Author Archives: Stephen Tall

Stephen was Editor (and Co-Editor) of Liberal Democrat Voice from 2007 to 2015, and writes at The Collected Stephen Tall. He writes a fortnightly column for ConservativeHome and 'The Underdog' column for Total Politics magazine. He edited the 2013 publication, The Coalition and Beyond: Liberal Reforms for the Decade Ahead, and is a Research Associate for the liberal think-tank CentreForum. He was awarded the inaugural Lib Dem ‘Blogger of the Year’ prize in 2006, was a councillor for eight years in Oxford, including a year as Deputy Lord Mayor, and appears frequently in the media in person, in print and online. Stephen combines his political interests with his professional life as Development Director for the Education Endowment Foundation, though writes here in a personal capacity.

Norman to fight Lewes again

Congratulations to Norman Baker on being re-selected by his local party in Lewes to contest the constituency for the Lib Dems whenever Gordon dares to go to the polls. Norman was first elected in 1997, when he defeated Tory Tim Rathbone, and was returned in 2005 with a majority of c.8,500, with more than 52% of the vote.

Full story over at the Eastbourne Herald’s website.

Posted in News and Selection news | Tagged | 39 Comments

Lib Dem MP: “We have to think about where we want to be in 18 months’ time”

From today’s Guardian:

there are now also questions over the fate of the Liberal Democrat leader, Sir Ming Campbell, 66, who has failed to push up his party’s fortunes in the opinion polls in recent months. He was chosen in 2006 to provide a safe pair of hands after Charles Kennedy had to resign – but he also has younger MPs who are keen to take the job. …

One Lib Dem MP said last night: ‘This election decision is going to have big ramifications for us all. We will have to take a good hard look at our own party,

Posted in News and Op-eds | Tagged | 68 Comments

Okay, so here come some polls

I do love it when Iain Pravdale gets his knickers in a twist about the failure of Lib Dem Voice to turn itself into the kind of insta-pundit knee-jerk blog he relishes. This time it’s because we haven’t obsessed about the latest AnyansweryouwantGov poll showing the party at 12%.

For the record, LDV has no policy about whether or not it covers individual opinion polls. I guess we’re more likely to highlight one that’s good for the party than the contrary – we’re only human – but to be honest I think there are more interesting and important things to …

Posted in Polls | Tagged | 10 Comments

Heath and Howarth to lead call for fixed-term parliaments

After the fiasco that was Gordon Brown’s ‘Yellow Saturday’, Ming Campbell has just appeared on BBC1’s The Politics Show and announced that two Lib Dem MPs, Davids Heath and Howarth, will this week be presenting a bill in Parliament which would legislate for fixed-term Parliaments.

What will be the Labour and Tory response? After this week, Gordon might be almost relieved to have the decision taken out of his hands. Meanwhile, Dave has said only that it’s something he’ll take a look at some time. It might almost be called a ‘cosy consensus’.

Posted in General Election and News | 17 Comments

Top of the Blogs: The Golden Dozen #33

Welcome to the 33rd of our weekly round-ups from the Lib Dem blogosphere, featuring the seven most popular stories according to click-throughs from the Aggregator (30th September – 6th October), together with a hand-picked quintet you might otherwise have missed.

And – who’d have thought it? – the prospect of an election seems to have been dominating bloggers’ thoughts this week. Which may be why only two of our top seven posts talk about it. Here we go, in descending of popularity:

Posted in Best of the blogs | 3 Comments

So what would you do if you were Gordon?

100 days in power, and the toughest decision yet faces the Prime Minister: does he seek a mandate, or does he delay calling an election?

A week ago, the decision looked a formality. Labour was riding high in the polls on the back of their ‘nobody mention the Blairs’ party conference, and a couple of polls suggesting double-digit leads over the Tories. Spool forward, and it’s all looking a lot less rosy, with a slew of polls indicating a narrowing of Labour’s lead.

If there’s one thing more stupid than taking too much notice of opinion polls, it’s taking no …

Posted in General Election and News | 21 Comments

Dave’s speech: the views of the Lib Dem blogosphere

I’m afraid Lib Dem Voice doesn’t have the access The Guardian does – they were able to ask three Tory shadow cabinet members, as well as two Tory parliamentary candidates, to enthuse just how orgasmically fantastic they thought Dave ‘look mum, no notes’ Cameron’s speech to the Tory conference was. A useful public service, I’m sure you’ll agree.

We’re simply going to point you towards what Lib Dem bloggers have so far said…

(Please use the comments to let me know of any I’ve missed, or any ones subsequently published.)

  • David Nikel: Cameron gets his knickers in a twist
  • Andy Hinton:
  • Posted in Best of the blogs | Tagged | 12 Comments

    Who are the 100 most influential liberals in the UK?

    All week the Torygraph has been running a series listing the top 100 people ‘on the right’ in British politics – it included two Lib Dem MPs as well as the Director of Liberty, Shami Chakrabarti.

    The list’s publication prompts the question: who would feature among the 100 most influential liberals in the UK?

