Angry doesn’t even come close.
“Contempt for this gutless, sickening Government decision“.
“The week Labour lost its last principles“.
These are just some reactions to a Government announcement today on settlement rights for Gurkhas who retired before 1997.
So what’s the story and background?
Gurkhas have served all across the world in the defence of our country for nearly 200 years. Over 45,000 died in the two World Wars as part of the British Army, and they are still fighting in the British Army today.
But until quite recently, the Gurkhas had no right to citizenship in this country after completing their service in the Army. This rule applied to no other nationality serving in the British Army: just the Gurkhas.
The Lib Dems took up this cause, and in 2004, the Government changed the rules following a major campaign. The change allowed Gurkhas who retired after 1997 (when the regiment moved its main base from Hong Kong to the UK) to stay in this country, but no such right was given to those who retired before 1997. Since that time, Gurkhas and campaigners have been fighting for the same rights for all ex-Gurkha’s irrespective of their retirement date.
A High Court ruling in September 2008 judged that the Government’s policy was unlawful and unfair, and insisted the Government change their policy. In response today, the Government have made a fresh announcement which extends to right to settlement to a few more Gurkhas, but falls well short of full justice.
To qualify for citizenship under these rules, most Gurkhas who retired before 1997 would have needed to have served 20 years. The normal period of service for a non-officer Gurkha was 15 years. This is a rank based decision, and leaves many thousands of loyal soldiers who fought for this country out it the cold. I mean that literally – without citizenship, there is no right to work or benefits and many Gurkhas are homeless in this country, replying on the generosity of others for somewhere to sleep, something to eat.
Immigration Minister Phil Woolas said: “This guidance honours the service, commitment and gallantry of those who served with the Gurkhas brigade”. It does no such thing – the majority of those who retired before 1997 in the Gurkhas will get no help whatsoever for this ruling.
The Campaign for Gurkha Justice led by Joanna Lumley is now working with renewed determination. To keep in touch with the campaign and add your support, visit www.gurkhajustice.org.uk and sign up.
In breaking news, Lib Dem Leader Nick Clegg has decided to use the Opposition Day debate in Parliament on Wednesday 29th April to call (again) for a fair deal for Gurkhas. Governments just don’t lose Opposition Day votes. If they lose this one, it would be a huge wake-up call to the Government.
On Wednesday, there will also be a Gurkha Justice rally and protest against the Government’s decision, starting at noon in Old Palace Yard, Westminster – all welcome.
However you can help:
– from writing to your MP [http://www.theyworkforyou.com/] asking them to support the Gurkha Justice motion on Opposition Day
– signing up to the Gurkha Justice [http://www.gurkhajustice.org.uk/] web site
– joining us on Wednesday outside Parliament
…the Gurkhas need your help. They have never let us down: it’s time to repay our debt.
Tim Prater is a Lib Dem councillor in Shepway and is one of the brains behind Prater Raines’ popular range of party websites.
Follow @libdemvoice.org on Bluesky
Like us on Facebook
Subscribe to our feed
Sign-up for our daily email digest
We have no idea what history will say about Keir Starmer and it may not be right anyway
Is Kier Starmer the new John Major?
A bargain at 23 guineas?
20C night
Lessons from 1936 and 2026 for the Liberal Democrats (LDN#211)
Jana
Matt (Bristol)
FS People
Chris Cory
Paul Reynolds
3 Comments
The Gurkhas for Justice Campaign has been led from the front by Nick Clegg and Joanna Lumley, in demanding a result for all these brave and loyal soldiers.
Nick Clegg has unreservedly condemned the ineptitude of the Government, not to over rule the High Court,in allowing the full equal numbers of pre-1997 serving Gurkhas, in the British Army, into the UK and to recognise their settlement rights.
All former Gurkhas, should now be given full entitlement to British citizenship and rights to abode and moreover,given seats and places of honour,at every possible occasion.
Field Marshall Bernard Montgomery of Alamein,wrote in `The Times’ 15/6/1970,with Gen.Slim et al,that in that year,£1M should be made available by Government,to safeguard the future of life for the Gurkhas, in the UK.
This famous General fully understood the bravery and courage of the Gurkhas,whom defended British liberty,second to none,whom he served with and knew well,in WW2.
There is an inherent human and settlement rights Liberal policy principle at stake, that dwarfs any counter of the Government claims,that deny the Gurkha equality, in full British rights,by the pre-1997 Gurkha servicemen.
The Gurkhas served in the British Army as loyally,in many campaigns,across the World and all equally were servants of the Queen and deserve the same merit,as any contemporary service personnel would do,today.
It is time for full recognition of the service to the British people made by the Gurkhas in WW1 and WW2,when they suffered 43,000 casualties and were awarded 26 VC`s.
What price can any Government place on all those Gurkhas,whom stood firm,when it mattered most, for British liberty?
It is time for a Government apology to the Gurkhas and full recognition of their overdue settlement rights,in the UK, to be honoured.
But Jo Lumley gets all the publicity…
Please allow the Gurkas who wish to stay in the U.K. the right to do so. They have earned their place here by their loyalty and many with their lives.
If imigrants who are hostile to our way of life can stay why not our friends ?
FA Barker.