Opinion: Why we should back liberal Free Schools

Tony Blair won his first election in 1997 on the back of his refrain, “education, education, education”, and in the run up to a likely 2010 general election the party leaders have already begun positioning themselves as offering radical proposals for education.

Nick Clegg and David Cameron have both voiced their support for seeing the introduction of Swedish-style ‘free schools’, where state funding, as is already standard, follows individual pupils; but in the case of free schools it also follows pupils into independent schools. Both Cameron and Clegg have made it clear that these schools would not involve academic selection (indicating a return to grammar schools) or be able to charge a top up fees (indicating the introduction of school vouchers). Both leaders are right to do so. Taking either or both those options would see an end to the meritocratic basis on which education is provided: state funding in education should go to all, regardless of ability, and shouldn’t be used to help the rich gain superior education.

On a similar theme, both leaders should also make it clear that they will not allow other barriers of entry to pupils, such as religion for example, and they shouldn’t become places for specific NGOs to promote their own agendas. Free schools need to be inclusive once pupils are in them.

Both Clegg and Cameron are right to support free schools: they offer a great chance to increase civil society, to provide better education in Britain, a greater level of plurality, and parents and children having increased choice and control in their education.

By declaring that the Conservatives will not allow firms to make a profit from the fee school system, however, Cameron is failing to fully utilise the opportunities free schools could offer, and which can only be accessed by allowing profit-making into the system. This might be the tokenistic suspicion of any institution making profit from state money; a refusal to take that idea to a public he fears won’t accept it; or that he’d rather see free schools be the sole domain of NGOs – which reveals a scary amount of paternalism. Whichever is the case, Clegg should not make the same mistake.

Posted in Op-eds | 71 Comments
Advert

It’s a three-way contest for next Scottish Lib Dem leader

Following Nicol Stephen’s surprise resignation as leader of the Scottish Lib Dems, three MSPs have declared their intent to succeed him, according to today’s papers. Here’s The Times:

Tavish Scott, the former Transport Minister, who is widely tipped as the favourite to replace Nicol Stephen as leader, formally announced his bid only hours after the former Rural Affairs Minister, Ross Finnie, made it clear he too was running. … Mr Scott, who is close to Mr Stephen, has won the backing of six of the party’s MSPs and five MPs. He also enjoys the support of the former UK party

…

Posted in Leadership Election | Tagged , and | 1 Comment

Ros Scott: can you spare 5 minutes for my online survey?

People often ask me how I got involved in politics.

Putting down roots in Suffolk after many years of moving around, it was a revelation to me to see how a community really works. I became increasingly involved as a community activist and saw at first hand the great work done by my local Lib Dem councillor.

All political parties are now talking about localism, but for us is it part of our DNA. We need to ensure that we keep faith with our localist instincts and our natural inclination towards small and accountable decision-making.

I’ve always believed that our …

Posted in Party policy and internal matters | Tagged | 17 Comments

The Conservative reaction to the Ray Lewis affair

Credit where credit is due, the official Conservative Party reaction to the Ray Lewis affair appears to be rather more measured and sensible than that of some of the party’s online cheerleaders:

Former minister Francis Maude will chair talks with senior party officials and one of Boris Johnson’s right hand men to learn lessons from the resignation of the deputy mayor …

Team Boris’s takeover of City Hall was seen as a test bed for Mr Cameron’s first 100 days in Government, with vital lessons to be learned. Mr Boles was seconded to manage the launch and report back.

The Ray Lewis

…

Posted in London | Tagged | 3 Comments

Bloggers! Would you like to interview Jo Swinson MP?

Jo Swinson, Lib Dem MP for Dunbartonshire East, has agreed to be interviewed by a bunch of Lib Dem bloggers at Westminster on Monday, 21st July at 7 pm.

Several mature, erudite interviewers (and their cuddly toys) have already signed up, but there are still a couple of free places in the playpen, oops, panel.