    Clearly, the leading lights of the Liberal Democrats – spokespersons in the Parliamentary party – would feature prominently, together with Lib Dem leaders of some of our larger Councils.

    But who else? Who in the world of politics, business, think tanks, trade unions, the media, pressure …

    Posted in News and Voice polls | 51 Comments

    Lembit attacks Labour’s post offices closure plan

    The list of the first 180 of the 2,500 post offices due to close within the next 15 months has been unveiled. They include:

  • 45 in the East Yorkshire area;
  • 58 in Kent; and
  • 77 in the East Midlands.
  • The full list can be downloaded here.

    The closures have been condemned by Lembit Öpik, Lib Dem shadow secretary of state for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform:

    “These closures are completely unnecessary. It is obvious that there are ways of sustaining post offices without breaking the bank. What’s missing is the Government’s willingness to do so.

    “What is the point in consultation if the views

    Posted in News | Leave a comment

    Laws and Clegg named among 100 most influential figures ‘on the right’

    It seems unlikely that either David Laws or Nick Clegg is going to appreciate appearing on this list, The Right’s 100 Most Influential People, compiled by Iain Dale and Brian Brivati for the Torygraph. David ranks 66th, Nick 44th – here are their profiles:

    66. DAVID LAWS MP
    LibDem Spokesman on Work & Pensions
    Laws was approached by George Osborne to defect last year but he rebuffed the advance. He is probably the most right-leaning LibDem MP and holds distinctly free market views on a whole range of issues.
    His influence will be determined by the degree to which

    Posted in News | Tagged | 11 Comments

    Osborne’s doing the Lambert talk

    From Sky News’s Boulton & Co blog:

    Under the heading “Third party experts back our position”, one release quoted Richard Lambert, head of the CBI saying “the sums mentioned by Mr Osborne may be small for these people.”

    When I contacted the CBI, they were rather surprised to find Lambert had been enlisted as a supporter…. He actually has a much more nuanced position than the press release implied, basically saying Osborne’s policy might work but might not… He neither endorses nor criticises the policy.

    So at the prompting of the CBI, I expect a fresh, “modified” press release to be

    Posted in News | 2 Comments

    Vince blasts “feeble and unfunded” Tory tax plans

    Lib Dem shadow chancellor Vince Cable has criticised the tax plans of his Tory counterpart, George Osborne:

    “Any expectation that the Conservatives had a radical and meaningful plan for fairer taxes has been blown out of the water with this utterly feeble set of half promises and unfunded commitments.

    “The Tories have apparently made a large open-ended commitment without explaining how it will be paid for.

    “They have borrowed from the Liberal Democrats the idea of taking action on non-domicile residents in the UK, but their proposal is completely inadequate and seems to be entirely voluntary.”

    Posted in News | 2 Comments

    What do the Tories have against widows?

    Desperately trying to pull rabbits out of hats ahead of their party conference, David Cameron has proudly trumpeted Tory plans to give tax breaks to married couple families.

    But it’s not just those irresponsible couples who ‘live in sin’ and refuse to conform to the Tory stereotype of who makes good parents who will be penalised – as Vince Cable forcefully notes, so too will widows and widowers struggling to bring up kids on their own:

    “It would appear that the so-called Tory tax cut for families is not a tax cut at all, but an increase in tax credits;

    Posted in News | 5 Comments

    Gordon’s snap poll could cause postal vote chaos

    That’s the warning from John Turner, chief executive of the Association of Electoral Administrators, as reported in today’s Scotsman:

    Turner said: “If there is an autumn election there will be a significant number of administrative problems. I’m fearful of the possibility of things going wrong administratively because of the pressures involved.”

    Concerns centre on the problematic postal voting system, which continues to place election officers under a huge burden. The AEA has called on the Government to change the law to extend the time limit between the dissolution of parliament and an election by at least another five working days

    Posted in General Election | 4 Comments

    Opinion: Will the Gordon backlash start here?

    It’s certainly looking like the cautiously prudent ex-Chancellor is about to prove what a reckless gambler he is now he’s made it to the top, and become Prime Minister.

    The momentum behind an early general election appears to be unstoppable. Having marched his troops to the top of the hill it’s hard to see how Gordon can march them back down again without destroying his credibility as a strong, British leader who is proud of the British strength he has gained in this strong Britain.

    Labour’s dream scenario is of course this: our granite-faced, crisis-tested Prime Minister, having caught his political opponents on the hop, will romp to victory with a bigger majority than Tony Blair achieved in 2005. Which may yet happen.

    But how will the media, and indeed the public, react to a cut-and-run election from a man who has carefully cultivated his image as the anti-Blair, an unspun, straight-talking dour doer? Mr Brown has deliberately spent the last three months trying to lose the reputation for slick opportunism Labour acquired under his predecessor. How will he justify his rush to the polls at the first sniff of victory?

    Posted in General Election and Op-eds | 11 Comments

    Trouble brewing for Tories?

    Sky News’s Jon Craig is trumpeting the news that Buckinghamshire Tory MP, John Bercow, will not be attending his party’s conference in Blackpool next week.

