Observations of an expat: The Thucydides Trap

Huawei, Hong Kong, Uighurs, the South China Sea, Chinese economic and military growth, “Kung Flu”, economic crisis, cyber-attacks, intellectual property theft, trade wars, sanctions, Donald Trump, Xi Jinping … are all combining to raise the spectre that the world is marching eyes wide open into the Thucydides Trap.

What, you may ask is the Thucydides Trap? It is a political/military term coined by American academic Graham Allison in 2012 to warn against the inevitability of war between China and America.

It was based on the work of the Greek historian Thucydides who explained that the Peloponnesian War (431-404 BCE) was the result of a growing power (Athens) rising to challenge the supremacy of the established power (Sparta) to such an extent that the only possible resolution was war.

The scenario has been used to explain the causes of several conflicts throughout history including World War One (Germany challenging Britain) and World War Two in Asia (Japan challenging the US).

Not all of the contests have resulted in an exchange of blows. The Soviet challenge was successfully contained at the Cold War stage. This was partly because of the nuclear-based Mexican stand-off and partly because the Soviet system failed to develop an economic model that challenged American supremacy.

China has the economic model in spades. Between 2004 and 2014 its GDP skyrocketed from $5,760 billion to $18,228 billion while the US went from $12,275 billion to $17, 393 billion over the same period. Militarily, Beijing still trails behind the US, but it is coming up fast and challenging American hegemony not only in East Asia but also in Africa, and even Europe where the prospect of lucrative trade deals and cheap manufactures speaks volumes.

David Cameron, for instance, did his best to usher in a “Golden Age” of UK-China relations, and trade with China was seen by Brexiteers as one of the cornerstones of a successful post-Brexit world. In 2017, China surpassed the US as Germany’s largest trading partner outside the EU. Beijing’s Belt Road initiative is heavily targeted on Europe and the Chinese have acquired a controlling interest in the strategic port of Piraeus to ensure its success.

The seemingly inexorable rise of China has led many of the leading figures in the Trump Administration to press for a showdown with China before it is too big to topple. Former National Security adviser Steve Bannon voiced their policy in February 2017 when he said that within the next five to ten years there would be a war between the US and China. “There’s no doubt about that,” he declared.

Trade wars, economic sanctions, and coronavirus conspiracy theories coupled with President’s Trump’s insulting and bellicose tweets appear to be designed to isolate China and push it towards breaking point.  Britain’s decision to dump Huawei and possibly other Chinese projects was a big win for the Trump Administration.

The Chinese have not helped. Threatening retaliation for Britain’s jettisoning of Huawei has only reinforced the belief that the company is a techno tool of the Chinese Communist Party. Then there is the issue of human rights in Hong Kong. The much vaunted policy of “two systems in one country” now lies in tatters in the streets of the former British colony. The next big test could be Taiwan where Tsai Ing-wen has been re-elected president on a promise to take the island to de jure independence from China—a move which Beijing has warned is “totally unacceptable.”

The economic fallout from the coronavirus pandemic only adds to this gathering perfect storm. The world economy is expected to shrink by anywhere between 3.2 percent (IMF prediction) and six percent (OECD prediction) this year. The US is better placed than most to weather the whirlwind. China’s heavy dependence on external trade makes it more vulnerable to a global downturn.

The generally accepted belief is that China takes the long view. Hong Kong and recent pronouncements from Beijing indicates that the view is shortening. China is an autocracy. The continued existence of its leadership relies on its ability to provide bread and circuses to a compliant population. If a democratic government fails to deliver it is voted out of office. If an authoritarian leadership fails then they can end up swinging from the lampposts—another incentive for Xi Jinping to shorten his view.

* American expat journalist Tom Arms is LDV's foreign affairs editor, author of the forthcoming book “America: Made in Britain” and Campaigns Chair for Wandsworth Lib Dems

Read more by or more about , , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.
Advert

5 Comments

  • Never thought I’d agree with anything Dominic Cummings might have said or that appears in the Daily Telegraph.

    “Aircraft carrier’s deployment to China shows its ‘immense capabilities’, former first sea lord says. Claim comes after Dominic Cummings said aircraft carriers cannot be sent to a ‘serious war against a serious enemy’, Daily Telegraph, By Danielle Sheridan, POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT 15 July 2020 • 10:10am”

    As long as Trump is in the White House, sending HMS Queen Elizabeth to the South China Sea is like smoking a cigarette over a box of fireworks……. What are they playing at ?

  • David Raw

    “What are they playing at ?”

    They are supporting the freedom of navigation operations being conducted by our close friends the US and Australia. I’d like to see other countries contribute as well, hopefully NATO will soon get involved.

  • People constantly talk about the threat to our world from global warming, I think they should be very concerned with something as threatening and possibly more imminent to world peace and security as the rise of some worrying nationalistic leaders and administrations in the world and that includes our present government. This pandemic crisis should be a wake-up call to what can happen out of the blue!

  • China’s rise is a challenge to the world community at a time when we need to work together. Like any emerging superpower it will want to test its boundaries and it is up to the global community to acknowledge its place and restrain its excesses peacefully.

  • China claims at present, with the joint efforts of China and Asean countries,the situation of the South China Sea has remained peaceful and stable and is still improving. China and Asean states are not only fully and effectively implementing the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea (DOC), but also accelerating the consultation on a Code of Conduct in the South China Sea (COC), which is an upgrade of the DOC. It will be more suited to our region’s needs and more effective in regulating the conduct of the parties. It will provide stronger safeguards for safety and freedom of navigation in the South China Sea and enable China and Asean to build trust, manage disagreements, strengthen cooperation and maintain stability.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert



Recent Comments

  • Fiona
    If anyone has residual concerns about the need (or possibility) of continuous economic growth, I very strongly recommend Donought Economics by Kate Rawarth. The...
  • Jenny barnes
    Eliminate all subsidies on fossil fuel. Increase tax on road fuel and gas. Create a proper electric car charging infrastructure. Build nuclear power. Building...
  • Martin
    Paul Barker: A minority Labour government?? - You must be foreseeing a sizeable turn in the tide. At this moment a minority Conservative government lo...
  • Yeovil Yokel
    To me, there is a glaring omission from these two lists: the way we manage farmland and produce food. Organic farming is probably the most sustainable form of m...
  • David Raw
    Good interview on Channel 4 News tonight with Andy Wightman, the former Scottish Green MSP who first raised the matter in Holyrood of Queens Consent in relation...