It doesn’t matter if you don’t have a blog of your own – you can always write it up for Lib Dem Voice. Just as long as you blog about it…

Jo is our Spokesperson for Foreign Affairs and chairs the Party’s Campaign for …

Posted in Blogger Interviews | Tagged | 7 Comments
Advert

Glasgow East latest

Well, they say a week is a long time in politics! Wednesday saw the shock resignation of our Scottish Party Leader, Nicol Stephen, on Thursday we selected East End Ian Robertson for the Glasgow East by-election and then on Friday Labour selected nobody because the favourite didn’t turn up … you couldn’t make this up, could you?

The Liberal Democrats have a great candidate in Ian Robertson, a great campaign office at 888 Shettleston Road, Glasgow, G32 7XN and a fantastic team coming together.

If you look at the posters on the lampposts it really is only the SNP and the Liberal …

Posted in Parliamentary by-elections | Tagged and | 22 Comments

Something for the Weekend: A day in the life

Afternoon. Welcome to this week’s collection of odds and sods from the twin worlds of Politics and Not-Politics. Just step this way…

If you see Doug, tell him

Labour MP Doug Henderson wants your views – if you’re one of his constituents in Newcastle North.

Doug Henderson MP - Tell Doug !

His household survey is a mix of leading questions (“Should tougher penalties be imposed on those who deal in drugs, blighting our communities and inflicting misery on individuals?”) and absent proofreading (I know, I can talk).

The pièce de resistance, though, is question 6, which I present for your delectation:

Voting intention question

Meanwhile, in Tyne Bridge…

Doug’s local Labour colleague David Clelland, the MP for Tyne Bridge, also takes an unorthodox approach to dealing with his constituents’ voting intentions.

In a textbook example of the drawbacks of the safe seats producted by the first-past-the-post electoral system, 23-year MP Mr Clelland responded to criticism from a constituent thus:

I accept your offer not to vote for me again I do not want your vote so you can stick wherever best pleases you.

The constituent in question, IT salesman Gary Scott (who was around four years old when David Clelland became an MP), had written a letter to Mr Clelland complaining that he was supporting an out-of-touch and authoritarian government.

You can read the full exchange on Paul Walter’s blog.

Book him, Dannie

Wales’s culture minister Rhodri Glyn Thomas took a leaf out of Terry Wogan’s book this week when he announced the wrong winner of the Wales Book of the Year award – before announcing the correct winner, 84-year-old writer and poet Dannie Abse, for his memoir The Presence.

Another gong for Vince

While we’re on the subject of awards, congratulations to our Shadow Chancellor and Deputy Leader Vince Cable who was recognised again this week for his sterling work.

Posted in Something for the Weekend | 5 Comments

Ray Lewis: two new allegations plus Boris increasingly in the firing line

Two new allegations around London Deputy Mayor Ray Lewis have emerged today. First, that – contrary to his claims – his Academy is no longer being funded by Newham Council and, second, that despite repeated references to Ray Lewis being a Magistrate, in fact according to the Ministry for Justice Ray Lewis “is not and never has been a Magistrate“.

Meanwhile, Boris Johnson is increasingly in the firing line over the whole issue because the Evening Standard has documented a series of checks that could have been undertaken before Ray Lewis’s appointment but which weren’t. Given the seniority …

Posted in London | Tagged | 19 Comments

In his own words: Tory David Maclean on MPs’ pay

An extract from the Hansard transcript of yesterday’s debate on MPs’ pay and expenses:

David Maclean (Penrith and The Border) (Con):

I have been a Member of the House for 25 years. I have been privileged to be a Minister under Prime Minister Thatcher and under Prime Minister Major. I have taken pay freezes, pay standstills, pay cuts and pay deferments, and a fat lot of good it did for the respect in which Parliament or Ministers at the time were held. Whether or not Prime Minister Thatcher had a pay policy — I am certain she never did — we …

Posted in News and Parliament | 10 Comments

I’m writing to the taxman

Letter sent to Liverpool tax office today:

4th July 2008
Dear Sir/Madam

I wish to bring your attention to an individual who is claiming to be self-employed who I believe may not be registered as such.

