Opinion: Hackgate – Who do you trust?

5 Live Drive had a poll yesterday on “Who do you trust?”, particularly with Hackgate in mind.

Emerging, blinking, from two weeks of saturation “Breaking News”, answering that question is a good way to take stock of where we are.

Who do I trust?

Vince Cable is the first person who springs to mind. He (inadvertently publicly) “declared war on Mr Murdoch”. He was then forced to be “hors de combat”. He said “I think we are going to win” and we did. Murdoch is in retreat. Well done, Vince.

Tom Watson is the second person I trust as a result of this episode. He’s a model of how a politician should behave. Patient, calm, studious, insistent.

The Guardian. OK, I could justifiably be called a “Guardianista”. But my faith in the Guardian has gone from hard concrete to immovable bedrock.

The BBC. I have always hated the Tory anti-BBC bias. I was delighted to hear Cameron acknowledge yesterday that his party had been too hard on the BBC. It is a national institution we should cherish dearly.

Who don’t I trust?

David Cameron. I was always equivocal about him. But his decision about Andy Coulson will mean I never really trust him.

News International, of course. But then, I never bought News International papers. Two weeks ago I flirted with The Times iPad app. It is technically exceptional. But, as I tried the trial version, I realized something. The Times has no soul. I abandoned it and then found out, anyway, that the Guardian are weeks away from launching an iPad app. So I’ll wait for that.

The jury is out on…

Rebekah Brooks. Most of the Tuesday spotlight was on the Murdochs and the phantom flan thrower. But after them, Rebekah Brooks was (partially) redeemingly boring.

Read more by or more about , , , , , or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • Keith Browning 21st Jul '11 - 1:24pm

    ……………… still thinking ………………… paper still blank after 30 minutes.

    The world has become a very unreliable and untrustworthy place at so many levels.

  • Keith Browning 21st Jul '11 - 3:43pm

    Tornado in Leamington Spa ……!!

    Is the world coming to an end?

    with the Murdochs at least you know what you’ve got.

  • John Roffey 22nd Jul '11 - 9:03am

    I have made an attempt to answer this question, however, it is too long to post as a comment.

    It can be viewed on my blog here:


  • Murdoch dominance has been a blight on British politics for years. But let’s be fair Vince Cable ‘didn’t speak out’ publically – he was caught out. Though in fairness his instincts were spot on. But what happened then – he was sidelined and the Lib Dem Coalition sat on their hands. Clegg and Ashdown warned Cameron – then what? Nothing. Hardly impressive. Whereas Tom Watson and Chris Bryant have stood out and in fairness to Milliband he did publically and clearly took on Murdock.

  • @John Roffey:

    And, he is indeed right on many accounts. The type of capitalism we now live under is destroying our society. We live in a society where our “obligation” to the banks comes before our obligation to care for our weakest and most vulnerable members of society. This government, Liberal Democrats in government, are removing many protections and real lifelines from people who depend on these services. It is heartbreaking to watch the Liberal Democrats become nothing more than neo-liberal apologists who are letting the Tories get away with policies they could not win a majority for on their own, all to please these all-mighty and unaccountable markets.

    We have Dodgy Dave and Pinocchio Clegg telling us there is no alternative and that we have to make pensioners sit in their own piss all night long because if we give the money to carers rather than bankers, said bankers and the rich will “just go elsewhere.” We have Liberal Democrats committing to the Conservative dream of, finally, privatising everything. Well, it wasn’t the disabled who brought the economy down, yet they are the ones being punished. I don’t remember librarians overspending, but they are the ones who are paying for it with their jobs. Modern Capitalism, after all, demands it.

    So when this winter comes and I am only able to afford to heat my house an hour or two at most, I’ll think about how I am benefiting from making sure these friendly bankers stay in the UK. And every time I see a LibDem or Tory politician on TV, I will redouble my will to help those who this LibDem government is punishing for the mistakes of the powerful.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Christian
    Opinion polls aren’t really improving for the Lib Dems, yet the economy is in crisis and Lab have no actual solution. Isn’t it time we flew the banner for R...
  • Paul Barker
    FYI Labour conference has just passed a motion calling for a change to Proportional Representation, this is a big step forward but conference does not decide p...
  • Julian Tisi
    I have a few disagreements with the OP. First - democracy: we must surely continue to support the concept of an elected HOL (or at least the vast majority must...
  • David Raw
    I’m old enough to remember Harold Wilson getting a huge amount of stick from the Tory press for a definite Government decision to devalue the £ by 14% back i...
  • Alan Jelfs
    Too complex. Keep it simple. Abolish the House of Lords and have a parliament for England, like Scotland and Wales do. It could sub-divide into regions later,...