Don Foster MP writes… The Integration Strategy: one year on

The Government’s Integration Strategy, Creating the Conditions for Integration was published a year ago on 21 February 2012. Since becoming a minister a few months ago, this is one of the areas about which I’ve had some of the strongest feedback from party members.

The views I’ve heard range from “the strategy is welcome, but not enough” to “it isn’t a serious substitute for a strategy to tackle racism and racial injustice”. Some have said that the document skates over the fact that integration is a two way process of mutual accommodation. Those with this view argue that there’s too much emphasis on creating (even imposing) a shared so-called “British identity”, rather than celebrating and sharing diversity.

I’m keen to hear more views on these issues although I also hope there will be an opportunity for more party members to appreciate the very wide ranging action that the coalition government is taking – with significant input from us.

Take the issue of diversity. I celebrate diversity. So does Nick Clegg. As he set out in his speech on the open, confident society, we should be “welcoming diversity, but resisting division”. There is a huge difference between “integration” and “assimilation”; the government’s policy is in support of the former and not – as some have suggested – the latter.

One of the triumphs of our multicultural society was of course the Olympics, where athletes including Mo Farah became national heroes and attributed their success to Britain’s multiculturalism. So we’ve shown it can work. But while we’re glad of them, we can’t let these successes distract from the fact that there is still a massive integration challenge to overcome.

Skin colour and race are among the biggest barriers to people feeling they belong; too often those of different skin colour or race ARE treated differently. And evidence shows that the more discrimination someone faces, the more likely they are to identify with their ethnic group rather than feeling that they’re also part of the wider community. So I want it on record that I completely agree: to create a multicultural society, as Nick has defined it, and to achieve the aims of the Integration Strategy we need to tackle racism.

I want to be very clear that the Integration Strategy isn’t how it would have looked if it had been entirely written by Liberal Democrats. It’s the product of compromise. Nor is it the last word on what the Government is doing on these issues. For example, the report Nick commissioned Andrew Stunell and me to write on BME access to finance is due to report shortly. Jo Swinson is undertaking some excellent work on stuck groups.

But having said that, there’s a lot in the strategy that we as Liberal Democrats should strongly support:

  • It provides some real solutions on how to encourage integration, for example, through supporting projects that pioneer innovative ideas and encourage integration, such as National Inter faith Week and projects aimed at knocking down barriers between communities through sports and music. Now I know that racism and exclusion have a myriad of complex causes that need bespoke and strategic approaches to tackle them, and I for one don’t want to patronise anyone by suggesting that giving money to the Girl Guides is going to solve everything in one fell swoop. But I firmly believe that these integration projects are one part of the solution.
  • One of the key projects, which is worth singling out, is Faith Matters’ Tell MAMA project, which records and provides support to those suffering from hate crime. The Government’s drive to stamp out anti-Muslim hatred is completely right, and I pay tribute to the work Fiyaz Mughal and MAMA are doing. We cannot allow anti-Muslim sentiment to become acceptable, and in places where it has taken root, we have to throw the kitchen sink at weeding it out.
  • Also, in line with a solid Lib Dem principle that local communities know their own local areas best, the strategy moves away from a top-down, Whitehall-led approach that characterised so much of what Labour did, and enables local authorities, communities, businesses and voluntary bodies to lead integration in their local areas. That’s not to say that Whitehall isn’t interested anymore though – there’s a monthly programme board which provides challenge and scrutiny, and I take a close interest, as does Baroness Warsi, Minister for Faith and Communities.
  • And we should also welcome the work the government is doing in supporting local councils tackle extremism. Councils whose residents have been most affected by the work of groups such as EDL are working with us to develop strategies to minimise the impact of such organisations.