Yesterday Mr Peter Kilfoyle MP stated that “I’m technically self-employed” .

My understanding, having previously been self-employed myself, is that a person who is self-employed is required to register as such with 3 months and is liable for class 2 and class 4 NI contributions.

I would be grateful if this matter could be investigated.

Yours faithfully

Hywel Morgan
CC Mr Peter Kilfoyle MP

Posted in Parliament | 6 Comments

Expenses reform: Clegg pushes ahead despite Labour and Conservative opposition

Press release just out:

Liberal Democrat Leader, Nick Clegg, has today committed to unilaterally introduce the recommendations of the Members Estimates Committee for independent spot checks of MPs expenses.

Despite Labour and Conservative MPs defeating the MEC’s recommendations on Thursday, the Liberal Democrats will go ahead with implementing those that are relevant in order to further improve accountability.

Nick Clegg said:

“The Liberal Democrats will now implement as many of the recommendations as we can to tighten up the rules on MPs expenses – particularly those relating to spot checks of MPs expense claims.

“My Shadow Cabinet will shortly be publishing quarterly breakdowns of their …

Posted in News and Parliament | 5 Comments

Mike Rumbles: why I want to lead the Scottish Lib Dems

I want to lead this party because I believe that it has never been a more important time to be a Liberal Democrat. The other parties are obsessed with eroding individual civil liberties:
* the Labour Party is hell-bent on forcing people to carry ID cards and increasing the length of detention without trial to 42 days;
* the Conservatives want to introduce random drug tests in schools; and
* the SNP continue to bring forward a whole raft of measures which will take away individuals’ rights, such as its proposals to ban all our young adults aged 18 to 21 …

Posted in Leadership Election and Scotland | 20 Comments

How Conservative MPs sunk expenses reform

Alex has beaten me to writing up the result of yesterday’s vote, so here are his words:

News reports of last night’s self-pampering vote by greedy MPs offer a choice of two messages: either ‘they’re all at it’ or ‘the Tories and Liberal Democrats condemned Labour’. But the truth is that not all MPs – and not all parties – have their snouts in the trough. The truth is that of 176 MPs so out of touch with the economic woes of the real world that they voted themselves £23,000 a year for home furnishings, 146 were Labour.

…

Posted in News and Parliament | 15 Comments

Ray Lewis in the news

Coverage left, right and centre today over the allegations against Ray Lewis, one of Boris Johnosn’s deputy mayors (e.g. The Times).

A few points to note:

  1. The Bishop of Chelmsford has said that, “Between 1999 and 2005 Ray was placed under the formal disciplinary structures of the Church of England and his ministry was restricted.” This is a very different story from Ray Lewis’s own public statements.
  2. This however hasn’t stopped ConservativeHome saying that, “the left-leaning media have jumped on this story with relish, pre-judging him with little more than some disjointed insinuations.” Hmm… I think most people would describe having a Bishop give such a

…

Posted in London | Tagged | Leave a comment

BBC Question Time: open thread

Lib Dem MEP for the south-east of England Baroness Emma Nicholson is one of the panellists on tonight’s Question Time (broadcast on BBC1 and online from 10.35 pm GMT).

The panel will also include the Minister of State in the Scotland Office and Labour MP for Greenock and Inverclyde David Cairns; Conservative shadow health secretary Andrew Lansley; Scotland’s Deputy First Minister, the SNP’s Nicola Sturgeon; and comedian, actor and writer David Mitchell.

So, if you want to sound-off as you watch, please feel free to use the comments thread.

Posted in Lib Dem TV | Tagged | 4 Comments

Needed: Spanish practices

The announcement earlier this year of a Spanish Cabinet that is majority women should cause everyone involved in British politics to stop and wonder why we’re doing so badly.

