Author Archives: Stephen Tall

Stephen was Editor (and Co-Editor) of Liberal Democrat Voice from 2007 to 2015, and writes at The Collected Stephen Tall. He writes a fortnightly column for ConservativeHome and 'The Underdog' column for Total Politics magazine. He edited the 2013 publication, The Coalition and Beyond: Liberal Reforms for the Decade Ahead, and is a Research Associate for the liberal think-tank CentreForum. He was awarded the inaugural Lib Dem ‘Blogger of the Year’ prize in 2006, was a councillor for eight years in Oxford, including a year as Deputy Lord Mayor, and appears frequently in the media in person, in print and online. Stephen combines his political interests with his professional life as Development Director for the Education Endowment Foundation, though writes here in a personal capacity.

PMQs: Vince v Gordon

As the party’s acting leader, it was Vince Cable’s turn to put the questions to the Prime Minister at this week’s pointless half-hour of theatrical nonsense. You can watch the exchange here.

Here’s the transcript:

Posted in News and PMQs | Tagged | 41 Comments

The race for the leadership: who’s in, who’s not

Here’s the current position as I understand it, with links where I have them.

Declared:

Chris Huhne
John Hemming

Actively considering:

Nick Clegg
Steve Webb

Unlikely:

Charles Kennedy

Ruled out:

Vince Cable
Ed Davey
Lynne Featherstone
Julia Goldsworthy
Simon Hughes
Susan Kramer
David Laws

(For those interested, the current betting prices can be found here.)

Posted in Leadership Election and News | Tagged , , , , and | 34 Comments

The race to succeed Ming starts today

Who will run? That will be the fascinating question which will be answered in the days ahead. Here’s some of the press speculation today:

Lib Dem leadership bids expected
(BBC)

Charles Kennedy May Run For Leader Again (Glasgow Daily Record)

Two outsiders may run for Lib Dem leader (Daily Telegraph)

Huhne set to launch Lib Dem leadership challenge (Liverpool Daily Echo)

Please use the comments to highlight other stories we may have missed.

Posted in Leadership Election and News | Tagged , and | 26 Comments

Ming: why I quit

Ming Campbell has given a series of interviews this afternoon setting out his reasons for choosing to stand down as Lib Dem leader.

You can watch Ming’s interview with the BBC’s Nick Robinson here.

And here are extracts from Ming’s conversation with Sky News’s Adam Boulton:

MC: … at the end of last week I worked out there had been seven consecutive days of reports in national newspapers about leadership and it became clear to me that if the party was going to make the kind of progress which it deserves and the British people need, it could be

Posted in News | Tagged , and | 10 Comments

The leadership election timetable

16th October: nominations open for the vacancy of leader of the Liberal Democrats. To run, an MP must be nominated by 10% of the Parliamentary party, currently seven MPs; and also by at least 200 party members in 20 local parties.

31st October:
nominations close.

17th November: ballot papers will be sent out to party members.

15th December: last day when ballot papers can be returned.

17th December: the new leader of the Liberal Democrats will be announced.

Posted in News | 2 Comments

New poll: who gave Ming the final push?

Well, the newspaper front pages assert there’s no doubt who is responsible for the downfall of Ming Campbell: Lib Dem ‘plotters’. Which coming from newspapers which have constantly pilloried Ming simply for being in his 60s, and have blown up his light-hearted asides as gaffes, seems to me like breathtaking hypocrisy.

But over to you: who do you think gave Ming the final push? Was it:

– The media;
– The ‘young turks’;
– The bloggers;
– Ming himself;
– The polls;
– Brown and Cameron?

To vote, see the poll in the right-hand column.

Posted in Voice polls | 10 Comments

Hughes rules himself out of contention

Simon Hughes, Lib Dem party president and unsuccessful leadership candidate in 1999 and 2006, has just ruled himself out of contention in an interview on BBC News 24. It was, he said, a decision he took last year.

Posted in News | 34 Comments

Setting the election timetable

Tonight, I think most of us are catching our breaths following the resignation of Ming Campbell as Lib Dem leader.

Though there had been a growing inevitability about it all in the last few days, the speed with which his resignation was brought about was surprising. It’s entirely to Ming’s credit that he foreclosed on the growing speculation before it started seriously to destabilise the party.

The speculation will swiftly turn to what happens next. At this stage, I have only one plea: no swift leadership election.

