Tag Archives: court ruling on article 50

4 December 2018 – today’s press releases

It perhaps tells you all that you need to know about the state of our politics when the Government is found to have acted in contempt of Parliament and yet, hours later, nobody has resigned. But you can guess what’s dominating today…

  • Lib Dems demand urgent action on prisons crisis (already covered here)
  • UK can get out of Brexit mess
  • Moran: Govt is fostering a culture of senseless competition in our schools
  • Cable: Legal advice must be published urgently
  • Parliament wins back control, but people must have their say
  • Cable: Bring country together with a People’s Vote

UK can get out of Brexit mess

Responding to the …

Posted in News | Also tagged , , , , , , , and | 1 Comment

Article 50 in the Supreme Court: what we should do next?

It is just over a week since the Supreme Court Article 50 hearings finished and all the excitement that went with it. For those of you who were fighting a by-election, the case was not a rerun of the High Court hearings as interventions were heard from all parts of the United Kingdom. The decision could have fundamental ramifications on the relationship between Westminster and the devolved administrations on top of the decision on Article 50 and the extent of the Royal Prerogative.

No one can realistically predict the result and I, as a non-lawyer, will not even try. But we must decide how we should respond to it. I list some of the possible outcomes below. How we challenge the government will vary dramatically in each case and needs careful thinking through now before the Supreme Court announces its decision before the government moves quickly to meet its March 2017 deadline if we are to respond quickly.

  1. The UK Government wins and no legislation is needed to trigger Article 50, i.e. a reversal of the High Court decision.
  2. A very short bill to trigger Article 50 has to go through parliament, drafted so as to reduce the chances of amendment (and probably already prepared).
  3. Substantive legislation is required to trigger Article 50 modifying existing legislation – this could more easily be amended to bind the government’s negotiating mandate.
  4. On top of either 2 or 3, the government is also required to consult the devolved assemblies (the Sewel Convention) to agree legislative consequences on the devolved administrations. How should we respond if no agreement is forthcoming?
Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged and | 10 Comments

We need to stop the drift towards self-destruction

It is more in sorrow than anger that I review the events of the last few days.

And if you want sorrow rather than anger done beautifully, then watch this wonderful piece of James O’Brien’s LBC show. He patiently asks why the caller asked for British law administered in Britain by British judges but is now angry about British law administered in Britain by British judges.

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged | 126 Comments

Article 50 ruling follows a monumental misjudgment by Theresa May

It is difficult not to see today’s High Court ruling as anything other than a disaster for Theresa May. The first big decision she made as PM turns out to have been a monumental misjudgment. She has been ruled out of order and, unless an appeal is successful, she’ll have to go cap in hand to Parliament.

Mike Smithson of Political Betting put it very well:

Tim Farron commented:

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged , and | 69 Comments
Advert



Recent Comments

  • User AvatarJoseph Bourke 23rd Feb - 1:44pm
    Taxes have both macroeconomic effects and microeconomic effects. So called deadweight losses are primarily (but not exclusively) a microeconomic feature. In the UK we have...
  • User Avatarexpats 23rd Feb - 1:38pm
    ........................Heidi Allen MP, one of the three ex-Tory Independents, who reportedly attacked George Osborne in her Maiden speech in 2015 over his tax cuts to...
  • User AvatarLorenzo Cherin 23rd Feb - 1:05pm
    Katharine you bring a constructive and of course welcome contribution to our debate about these mps. I feel there is much to agree with in...
  • User AvatarJoseph Bourke 23rd Feb - 12:56pm
    Peter Martin, House prices in the UK have increased by more than double that in comparable European Counties since 1970. Rents have increased by three...
  • User AvatarMichael 1 23rd Feb - 12:52pm
    @Gordon On VAT All taxes increase the cost of doing business and therefore the cost of living. Income tax increases the cost of living. And...
  • User AvatarRichard Underhill 23rd Feb - 12:38pm
    Sean Hagan 23rd Feb '19 - 10:43am: Peter Kyle MP was interviewed at length on BBC tv Politics Live on 22/2/2019. His proposed amendment falls...