The Independent View: Direct democracy in Wales

The idea of recall caught Welsh media attention on Monday, when Kirsty Williams, Welsh Lib Dem leader, made the case for this form of direct democracy to apply to Assembly Members if 20% of local voters signed a petition.

Direct democratic methods such as recall, referendums and petitions are increasingly popular, especially among those who least trust politicians. For many of these citizens, taking control into their own hands is preferable to either creating more politicians (mayors; assemblies) or giving the existing crop more powers. So as Westminster continues to debate a (limited) form of recall, it makes sense for Wales to consider similar measures. After all, Wales suffers a similar disconnect from formal party politics as other parts of UK and actually has the lowest turnout in any devolved elections. Kirsty Williams’ model is an improvement on the current proposal before Westminster, which puts the recall trigger in politicians’ rather than citizens’ hands.

But Kirsty’s speech, given at ERS Cymru’s first Platfform event, went beyond single policies to offer ‘a wholesale, big bang approach to political reform’. Direct democracy was there (recall, American-style propositions and mini-referendums); but so was renewal of existing institutions (more AMs to reflect greater powers, combined with the Single Transferable Vote – ‘the best way to make every vote count’), as were reforms designed to bring voting into the modern era (same-day registration; experimenting with election timing; online voting and extending the franchise to 16 and 17 year olds).

(It was great to hear a Welsh party leader throw down the gauntlet to others to join her in supporting the call for more Assembly Members. Kirsty bases her argument on the need for greater scrutiny, as more powers are devolved. In Size Matters, our report written jointly with the UK’s Changing Union project, we make a detailed case for increasing the number of Assembly members from 60 to 100, drawing on evidence from legislatures elsewhere. Now that Kirsty has shown the Lib Dems’ commitment to this idea, we hope others will follow suit so we can have a mature debate about the levels of representation required for effective scrutiny and accountability.

Another broad theme to emerge was about who is responsible for the health of our democracy. This is a highly relevant issue for those of us keen to see a constitutional convention bring together citizens and politicians as equals, to deliberate and draw up recommendations on identified constitutional issues. For Kirsty, democratic participation includes civic groups taking responsibility for legislative scrutiny, for example by being open with decision-makers about their true opinions of public services and government policy.

Finally, noting her pride in the strength of Liberal Democrats’ internal democracy, Kirsty Williams promised to put her democratic reform package to party conference in Aberystwyth this weekend. Crucially, the package combines institutional and voting changes with ideas for fostering a greater culture of participation outside election periods. From extending the franchise to 16 and 17 year olds to fresh ways to encourage participation, they provide a fantastic starting point for members to debate the future health of our democracy.

* Katie Ghose is the Chief Executive of the Electoral Reform Society

Read more by .
This entry was posted in The Independent View.
Advert

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?

Advert

Recent Comments

  • Tim
    Here is my answer - (600 words ish) - originally appeared in The Economist, reprinted by permission - https://timleunig.substack.com/p/what-to-do-about-fiscal-r...
  • George Thomas
    Residency can become more complex. For example, if my hypothetical sibling is working for the British armed forces stationed abroad but wants to donate to the L...
  • Chloe
    What your up against is voter apathy. So many only turn out to vote in a GE . Mayoral election turnouts hover around 30%. That's on a par with pcc's and in the ...
  • Jana
    I understand why some people believe we need to prevent Reform from getting donations that would allow it to match or even exceed the spending of the main parti...
  • Mohammed Amin
    I agree with David Vigar. While parts of the media have always had poor editorial standards. Conversely the BBC used to be quite good, but has declined signi...