This afternoon, MPs who really shouldn’t have been in the House of Commons, either through very advanced pregnancy or serious illness, had to go in and vote on that Brexit amendment.
One of them was our Jo Swinson, who is two days past her due date with her second baby. It is entirely unsurprising that she made it in to vote. Anyone who knows how committed and determined she is will know that unless she was in fairly advanced labour, she would made it. She still deserves respect for doing so. Most women have stopped going into the office by due date + 2.
In the 19th year of the 21st century, it is ridiculous that there is no procedure in place to enable MPs to cast their votes by proxy if they are indisposed for whatever reason. The House voted for it some weeks ago, and it is not difficult to set up. I wonder if the Government would have found a greater sense of urgency to do this if the MPs in question had been on the Conservative side.
Jo tweeted about her day and, of course, she had something for us to do too.
My thanks to MPs from across different parties in the House of Commons for their goodwill and best wishes as I voted, at 40 weeks pregnant, in today's close division on giving Parliament a meaningful vote on Brexit (govt maj 16 votes, sadly my side lost). However… (1/3)
— Jo Swinson (@joswinson) June 20, 2018
This is no way to run a Parliament in a modern democracy. Deciding matters of state, or which parts of the country will have their voices heard, should not be determined by which MPs can be discharged from hospital or happen to be in childbirth. We need proxy voting. (2/3)
— Jo Swinson (@joswinson) June 20, 2018
And to everyone saying nice things about me coming in to vote on Brexit while 9 months pregnant….
I've done what I could this week, can you do yours by joining the People's March on Saturday to fight for a People's Vote and an #ExitfromBrexit? (3/3)https://t.co/hxldKHwzYI
— Jo Swinson (@joswinson) June 20, 2018
To be fair, I really should commend Baby Hames for staying put to let Jo vote. The wee one will be joining the rest of the family soon and we at LDV wish them all the very best as they get to know each other.
* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings
Follow @libdemvoice.org on Bluesky
Like us on Facebook
Subscribe to our feed
Sign-up for our daily email digest
Lochee Park - 1973 #dundeewestend
Urgent action needed on Welsh rivers
Llandow, 1950: The worst air disaster the world had seen
Electoral Calculus's local election predictions
Are memories like a row of telegraph poles?
David Murray
tom arms
Simon R
Alan Jelfs
3 Comments
Whilst proxy voting would without doubt improve access to parliamentary voting, there are downsides.
A key part of parliamentary democracy is the debate that precedes votes which voting members are expected to participate in (which can just mean be present and listen)
Of course members can attend and not listen/play on their phones/fall asleep/vote tribally at the instruction of the whips, but the principle of being exposed to debate from both sides before making up your mind and casting your vote is a powerful one. This might sound highly paternalistic that a member of parliament doesn’t know how they want to vote and must be mentally nursed through it in the debating chamber (Naz Shah’s experience yesterday being a case in point), but on the flip side it’s highly arrogant for a member of parliament to think they know it all already and don’t need to listen to opposing views before deciding. The issues of today are extremely nuanced and not as black and white as our simplistic and partisan media portray them as. Most of us have the ability to change our minds if exposed to something we hadn’t heard of or considered before.
I have similar views about the widespread use of postal voting (different to proxy voting I know, but have similar problems of principle), which means voters are not exposed to the full election campaign before they cast their vote. I can think of 3 elections where I would have cast my vote differently had I done so 2 weeks before polling day rather than in the polling station.
Arrange a pair with Theresa May, giving the PM more time to concentrate on her important work.
Best wishes to Jo and all her family. It is good to see that she was able to vote in the circumstances.
I seem to remember a case some decades ago when, for a close vote, a dying MP was brought by ambulance to the the yard of the Houses of Parliament, from where, in his stretcher, he could cast his vote.