Which Lib Dem minister had the worst year? Here’s what party members think…

Lib Dem Voice polled our members-only forum recently to discover what Lib Dem members think of various political issues, the Coalition, and the performance of key party figures. Over 500 party members have responded, and we’re publishing the full results.

The Lib Dem half of the Quad top our members’ poll for the worst 2012

Nick Clegg yay2 - Some rights reserved by Liberal Democrats
LDV asked: In your opinion, which Lib Dem government minister has had the worst year?

Unusually for our Voice surveys, this question allowed an unprompted, free-text response, which c.400 of our respondents filled in. And here’s what you told us:

    1. Nick Clegg (123)
    2. Danny Alexander (69)
    3. Sarah Teather (33)
    4. Chris Huhne (28)
    5. Vince Cable (27)
    6. David Laws (21)
    7. Lynne Featherstone (16)
    8. Jeremy Browne (15)
    9. Ed Davey (12)
    10. Andrew Stunell (11)
    =11. Paul Burstow (10)
    =11. Lord (Tom) McNally (10)
    13. Nick Harvey (8)

    (Note: only Lib Dem ministers who scored double-digit votes are mentioned here.)

Last year he tied with Chris Huhne, but in 2012 Nick Clegg tops our poll outright as the Lib Dem minister who suffered the worst year. Not only did the party suffer a second successive bruising at the polls, but Nick’s hopes of reforming the House of Lords were shot down in flames by a major backbench Tory rebellion. By late summer, our survey showed party members evenly split whether Nick should lead the party into the next election.

Last year, Danny Alexander came in third place; in 2012, he moves up a place to become runner-up (perhaps not something he’ll celebrate this Hogmanay). For many he is no more than the Lib Dem face of Coalition cuts, always defending George Osborne’s decisions with just a bit too much enthusiasm. That said, he is also steering the Lib Dems closer to meeting the party’s number one manifesto pledge, proving himself more economically adept than the Chancellor, and skilfully navigating a speech to the TUC.

Sarah Teather is one of five Lib Dems in our list who began the year as ministers and end it on the backbenches — she left most noisily, with a scorching exit interview in mid-November, lambasting the Tories’ “immoral and divisive” intent on welfare benefits. She is joined by Chris Huhne, Andrew Stunell, Paul Burstow and Nick Harvey (the latter in particular may feel hard done by for being shunted aside for doing his job at Defence too well).

In total, nine of those who appear above also featured on our list of those who’d had the best year, in alphabetical order: Danny Alexander, Jeremy Browne, Vince Cable, Nick Clegg, Ed Davey, Lynne Featherstone, Nick Harvey, David Laws and Sarah Teather. These polls always trigger a mix of responses: some use it as a chance to vent against a Lib Dem politician who gets their goat; others attempt pure objectivity; and others choose the Lib Dem they think has had the most rotten time to express their sympathy for him/her. Make of it what you wish!

Tomorrow: which Lib Dem MP or peer you think has had the best year…

  • Over 1,200 Lib Dem paid-up party members are registered with LibDemVoice.org. Over 500 responded to the latest survey, which was conducted between 7th and 11th December.
  • Please note: we make no claims that the survey is fully representative of the Lib Dem membership as a whole. However, LibDemVoice.org’s surveys are the largest independent samples of the views of Lib Dem members across the country, and have in the past offered accurate guides to what party members think.
  • For further information on the reliability/credibility of our surveys, please refer to FAQs: Are the Liberal Democrat Voice surveys of party members accurate? and polling expert Anthony Wells’ verdict, On that poll of Lib Dem members.
  • The full archive of our members’ surveys can be viewed at www.libdemvoice.org/category/ldv-members-poll
  • * Stephen Tall is Co-Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice, and editor of the 2013 publication, The Coalition and Beyond: Liberal Reforms for the Decade Ahead. He is also a Research Associate for the liberal think-tank CentreForum and writes at his own site, The Collected Stephen Tall.

    Read more by or more about , or .
    This entry was posted in LDV Members poll.
    Bookmark the web address for this page or use the short url http://ldv.org.uk/32393 for Twitter and emails.

    9 Comments

    • Peter Watson 28th Dec '12 - 6:43pm

      It’s probably not much consolation, but you don’t have to go as far down this list to find a woman.

    • Chris has done well!? When oh when is his court case – are strings being pulled?

    • Helen Tedcastle 28th Dec '12 - 7:20pm

      Nick Clegg and Danny Alexander – having the worst year? Yes, and it could have been so different – not going along with Osborne and Gove’s policies would have been helpful.

      I’m sorry that Sarah Teather was moved out of the Government – then again, she has her own mind – and is not Tory-lite.

    • Richard Dean 28th Dec '12 - 8:15pm

      When you write “double-digit”, do you count 8 as two noughts?

    • Christine Headley 29th Dec '12 - 3:23am

      @David Goodall

      The good news was yesterday! It’s about half a dozen posts down from this one.

    • Stephen – hope you had good Christmas, and a Happy New Year. Thanks for the work you do for LDV, and in particular, processing these surveys. I am sure you will allow me my mandatory not – so- positive comment! You mention that you have passed on the major issues commented on (presumably negatively?), by members, but there seems nothing in your text or links with any direct quotes from the survey of people’s comments. You have a couple of your own (more balanced) summaries of Clegg and Alexander, and links to individuals’ speeches / reports of action etc. Could we have the quotes, please – unvarnished!

    • Peter Andrews 29th Dec '12 - 10:17pm

      @jedi or it means members interpreted the question to mean that if you lost you Ministerial position then you by definition had a bad year.

    Post a Comment

    Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

    If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

    Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

    *
    *
    Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?




    Recent Comments

    • User AvatarJRC 21st Sep - 12:48am
      Rebecca Hanson, That is completely at odds with my experience of the period and completely at odds with what Thatcher and her ilk said at...
    • User AvatarTim13 21st Sep - 12:22am
      Paul Barker No, your proposition doesn't make sense. Everyone has to be reselected, MP, or PPC. An advert has to go out, under Party rules...
    • User AvatarAllan 21st Sep - 12:11am
      Just my 2 cents First yes we must with haste give Scotland a fair deal Second how many voters do you think in England will...
    • User AvatarMichael Kilpatrick 21st Sep - 12:11am
      Yorkshire Guidon, as someone brought up in Yorkshire (in Sheffield Hallam, to be more precise) I would equally love to see a directly elected and...
    • User AvatarRichard Dean 21st Sep - 12:04am
      For many jobs, there are some criteria which help set the pay rate. Some examples of criteria are: > number of hours/days per week >...
    • User AvatarJohn Innes 20th Sep - 11:36pm
      @Tsar Nicholas Nick Clegg is a particularly bad leader!