We know that the under-representation of women in politics is a bad thing – and that this applies to the Liberal Democrats as much as anyone else, even if we do have a good heritage of standing up on issues of inequality.

But how many more women do we really need to stand for us if we’re going to get a more equal party?

It turns out that the answer is at least 100 …

Posted in Op-eds | 29 Comments

Top Mayor aide investigated over sexual misconduct allegations

London Mayor Boris Johnson held a press conference this afternoon, announcing that he is to hold an inquiry into his newly appointed Deputy Mayor, Ray Lewis, over allegations of sexual misconduct.

The BBC takes up the story:

BBC London learned Mr Lewis, who has responsibility for youth, was barred from working in the Church of England after the allegations were made when he was vicar at a church in east London a decade ago.

Mr Lewis was placed on the Church of England’s Lambeth and Bishopsthorpe Register – the so-called Lambeth List – in 1999.

People on the list are prevented from public

…

Posted in London | Tagged | 3 Comments

News from Glasgow East

Just three and a half weeks after moving to Edinburgh to take up my new post as Deputy Director of Campaigns for Scotland, I find myself involved in another major election campaign!

We have selected born and bred Glaswegian Ian Robertson as our candidate to fight the by-election, and although the media are saying it is a two horse race we should remember that the SNP were in fact only 1,603 votes ahead of us in 2005.

This is an election that will be fought on the local issues that matter to the people in the East End of Glasgow – unemployment, …

Posted in Parliamentary by-elections | Tagged | 11 Comments

Ian Robertson selected for Glasgow East

Glasgow Liberal Democrats have chosen local teacher Ian Robertson to be the party’s candidate in the parliamentary by-election on July 24th.

The full press release is on the Glasgow East Liberal Democrats website.

Posted in News and Parliamentary by-elections | Tagged | Leave a comment

Manchester Labour councillors plan secret underground car park “in the interest of democracy”

The Manchester Evening News reports:

PRO-CONGESTION charge councillors are planning to build themselves a private underground car park in the city centre. Senior Labour councillors – who are backing the toll in exchange for a massive expansion of public transport – want to tunnel next to the town hall to provide spaces for the 96 elected members, a handful of top officials and approved visitors. Ironically the car park bunker, under the Peace Gardens, would be only a few yards from one of Manchester’s main tram stops in St Peter’s Square.

… Bernard Priest, Labour’s finance chief and the man

…

Posted in Local government and News | 6 Comments

Nick Clegg on local democracy: we should try it for a change

Nick Clegg today delivered a major speech to the Local Government Association outlining the ways Liberal Democrats intend to give real power back to local people and communities. It’s well worth reading in full – which you can do here – but for those who want the skinny, here’s a few snippets…

On the principle of ‘localism’

I am drawn to the philosophy of decentralisation and local empowerment for many reasons. There’s the basic principle of subsidiarity – the liberal belief that decisions just ought to be taken as close to the people they affect as possible. But it’s more than that. Centralised government simply doesn’t work to deliver the change I want for Britain. It doesn’t improve services fast enough. And it certainly doesn’t deliver fairer outcomes – where everybody gets opportunities no matter their background.

On the so-called ‘postcode lottery’ that results

In Britain today there is often a pervasive notion that the only way to deliver fairness and opportunity for all is to have absolute rigid uniformity. And this generates the media refrain of a postcode lottery. But people are different. Uniform services – almost by definition – do not fit individuals. We need variation, flexibility and personalisation in the way services are run and delivered if they are to fit into real people’s lives.

A postcode lottery is a terrible thing. But the terrible part isn’t that things are different in different areas. The terrible part is the lottery – it’s that you don’t get to choose what fits you, or fits your postcode.

I want things to be different in different places. I want things to be different for different people. I just want people to be able to choose what suits them – not have it handed out arbitrarily by a bureaucratic lottery no-one understands.


