ALDC by-election report: 11 November 2021

Thursday’s by-elections threw up some very interesting results. There was an excellent performance from the Lib Dems in Cardiff, while lots had to be drawn to decide a winner in North Kesteven in Lincolnshire!

Most of all this week we want to credit all Lib Dem candidates and local parties who stood for election and gave voters in their area the opportunity to support a Liberal Democrat on the ballot paper.


We start in Cardiff where candidate Kathryn Lock and the local Lib Dem team achieved a great result in Heath ward on the City Council – increasing the Lib Dem vote share by over 10%, quadrupling the number of votes we received, and jumping from 5th place to 3rd place. An excellent performance!

Ultimately, Labour gained the seat from the local Independent party.

Cardiff City Council, Heath ward

  • Labour: 1729 [47.1%, +16.1%]
  • Conservative: 1128 [30.8%, +2.5%]
  • Lib Dem (Kathryn Lock): 561 [15.3%, +11.5%]
  • Plaid Cymru: 250 [6.8%, +0.5%]

North Kesteven

The best drama of the night was to be had on North Kesteven District Council where three  council seats were being contested and lots had to be drawn to decide the second councillor elected in a double vacancy in Metheringham ward. The Conservatives won the first councillor but tied for second place with the Lincolnshire Independent Party. Lots were drawn and the Lincolnshire Independents won the second seat.

Thank you to Diana Catton for contesting the seat for the Lib Dems. Having not stood in the previous election it was great to have a Lib Dem on the ballot paper this time.

Similarly in Sleaford Castle ward (also on North Kesteven DC) we would like to say thank you to Susan Hislop for giving voters a Lib Dem option in the ward – which was gained by the Conservatives from the Lincolnshire Independents.

Well done and thank you to the Lib Dem team in North Kesteven!

North Kesteven DC, Metheringham ward (double vacancy)

  • Conservative: 424 (elected)
  • Lincolnshire Independent: 404 (elected by drawn lot)
  • Conservative: 404
  • Lincolnshire Independent: 369
  • Labour: 85
  • Labour: 69
  • Lib Dem (Diana Catton): 29

North Kesteven DC, Sleaford Castle

  • Conservative: 135 [42.2%, +10.2%]
  • Labour: 93 [29.1%, -2.9%]
  • Independent (Mason): 49 [15.3%]
  • Independent (Fernandes): 22 [6.9%]
  • Lib Dem (Susan Hislop): 21 [6.6%]


In the South-East, the Green Party held Thanet Villages ward on Thanet District Council. Thank you to Jeremy De Rose for standing for the Lib Dems in this election.

Thanet DC, Thanet Villages ward

  • Green: 638 [60%, +36.8%]
  • Conservative: 358 [33.7%, +8.9]
  • Lib Dem (Jeremy De Rose): 67 [6.3%, -15.7%]


In the Lancaster City Council ward of University & Scotforth Rural Labour held one despite a strong challenge from the Greens. Thank you to the Lib Dem candidate Zanna Ashton for giving a Lib Dem option to voters there.

Lancaster City Council, University & Scotforth Rural ward

  • Labour: 216 [46.1%, +5%]
  • Green: 193 [41.2%, +11%]
  • Conservative: 44 [9.4%, -7.2%]
  • Lib Dem (Zanna Ashton): 16 [3.4%, -8.8%]

Other elections

Finally, there were two further elections on Thursday night, sadly without Lib Dem candidates standing. On Melton Borough Council the Conservatives held Melton Dorian ward. While on Denbighshire County Council Plaid Cymru held the ward of Llandrillo.

Melton BC, Melton Dorian ward

  • Conservative: 362 [56%, +3.9%]
  • Labour: 284 [44%, from nowhere]

Denbighshire CC, Llandrillo ward

  • Plaid Cymru: 179 [44%]
  • Independent: 140 [34.4%]
  • Conservative: 88 [21.6%]

A full breakdown of these results can be found on ALDCs website here.

* Charles Quinn is Campaigns Organiser for ALDC and a local councillor in Hull.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Op-eds.


  • John Marriott 12th Nov '21 - 9:05pm

    I’m afraid that the results in North Kesteven just show what a mountain the Lib Dems need to climb around here. It wasn’t always that bad, although being a non Conservative around here has always been a tough call. There really is no substitute for having a LOCAL candidate, who is prepared to stick at it. Until the party locally recognises this, ritual humiliation will be the result every time.

  • Not brilliant results overall. However, it is worth remembering that the easiest way for Conservatives to increase their vote share is to mop up votes that previously went to UKIP or, in some cases, independent candidates/groups who didn’t appear in by-elections.

  • Kevin Hawkins 13th Nov '21 - 12:02pm

    They may not be brilliant results, but as I have often pointed out on this site you should not get too worked up over one week’s set of by-elections. There is no point in being dismayed at this week’s by-elections any more than you should get excited by last week’s excellent results. At the end of this month (as I have been doing for the past few months) I will produce a longer term analysis of by-elections which will be more meaningful.

  • Sure Kevin. All power to your calculator!

  • John Marriott 13th Nov '21 - 2:24pm

    @Kevin Hawkins
    To quote Oasis, starting “a revolution from my bed” is no substitute for hard work and perseverance!

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Tom Arms
    @daniel Howitt. And if you had read to the end you would know that I am in total agreement with you. But at the same time I think we should all be fully aware, ...
  • Iain Sharpe
    I agree with Ruth Bright. It is curious that nearly half the comments about a review of a book on antisemitism by a British author make reference to Israel as i...
  • Tristan Ward
    "The author believes this is the case for two main reasons, because Jews are seen by progressives as being privileged and not a true ethnic minority and therefo...
  • Daniel Howitt
    Well that started off well and then wandered into the land of Appeasement. The best historical comparison would be Hitler and the the Sudetenland....where Hitle...
  • Tim Rogers
    Immense sympathy for a country sandwiched between the two giants. Indeed often forgotten by world events. I suppose that they will have to balance relations bet...