A little part of who I am is struggling to survive

 

I feel as if a little part of who I am is struggling to survive. A little part that has been nurtured and has grown since, as a teenager, I marvelled at the liberal values and writings of Robert Kennedy and Dr Martin Luther King.

It’s the part that grew up regarding US history as testament that a people can use lessons of a divided past to create a society that offers opportunity for all.

And it’s the same part of me that’s always been so proud that I have family amongst those tired and huddled masses who were welcomed with open arms to a nation founded on that simple, yet beautiful, declaration:

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal.”

That’s the promise of the United States. A promise to which so many have trusted their futures, and their dreams. But it’s a promise that today seems under threat.

Perhaps not all are equally welcome.

The cruel irony is that the threat comes from one whose own forebears trusted their future to that promise. Whose mother left the Hebrides to live the epitome of the American dream.

Last year I visited the United States three times. I love the place. And the people. Its culture, its literature and its politics. Today I doubt I will visit again, for at least four years.

That’s not a stand I take easily. I have friends I would love to see. Places I may not get another chance to visit. But looking at the immediate impact of Trump’s Presidency I am not sure that I want to experience it up close.

What is the moral imperative now guiding America?

Of course there are aspects of life and politics in the US with which I have always differed, often argued, with American friends about. I prefer our health care system, even with all its problems. I feel much more secure in our stricter anti-gun culture. I often find their politics a little more to the right than my own instincts.

But those differences and the debates they provoke are what is part of what makes democracy so wonderful, and our relationship so special. Through debate and creative discussion you find the way ahead. Only by listening to others can you see the potential flaws in your own ideas and strategies, and find improvement.

On the last of those three visits last year I travelled to Virginia to observe, and help where I could, the campaign to elect Hillary Clinton 45th President. At no time did I regard the former Senator and Secretary of State as the least worst option, particularly for those of us living firth of the US, but dependent on a strong cohesive administration to bolster world security.

No. I saw Hillary as the best, most liberal, most reforming option.

Neither did I see Donald Trump as some dangerous demagogue, or a threat to the established order. I thought he simply was not qualified for the job. When the shock of his victory was met by reassurance from many of those on the right of British politics that it wasn’t really that bad.  Or pleas to give him a chance to prove his worth. I hoped they were right. Now I fear there can be no doubt they were mistaken.

When a British Prime Minister instructs her Foreign and Home Secretaries to make representations to the US about policy, you cannot help but feel you are in uncharted territory. It may yet, of course, be fine. Reason may prevail. These first few days of walls, deportations and bans may be some exaggerated muscle-flexing exercise. Let’s hope so.

But even though I find the situation we now face challenges so much of what I thought America is, that little part of me is refusing to give in. Refusing to accept that this really is America. It’s certainly not the American that the majority of the people voted for.

And then at the 11th hour the wisdom of the founding fathers, the same men who wrote that most beautiful of declarations, came to the rescue. Their system of checks and balances so cherished by Americans allowed the judiciary to block the President’s executive order. But it may be only temporary respite.

In all sections of US society there are citizens, judges and senators like Elizabeth Warren standing up against, what they see as an assault on Americanism. But they need to know they have our support. Never before, perhaps, has the special relationship mattered so much to Americans. Our Prime Minister tells us she can be frank with the President if necessary. She has asked her ministers to speak to their counterparts in Washington. It’s a start.

Perhaps that little part of my ideals that is struggling will survive yet.

* Christine Jardine is MP for Edinburgh West and spokesperson for Women & Equalities and Scotland

Read more by or more about .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

7 Comments

  • Eddie Sammon 30th Jan '17 - 8:18pm

    We need a pro-democracy foreign policy, but some people like Trump are testing democracy to the limits, so we should toughen up our stance.

    However, where liberals should disagree with others is to place Trump in a uniquely bad category – there are other deeply authoritarian leaders around the world and we should be firm with them too because if we don’t then we risk pandering to what is basically neo-communism, policies espoused by the likes of Jeremy Corbyn who campaign strongly for rights when it comes to people like Trump, but are soft with the likes of Iran and Russia.

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts and feelings.

  • I’ve never entirely understood the sentimentality about America. It’s a fun place to visit, but really its values have always seemed a bit of a triumph of marketing over actuality. Having said that, if we can maintain good relations with an in truth very closed nation like Japan (look up its immigration and refugee laws), then we can weather 4 years of Trump without the over amped hysteria.

  • nigel hunter 30th Jan '17 - 10:42pm

    He says he wants to keep the killers out to keep his people safe. Correct me if I am wrong but in the past I understand that most Americans in the USA are killed by Americans, look at the killings on the Campus.

  • I was in US when New Orleans was flooded and I saw two sides of it, the selfless humanitarian side, but also the darker Neocon side who suggested N.O. and realisticallly some of its people should be abandoned as it was uneconomic to do otherwise. Its the latter group who now call the shots.

  • Lorenzo Cherin 31st Jan '17 - 12:02am

    Christine

    Terrific article, really heartfelt.

    As the husband of a wife who is from their originally, and with current family there , I share your feeling for the country.

    You are right to say the special relationship needs nurturing not denigrating.

    Thus you are wrong , in my view to feel you shall not go there for years, Go and build on those contacts and lets all, who care , do so in any way we can, to keep our relationship special, and our futures more Liberal.

  • Eddie Sammon:

    You are quite right to say that Trump is not uniquely bad – compared to many others he is not even especially bad; and we look hysterical if we say he is.

    Nevertheless, he is uniquely damaging to us because of the importance of our alliance with the US. However terrible, say, Mugabe, is, his impact is limited outside of Zimbabwe. Trump affects the whole world and on this issue he specifically affects British citizens. And that fact shows up the appalling mess the current government has inflicted on our foreign policy.

  • Sue Sutherland 31st Jan '17 - 4:35pm

    No he’s not uniquely bad but he is supposed to be leader of the free world, he has enormous power and he is uncontrollable. In addition he seems to be following Hitler’s path away from democracy. If this carries on the whole world is threatened, so the whole world has to show that we won’t be cowed and that he can’t get away with everything he wants to.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • Caron LindsayCaron Lindsay
    Beat headline in the history of the world. In other news, what the hell am I doing up at 2:08 am watching a football match. I did not expect this....
  • Neil Hickman
    I confess my main feeling about the current World Cup is a burning desire for the USA to lose, preferably extremely humiliatingly, to a team which is brown and/...
  • expats
    Putin first attacked Ukraine in 2014; four years after his Feb 2022 attack he has still not succeeded in defeating that single nation... The idea that he poses...
  • Jana
    Sorry, meant to say ‘not able to move offshore’....
  • Jana
    I disagree with raising income tax, NI or VAT. We need to be taxing those assets that rich people are able to move offshore - let’s start by taxing the owner...