I also want to be clear that the Integration Strategy isn’t a standalone document – it works alongside the Social Mobility Strategy and the Equality Strategy. Together, these documents provide a comprehensive, cross-departmental approach to creating a society where everyone, no matter what their race, gender or background, can live and work successfully together. This is completely in line with the Liberal Democrat commitment to social justice. That’s how I believe we need to tackle racism. As the Joseph Rowntree Foundation concluded in Tackling the Roots of Racism, to tackle racism, we have to also tackle structural segregation and poverty. Schools, colleges, universities, museums and arts and sports venues have an important role to play in combating everyday racism. And racism depends on context – there is no one cause of racism or one solution to racism.

Of course we must speak out against racism. Racism, discrimination and intolerance, wherever they occur. Inequalities of this kind have no place in a modern Britain and we as Liberal Democrats will not stand for them.

* Don Foster is MP for Bath, Liberal Democrat Chief Whip and Coalition Deputy Chief Whip.

Read more by or more about , , , , , , , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • Oriki Awolaja 21st Feb '13 - 1:05pm

    “Inequalities of this kind have no place in a modern Britain and we as Liberal Democrats will not stand for them”

    Well, the Lib Dems don’t have a single ethnic minority MP, so I’m not sure you should be lecturing the rest of us to live in non-segregation, while the Lib Dems are completely segregated…

  • Oriki Awolaja, thanks for your comment on the article. I wholeheartedly agree that it isn’t good enough and needs addressing, which is why I commend the hard work going in to the Leadership Programme launched by Nick Clegg last January. The Leadership Programme supports some of our excellent candidates from under-represented groups in being selected for winnable seats. A third of the candidates are from BME backgrounds. This is an excellent step towards improving the diversity of the Party, but of course we must work hard at this and much more needs to be done.

  • Helen Dudden 21st Feb '13 - 9:44pm

    I think there are those out there, with simply too many opinions. We are all able to believe in a religion or have the right to fight for justice or freedom.

    Don, do you feel that others have the right to make comments, and what should happen when this happens?

  • Helen Dudden 22nd Feb '13 - 8:31am

    Could I add there is quite a bit to be said about those who worship, in and live their lives in this country.

    I do not support Gaza, or feel that I am responsible for anything that is not compassionate or kind.

  • Simon Banks 22nd Feb '13 - 6:06pm

    Oriki – yes, you’re right to challenge the party to cease to be completely white in the House of Commons (I’m not sure that we don’t have ethnic minority MPs in the Lords) but to say we’re completely white is incorrect because that is not the nature of local council groups.

    Don – all very well, and I welcome your understanding that we need legal action against discrimination as well as initiatives to bring people together, but it’s ironic that this comes out with your comment about the interfaith aspect just after the excellent East of England Faiths Council has been forced to close for lack of funding, central government funding having been lost in one of Eric Pickles’ first blundering thuds and local authorities who’ve used EEFC’s work having found themselves too cash-strapped to save it.

  • Helen Dudden 23rd Feb '13 - 4:26pm

    Don, the comments of George Galloway MP, have again been reported as he refuses to speak with a student at Oxford University debate.

    Do you feel that his position as an MP, should reflect his behavior in this situation?

  • Helen Dudden 28th Feb '13 - 10:57am

    Don I feel that it is sad that women members of your party feel so excluded. Do you cover this item as well? Women are an equal part of society.

    I believe what is written on this site about the less than equal attitudes, if true leave, your party in a position of inequality.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Jeff
    Marco 12th Apr '24 - 10:01pm: The right wing media dont bother to defend Brexit anymore... As someone who reads across the political spectrum ...
  • Katharine Pindar
    What a refreshing discussion started by William, warning but also encouraging us. I think we can go strong on climate change policies, as you suggest, William -...
  • Simon McGrath
    “ Technically speaking, Israel is a democracy” Well yes. Alas Israeli’s have elected a dreadful government but the key is they elected them. And yes it...
  • David Allen
    Chris Moore, I'll be delighted if the party can prove me wrong!...
  • Chris Moore
    @David Allen: Paul Marshall is long gone from the party. Social Liberalism is the dominant current of thinking . You'd need to back up your slightly cyni...