked Bill Aitken?

At the start of the week Caron Lindsay blogged about the case of Conservative MSP Bill Aitken:

The Tories are usually very supportive of victims of crime … Unfortunately, their sympathy for victims doesn’t seem to extend to the crime of rape. Shadow Tory minister for Community Safety in the Scottish Parliament Bill Aitken has apparently asked the Sunday Herald whether a victim of an horrendous rape in Glasgow earlier this week was a prostitute. This woman was dragged down a lane by 3 men and raped. This was the latest in a series of similar assaults in Glasgow.

As the Sunday Herald reported of Bill Aitken,

Aitken has been a District Court Judge, Justice of the Peace and is a Deputy Lord Lieutenant of Glasgow. He is also convenor of the Scottish Parliament’s justice committee – which helps formulates rape laws.

Police officers and women’s organisations reacted with outrage to his claims.

Detectives from Strathclyde Police are still hunting for three men of Middle Eastern appearance who dragged the 38-year-old woman off Renfield Street in the city centre and raped her in a lane as she headed home after a night out with friends just after midnight on Thursday. It is the fourth city-centre sex attack since Christmas. Police believe different gangs are responsible.

Asked to comment on the series of so-called “lane rapes”, Aitken said: “I really think we need to know a bit more about these. They are not always as they seem to be, put it that way.”…

Aitken also said a lot of rape allegations are falsely made by drunk women – but had no research to back this up…

When challenged on his comments by the Sunday Herald, Aitken denied making them until he read a transcript of the conversation.

Pressure has built during the week with the New Statesman getting hold of a leaked copy of that Bill Aitken transcript, which includes comments from him such as:

“Well, you always know there’s a lot more to these city-centre rapes than meet the eye, of course. But this does sound concerning.”

“Well, what is particularly noteworthy in this case is it’s three Asian people they are looking for. Now, Renfrew Lane is known as a place where things happen, put it that way.”

“How do you tell a Middle Eastern from an Asian?”

It has now been announced that Bill Aitken will retire at the next Scottish Parliament elections, but without an apology from him and with no disciplinary action in the interim from the Conservative Party. That falls far short of the sort of reaction his comments deserve.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in News and Scotland.


  • Repulsive

  • David Le Grice 18th Feb '11 - 7:31pm

    Surly that should be ‘Why hasn’t Annabelle Goldie sacked Bill Aitken?’

    It would be undemocratic if Westminster politicians held power over MSPs.

  • This vile creature currently sits on the violence against women committee in the Scots parliament in his capacity as justice convenor. Shame!

  • I’m afraid every now and again the mask slips and we get to see that many are still old fashioned hang ’em flog ’em bigotted Tories with the type of viewpoint that will never be acceptable to those of us that actually belong to the human race.

    God alone knows how the poor victim must feel, to suffer that and then to have such insinuations made. I almost hope this blows over so she doesn’t have to face his comments again.

  • Repulsive indeed, but as David Le Grice has said, it is Ms Goldie who should sack him.
    Also, in the interests of accuracy, Aitken has apologised and it was announced last year that he would not stand again for election.

  • Bill Aitken and now this one? This is the kind of people that the LibDems are propping up in government.


  • Mark – Bill Aitken had already announced he was standing down in May, so it’s not even connected to this – latest – ill-thought outburst (he has a track record of this.)

    Technically these appointments are in the gift of Annabel Goldie, who is generally a decent person and I’m pretty sure would be unhappy about the comments. However, I suspect that, because it’s not been picked up by the London press, they think they can get away with it.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Trevor Andrews
    I am sorry to hear of your problems in Shropshire, although I suspect your not alone in having these problems. I tried many times to get a part time “Director...
  • john oundle
    Simon R 'But are we sure that simply admitting these people to the UK and providing them all with shelter and the means to build lives here is actually a gen...
  • nigel hunter
    We can equally campaign to fully replace the Overseas Aid budget to help the countries that the refugees come from....
  • TonyH
    Yes I have to agree with the criticism here of the way some quotes are being mis-represented. I love Andy's passion for the campaign, but I think using the "her...
  • Alexander
    By that logic, as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, Boris Johnson is the most credible person in the country. Maybe take into account her actual behaviour a...