What devolution really means

I want to address what I really mean by devolution – because it’s a word that’s often used, but rarely followed through. Real localisation means giving communities autonomy. The power to disagree with central government. And to do something different. I believe this is only possible when communities are in charge of their own money. … if local government is spending central government’s money – central government will want a big say in what it’s spent on.

So at the heart of any real plan to transfer power downwards in Britain must be a plan to transfer taxation downwards. Britain has the second most centralised taxation system in Europe. Second only to Malta. And Malta has a population about the same size as Croydon. This has to change. Until it does, all this talk of double devolution and post-bureaucratic ages will be so much hot air.

Posted in Local government, News and Party policy and internal matters | 3 Comments

Peter Hain file passed to prosecutors

As The Guardian reports:

The Metropolitan police handed a file to the Crown Prosecution Service following an inquiry into late declarations to his campaign for the deputy leadership of the Labour party.

Hain today put any inconsistencies down to an “innocent mistake” and said he had provided police “with all the information they might need”…

A Metropolitan police spokesman said that the CPS would “advise us on whether any further enquiries are necessary and whether any charges should be brought”.

Hain quit as work and pensions secretary in January after the Electoral Commission referred his late declaration of donations to the police following

…

Posted in News | Tagged and | 1 Comment

Nicol Stephen resigns as Scottish leader

As the BBC reports:

The former Scottish deputy first minister said the stresses and strains the job placed on his family life had become too great.

However, he will remain as the MSP for Aberdeen South…

Mr Stephen, who has four children aged between four and 12, said in a statement that family now had to take priority.

“Everyone involved in politics knows that there are stresses and strains on family life. But when it goes beyond that, when it crosses a line, something has to be done.”

“And at that stage – when you have to make a choice between family and politics

…

Posted in Scotland | Tagged | 14 Comments

What are the Lib Dems doing about David Davis?

Today David Cameron joined David Davis on the campaign trail in the Haltemprice and Howden by-election in support of Mr Davis’s candidature. Perhaps he did so through slightly gritted teeth – the former Tory shadow home secretary’s resignation put in the spotlight Tory divisions on 42 days just at the point when pressure was piling on Gordon Brown following his ‘non-deal’ with the DUP to secure a wafer-thin Commons victory. But, whatever his private feelings, Mr Cameron did it.

Doubtless he joined him for many reasons – to avoid repeated stories of Tory splits, and because he recognised how popular …

Posted in Op-eds | 32 Comments

PMQs: Nick tackles Gordon on mental health problems

At this week’s Prime Minister’s Questions, the Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg highlighted a serious issue paid scant attention in society – the lengthy waiting lists facing millions of NHS patients with mental health problems. No surprises that Gordon Brown side-stepped the question (it’s what he does), though it sparked a quick-fire response from Nick: “ is doing it again: he is confusing a list with an answer, and a review with action.” Nick has well and truly found his feet in the bear-pit of PMQs.

But what of David Cameron? Last week I noted that he seemed a little out of sorts. Today, again, many have noted his more subdued performance, and even given Mr Brown a ‘points win’ (pretty much by default, for Gordon isn’t a patch on Tony). Some suggest it’s a deliberate strategy; that Mr Cameron daren’t try ‘too hard’ lest the force of his rhetoric brings the Prime Minister to his knees – and that the Tories want to keep Mr Brown in place. I don’t buy the explanation for a moment.

What I hope might be more accurate is that Mr Cameron is deliberately moderating his performance, attempting to tone down the shrill posturing and cheap jibes which have all too often marred his superior debating skills: he’s trying hard not to seem as if he’s trying too hard. As I say, I genuinely hope that’s the reason; that the Tory leader is demonstrating a little more maturity to reflect his current standing as PM-in-waiting. PMQs might be marginally less boorish if so.

