Amongst last Tuesday’s excitement of Theresa May attempting a “Charles the First”, it was easy to miss the significance of Dominic Grieve’s Brexit amendment:
With the government seemingly heading towards a defeat for May’s deal, there was concern that in such a scenario, there would be a bit of an impasse, with the government in the driving seat. Grieve’s amendment means that Parliament will have the power to say what happens next. As the Guardian explains:
Under the terms of the EU Withdrawal Act, the government will have 21 days to come back to parliament with a motion, setting out what it plans to do.
Grieve’s amendment, which is backed by the shadow Brexit secretary, Sir Keir Starmer, is aimed at ensuring any such motion can be amended by MPs.
They hope this will allow parliament to express its support for alternative approaches – and prevent the government either hurtling towards a no-deal Brexit without the backing of MPs, or imposing a plan B of its own devising.
A proviso should be stated. As the Clerk of the House of Commons recently clarified, only laws passed by Parliament have to be followed by the government. Motions do not have to be followed by the government.
That said, it is a relief that there is more of process in the event of May’s deal failing in Parliament. As Rafael Behr wrote in the Guardian, the amendment:
…reduces (but does not eliminate) the risk of Britain leaping off the Brexit cliff without a parachute.
Dominic Grieve’s amendment was backed by an interesting assortment of Conservative MPs, such as Sir Nicholas Soames, Richard Benyon, Oliver Letwin, Damian Green and Michael Fallon. They are far from being “the normal suspects”.
* Paul Walter is a Liberal Democrat activist and member of the Liberal Democrat Voice team. He blogs at Liberal Burblings.
Follow @libdemvoice.org on Bluesky
Like us on Facebook
Subscribe to our feed
Sign-up for our daily email digest
The Joy of Six 1571
Same old, same old from Farage
How Long Has it been?
Oh no, not another by-election
Discovery
Starmer makes the ultimate betrayal
Tŷ Newydd National Writing Centre's Open Day - 27 September 2026
Caron Lindsay
John MacInnes
Simon Robinson
7 Comments
Where was a Lib Dem supporter? AWOL!!
List of ayes is here:
https://www.theyworkforyou.com/divisions/pw-2018-12-04-274-commons/mp/10084
I am hurrying to choir but it includes Cable, Carmichael and Swinson for starters.
Thanks for posting that list, Paul, all 12 Lib Dem MPs’ names are there.
Glad to note that our MPs all voted in the ‘Ayes’ Lobby (even Stephen Lloyd on this occasion!) – but why is there not a single Lib Dem on the list of the amendment’s proposers when this does include not only Conservative and Labour MPs, but also SNP, Plaid Cymru and Green members?
If we are serious about helping to secure a People’s Vote/further referendum, then our MPs need to work with others on a properly coordinated cross-party basis in order to use any parliamentary opportunities that may be open to us. The issues at stake are too important for narrow party politics.
David
“Where was a Lib Dem supporter? AWOL!!”
A bit harsh, David. Just because someone doesn’t support an amendment doesn’t mean they are “absent without leave”. It’s possible they were not asked and were beavering away in Parliament or in their constituency office at the time signatures were being collected.
I’ve recently discovered a fondness for lawyers.
If parliament now dictates what happens, we have to trust it and that leaves everything in the air though better than the government in control. It all goes for a hasty decision and I’m against that. We need time for reflection, further negotiation and another referendum. And it’s Christmas.