Whatever follows next needs to be both a contest of ideas, as well as …

Posted in News and Op-eds | 28 Comments

Ming’s resignation letter in full

Here’s the text of the letter Ming Campbell earlier today submitted to Simon Hughes, as President of the Liberal Democrats:

When I was elected Leader of the Party in March 2006 I had three objectives. First, to restore stability and purpose in the party following my predecessor’s resignation and the leadership campaign itself, second to make the internal operations of the party more professional, and third to prepare the party for a General Election.

With the help of others, I believe that I have fulfilled these objectives, although I am convinced that the internal structures of the party need radical revision

Posted in News | Tagged | 17 Comments

It’s over: Ming quits

Here’s the BBC report. More soon…

6.32 pm… It’s official: Simon Hughes and Vince Cable made the announcement at 6.30 pm. Where was Ming? Did he resign, or was he ‘resigned’?

6.46 pm… This quote from The Guardian:

A friend of Sir Menzies told Guardian Unlimited: “This was a very personal decision taken after much reflection. He has been thinking about the decision ever since Gordon Brown took his decision . That was the moment to think about things, talk to one or two people and weigh up whether he wanted to do this.”

6.50 pm… the statement from Vince and Simon …

Posted in News | Tagged | 47 Comments

Is it all down to the leader?

Over at The Guardian’s Comment Is Free blog, Lib Dem blogger of the year, James Graham, analyses the problems facing the party in The fight for survival. It’s well worth reading in full, but here’s an extract:

… the fact that Ming is not the problem. Rather, what we’re seeing is the consequence of a campaign strategy (or lack thereof) that has been focused on winning round swing voters in target seats at the expense of all else. The party’s fundamental problems are the fundamental problems we had under Kennedy – poor communications and a lack of coherence.

Posted in News | 6 Comments

Insert your own quip here

As reported everywhere: a man who left money to the Tory party has been judged not to have been of sound mind at the time.

Posted in News | 3 Comments

Vince on Ming’s leadership: “under discussion, not under threat”

Vince Cable, the Lib Dems’ deputy leader, has had this to say to the BBC about the future of Ming Campbell’s leadership:

“It’s certainly under discussion. But I don’t think it’s under threat and I think the key point for all our activists and MPs and lords is that we shouldn’t panic in what is a very volatile political environment.”

He added: “I remember in the middle of our party conference, which was only a few weeks ago, our leader was being shown in some polls to be more popular than David Cameron. Brown was ruling the roost: he was

Posted in News | Tagged | 8 Comments

Welsh leadership in German’s hands… for a year

Mike German, leader of the Liberal Democrats in the Welsh Assembly, has announced his intention to retire from the post in 2008. This from the BBC:

Mr German said he had “unanimous support” from his colleagues in the assembly to continue as their leader. He is also to stand for the separate role of Welsh Liberal Democrat leader which MP Lembit Opik is to vacate.

“I think it would be wise to do that, to bring the leadership into the National Assembly,” Mr German told BBC Wales’ Politics Show. “I think that was Lembit’s view, and I agree with him,

Posted in News | Tagged | 26 Comments

Top of the Blogs: The Golden Dozen #34

Welcome to the 34th of our weekly round-ups from the Lib Dem blogosphere, featuring the seven most popular stories according to click-throughs from the Aggregator (7th-13th October), together with a hand-picked quintet you might otherwise have missed.

And no prizes for guessing which story has been to the fore this past few days. So, here we go, in descending order of popularity:

Posted in Best of the blogs | 1 Comment

Öpik steps down as Welsh Lib Dem leader

Okay, so we’re a few hours behinds with the news, but I was out having a life. James Graham and Anders Hanson were first up, and here’s what the BBC say:

The leader of the Welsh Liberal Democrats Lembit Opik has announced he is to stand down from the post. He told the party’s autumn conference that he was doing so after six years so that the positions of assembly group leader and Welsh party leader could be decided at the same time. Assembly group leader Mike German is due to announce his intentions about his own future

Posted in News | Tagged and | 2 Comments

Simon on Ming: “must do better”

Lib Dem President Simon Hughes, interviewed for GMTV’s programme on Sunday, has this to say about the party leadership, according to the BBC:

“The leadership is always an issue in all of the parties, we live in a presidential system and therefore the leader has to continually do well and better and he had a good conference,” he said.
“He did a very good speech, it was meant to be the best conference speech he’s made since being leader, and Ming knows that and there’s no sign that he’s not up for that as a task.”
Asked if that meant Sir Menzies

Posted in News | 82 Comments

How many times do we have to say this?

A media lie when repeated often enough becomes the truth. Discuss.