Anyway you can judge for yourselves below, via Hansard:

Posted in Parliament | Tagged | 2 Comments

Was Keith Vaz promised an honour in return for supporting 42 days?

The Daily Telegraph has the story:

Gordon Brown is under pressure to reveal whether Keith Vaz, the influential head of a Parliamentary Committee, has been offered a peerage or honour in return for backing the Government’s controversial counter-terrorism measures.

The Daily Telegraph has seen a private letter sent by chief whip Geoff Hoon to Mr Vaz expressing an expectation that his former ministerial colleague will be “appropriately rewarded” for backing the measure to hold terror suspects for up to 42 days without charge.

Mr Vaz is the Labour chairman of the Home Affairs Select Committee. He was previously opposed to the plans

…

Posted in News | 10 Comments

Did 41,000 votes go missing in the London elections?

I’ve blogged previously (here and here) about some of the errors which came to light in the London election results. None of these were serious in their own right, but they do cast doubt on how good the checking processes really were. Now a comprehensive review has suggested that up to 41,000 votes went unaccounted for:

Although the glitches are unlikely to have changed the overall result of the mayoral race – Boris Johnson won by almost 140,000 votes after second choices were taken into consideration – today’s report lists a string of potentially serious problems with the

…

Posted in London | Tagged | 1 Comment

Boris Johnson – two months on

Just days after his May 1st victory, looking out from his 8th floor office across the skyline of our great capital city, Boris Johnson repeated to me his early days mantra – yes, I was elected as a Conservative, but I am now mayor of the whole of London and will govern for the whole of London. Don’t believe what my opponents said, was his message, I’m no rabid right-winger.

Assessing his progress two months on, that clearly remains his desired positioning. It’s significant that his first gaffe – the sacking of deputy chief of staff, James McGrath, over ill-judged (but …

Posted in London and Op-eds | Tagged and | 9 Comments

A look back at the polls (2/2): what a difference a year makes

To celebrate the beginning of Gordon’s second (and last?) year as Prime Minister, what could be more cheering than to have a look at the parties’ polling averages over the last 12 months? Well, if you’re a Labour supporter, smearing yourself in slurry would probably be more comforting, but never mind:

June 2007 (Tony Blair’s last month in charge)
Tories: 36%, Labour: 36%, Lib Dems: 17%
Tory lead 0%

July 2007 (Gordon Brown’s first full month as PM)
Tories: 34%, Labour: 39%, Lib Dems: 16%
Tory lead -5%

August 2007 (Floods, terrorists and foot-and-mouth)
Tories: 34%, Labour: 39%, Lib Dems: 16%
Tory …

Posted in Op-eds and Polls | 11 Comments

A look back at the polls (1/2): June

We tend not to be too poll-obsessed here at LDV – of course we look at them, as do all other politico-geeks, but viewed in isolation no one poll will tell you very much beyond what you want to read into it. Looked at over a reasonable time-span and, if there are enough polls, you can see some trends.

Here, in chronological order, are the results of the eight polls published in June:

Tories 42%, Labour 26%, Lib Dems 21% – ICM/Sunday Telegraph (8th June)
Tories 45%, Labour 25%, Lib Dems 20% – Populus/Times (10th June)
Tories 45%, Labour 28%, Lib Dems 16% …

Posted in Op-eds and Polls | 11 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • David
    Some very useful food for thought for the party. It really needs the leadership to start being prepared to come of the fence for more than reheated coalition er...
  • Simon McGrath
    Thanks for all ther comments including from some very old friends !...
  • JONATHAN M
    Well put, Miranda! I live, and have done so for many years in Australia, but still consider myself a 'former' Liberal Party supporter (nowdays a current Liberal...
  • JohnMc
    Labour MPs have already reportrd the Greens to the police, but as i am confused about definitions here I cant dee how that works. As opposed to actual racist st...
  • David S
    All that allowing (for instance) corporations to engage in environmental destruction for a fee, or a tax, or whatever you call it does is to make the government...