I raise the point because the BBC is now peddling the same rubbish LDV criticised the Grauniad for just a few hours ago:

The Lib Dems’ conference week in Brighton was overshadowed by speculation – denied by all concerned – about possible leadership bids by environment spokesman Chris Huhne and home affairs spokesman Nick Clegg.

This is what is technically known as complete bollocks. The only people speculating about Ming’s future at conference were the media. Lib Dem conference delegates were too busy talking policies, some of which required an attention …

Posted in News | 15 Comments

Two Lib Dem gains from Tories

A brace of good results in last night’s local by-elections in Horsham and Chippenham. Congratulations to Belinda Walters and Mark Packard. Jonathan Wallace has the full figures.

Posted in News | 3 Comments

A message to the gentle folk of the press

And in particular for the benefit of Andrew Pierce of The Daily Telegraph and Hélène Mulholland of The Guardian.

First, please do try and get our name right. It’s simple common courtesy. A look at the mast-head or website address may help. This is Liberal Democrat Voice. We can happily live with Lib Dem Voice. But we are not Liberal Voice. Any more than you are the Torygraph and Grauniad.

Secondly, you say Lib Dem Voice has been “swamped” by grassroots activists demanding Ming quit. I assume you refer to this thread, Lib Dem MP: “We have to think

Posted in News | 6 Comments

Norman’s on the war-path again

Norman Baker, Lib Dem Shadow Minister for the Cabinet Office, and scourge of the Establishment, has called for the head of Sir John Bourn, head of the National Audit Office, who’s racked up £365,000 travel expenses in the last three years:

“It is incredible that Sir John Bourn has seen fit to run up gigantic bills for largesse at the taxpayers’ expense. Even more serious is appearing to accept hospitality from companies such as BAE which compromises the independent and professional standing essential to someone in this post. The time has come for him to call it a day

Posted in News | Tagged | 8 Comments

Who are the most-quoted opposition MPs?

Iain Dale has produced his monthly list of Tory shadow cabinet ‘media tarts’, based on their total number of mentions in the UK newspapers, according to the Lexis-Nexis database.

Rather kindly, he has also compiled the figures for four Lib Dems: Ming Campbell, Nick Clegg, Chris Huhne and Vince Cable.

Merge the two lists, and here’s what we find for September:

1. David Cameron 2527
2. Ming Campbell 701
3. George Osborne 355
4. Nick Clegg 255
5. William Hague 225
6. Chris Huhne 201
7. David Davis 162
8. Vince Cable 152

Yes, that’s right – half of the top eight most-mentioned …

Posted in News | Tagged and | 30 Comments

The power of blogs, or the weakness of journalism?

When does a story become worth reporting? I ask the question in the light of today’s Indy story, ‘Delayed election revives criticism of Lib Dem leader’, which quotes extensively from Jo Hayes’ blog posting, ‘Time to take stock’.

Here’s Jo’s conclusion:

“To go on indefinitely working for our success I need to be sustained by the belief that we have a leader who is a potential Prime Minister. Is it not time that our MPs moved to propose someone new?”

To be clear: I have no problems with what Jo has written, or her decision publicly to speak her …

Posted in News and Op-eds | 26 Comments

PMQs: Ming v Gordon

If you missed today’s heated clashes in the House of Commons, you can watch them on the BBC website here, or listen to them on The Guardian website here.

The exchanges which will be replayed on tonight’s news bulletins are those between Gordon Brown and David Cameron. I was surprised once again by how poorly the Prime Minister performed – today was obviously going to be a tricky day, and it was unlikely he was going to come out of it looking best. But his replies were weak in content and uncertain in delivery. The Tory leader was his usual fluent and witty self, though his tendency to become shrill gave Mr Brown his only good line: “This is the man who wanted an end to the Punch and Judy show!”

The exchange between Ming and Gordon was much shorter – it’s about 12 minutes in, and lasts 90 seconds – and is reproduced below. Both questions are perfectly valid, and make good points. One thing I’ve noticed about Ming’s approach, though, is that he asks very short questions. This has three effects:

(i) What he says tends to get lost in the hubbub, as opposition MPs barrack him. He often ends up sitting down before anyone’s properly heard his question.

(ii) He speaks for a much shorter period of time than Mr Cameron. One of the Tory leader’s questions today was 125 words long, three times the length of Ming’s first question. As a result, Ming rarely gives himself the opportunity to give any context to what the Lib Dem approach would be. For instance, today he mentioned the party’s policy of cutting income tax to 16p. But without explaining that this would be paid for by increasing taxation on pollution and the wealth of the super-rich it handed Mr Brown the too-easy comeback that Lib Dem figures don’t add up.

(iii) A question is in itself unlikely to get replayed on the evening news. The Tory leader uses his time to preface his question with a couple of soundbites, so beloved by broadcast news editors as they can be easily spliced up for that evening’s news package.

Posted in News and PMQs | Tagged | 13 Comments

Vince on the pre-budget report

The BBC’s fairly self-explanatory report – Darling ‘using Lib Dem air tax’ – can be read here.

For those who’d like to enjoy Vince’s wise words in full here they are, brought to you thanks to the wonder that is the online Hansard:

Dr. Vincent Cable (Twickenham) (LD): I thank the Chancellor for an advance copy of his statement, but 12 of the 18 pages were blank. Is that a new signal of open government and transparency? I congratulate him on adopting our long-standing policy on aviation taxation. … May I also sympathise with the Chancellor for having obviously spent the past 72 hours rewriting a speech that was originally intended to be a chapter in the election manifesto, and for having only just recovered from the ignominy of being the first Chancellor of the Exchequer since 1866 to preside over a run on a bank? Not since Black Wednesday has there been such a collapse of confidence in the authority of Government.

Posted in News | 6 Comments

Lib Dem leadership announcement this Sunday

Before those of you outside Wales get too excited… This from the BBC:

The leader of the Liberal Democrats in the Welsh assembly, Mike German, is expected to reveal this weekend whether he wants to remain in the job.

Mr German said he would “probably” announce his decision during his speech at the party’s autumn conference in Aberystwyth on Sunday. He told journalists: “I have come to a conclusion,” and that he was “99%” certain about his decision. But the AM said he would continue to listen to the views of party members.

Mr German has held the role since

Posted in News | Tagged | 6 Comments

Not a good week to be Gordon Brown

First, came Yellow Saturday, when he ditched his plans to call an election

Then, yesterday, the Parliamentary ombudsman criticised the former Chancellor’s own invention, the bureaucratic and complex tax credit system, as being “unfair” to some of the UK’s poorest families.

As Danny Alexander, Lib Dem shadow secretary of state for work and pensions, commented:

“Gordon Brown is incapable of admitting mistakes. His callous disregard for the Ombudsman’s first report, as the title suggests, has led to continued incompetence in the administration of the system.

“Well intentioned policies for low income families are entirely undermined by mass means-testing, chaotic

Posted in News | 3 Comments

Ming on Iraq

I had thought Ming’s House of Commons statement on Iraq yesterday would be up on his website, so wasn’t going to post it on LDV – but as it wasn’t here it is, verbatim, courtesy of Hansard:

Sir Menzies Campbell (North-East Fife) (LD): The Prime Minister began with a tribute to those who have died and been injured. Let me, on behalf of my right hon. and hon. Friends, associate myself with that tribute. Let me, too, as he did, salute the professionalism and bravery of our armed forces—something that is too often taken for granted. The truth is, though, that they were given an impossible task in Iraq. Who now in the Government takes the blame for what the Chief of the Defence Staff called the “false and inflated expectations” of what they could achieve in Iraq?

Posted in News | Tagged | Leave a comment

Oh gawd, now they’re wheeling out Baxter

There’s nothing amateur psephologists and party hacks like more then feeding the latest poll figures into Martin Baxter’s Electoral Calculus seats predictor. Tonight, there’s a small ripple of excitement in the blogosphere as it shows the Lib Dems with zero (0) seats.

From which we can infer two possible conclusions:

1. The Baxter model is nonsensical for three party politics (which is what now de facto exists in the UK);

2. Or the Lib Dems are going to find themselves in a worse position than the Liberal Party in 1979, which retained 11 MPs even after Jeremy Thorpe’s resignation and the

Posted in News | 10 Comments

Colin Breed to stand down

Colin Breed, Liberal Democrat MP for South East Cornwall has announced that he will not seek re-election at the next general election.

Full story over at the ThisIsPlymouth website.

(Hat-tip: Stephen Gilbert commenting on LDV earlier.)

Posted in News and Selection news | Tagged | 18 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Ian Dixon
    While I fully support the long term aim, there is a 2 word rebuttal. Jo Swinson....
  • Dennis
    Completely agreed! This party needs to tap into empowering left-behind communities....
  • David Raw
    I didn't expect to feel sorry for Sir Keir Starmer this morning but I'm afraid I do. I put his downfall down more to the impact and ripples of the Mandelson app...
  • Ynys Mon Man
    Nigel Jones, I am puzzled by the view put forward by many (not just you) that a visit from an MP, no matter how high-profile, will do anything to turn around th...
  • David Garlick
    Vincent spot on as usual....