    For some time now, he’s been billed as the Tory most likely to cross the floor and join Quentin Davies on the Labour benches. Bercow’s absence is ‘fuelling speculation’ ((c) all media organisations everywhere when trying to justify passing on hearsay).

    More interesting is Jon’s last para:

    In a further sign of turmoil and panic in the Conservative Party, Shadow Home Secretary and defeated leadership candidate David Davis has cancelled all his appearances at fringe

    Posted in News | 10 Comments

    It’s Boris!

    Yes, ‘the blondest suicide note in history’ has romped home to victory in the Tories’ London mayoral primary. The results were:

  • Boris Johnson: 15,661 votes
  • Victoria Borwick: 1,869
  • Andrew Boff: 1,674
  • Warwick Lightfoot: 609
  • The vote was open to all seven million of London’s voters, so it’s good to see a super turn-out of 0.2%.

    As LDV reported last week, though, the Tories may just have cut their own throats. And anyone who listened to Boris being interviewed on BBC Radio 4’s Today Programme this morning might be forgiven for wondering how on earth the Tories think they’ll sustain a credible campaign with …

    Posted in News | Tagged | 12 Comments

    A rogue poll, or are we kidding ourselves?

    There’s no point obsessing about every poll, but… having reported last week’s ICM survey for The Guardian showing the Lib Dems with a 20% share of the vote, balance compels me to mention tonight’s Channel 4 YouGov poll showing the Lib Dems with just 13%, the party’s lowest YouGov rating since January 2006.

    YouGov has (as Lib Dem chief executive Chris Rennard remarked on LDV last week) been consistently recording lower vote-shares for the Lib Dems than other pollsters for some months now.

    Personally, I find it hard to believe that – if this poll is accurate …

    Posted in Polls | Tagged | 8 Comments

    Warning: this post contains traces of Iain Dale

    In all my excitement yesterday at the posting on Iain Dale’s Diary of Iain Dale’s Guide to Blogging 2007: Top 100 Liberal Democrat Blogs – an article trailing the publication this week of Iain Dale’s Guide To Political Blogging In The UK, edited by Iain Dale – I forgot to mention that Iain Dale’s Guide To Political Blogging In The UK also includes articles not by Iain Dale.

    The following four chapters are by Lib Dem contributors:

  • Blogging: what’s in it for political parties? – Mark Pack
  • Why MPs Should Blog! – Lynne Featherstone MP
  • The state of Lib Dem
  • Posted in Online politics | Tagged and | 3 Comments

    Tories suspend Andrew Pelling MP

    The Tory MP for Croydon Central, Andrew Pelling, who is also a member of the Greater London Assembly, has been suspended from the Tory party, following his arrest last week on suspicion of assaulting his wife.

    This is the Tory statement as reported by the BBC:

    “Following a meeting today with the Chief Whip, Andrew Pelling’s case has been referred to the Conservative Party’s Ethics and Integrity Committee. Until a conclusion is reached, he has been suspended from the Conservative Party Whip.”

    Posted in News | 3 Comments

    Vince hits out at Gordon’s ‘Big Tentism’

    Lib Dem deputy leader Vince Cable has delivered a typically withering-yet-courteous assessment of Gordon Brown’s determination to assemble a ‘government of all the talents’.

    Speaking at a Fabian Society fringe meeting at the Labour party conference in Bournemouth, he’s quoted by the BBC saying:

    “I am concerned about what I would regard as big tentism – this attempt to get everybody into the same fold. I think it is an attempt to create – in the nicest possible way – a one-party state.”

    He likened Mr Brown to Jomo Kenyatta, former president of Kenya, for whom he once worked and

    Posted in News | 5 Comments

    Another Tory defection to Labour

    Calm down, nothing too exciting – one of Dave’s A-listers, Judith Symes, has crawled inside Gordon’s big tent. She stood for the Tories in Brighton Kemptown in 2005, coming within 2,373 votes of unseating the sitting Labour MP. The Brighton Argus has more. (Hat-tip to Guido.)

    Posted in News | 3 Comments

    Liam Byrne: a minister who should make Labour members ashamed of their own government

    Last week, the Lib Dem conference overwhelmingly approved plans drawn up by Nick Clegg and Simon Hughes to tackle the issue of the estimated 600,000 immigrants currently living in the UK illegally – they would be able to earn British citizenship if they could prove they had no criminal record and could show a long-term commitment to the country.

    The proposal earned praise from The Economist, which said “the plan looks more credible than the government’s commitment to deport all illegal immigrants, something which at the current rate would take at least 25 years.”

    The response

    Posted in News | 8 Comments

    On your way to the Forum?

    If you’re a party member you can register to use the members’ forum – our place to say whatever’s on your mind without the danger of it being misquoted (or quoted out of context or quoted all too bloody accurately) on opposition leaflets.

    Topics currently being discussed include:

  • Will there be a snap election?
  • Sharia law
  • That referendum
  • Why join the lib dems
  • Decommisioning laws
  • Brighton feedback
  • Candidate selection
  • Taking on the BNP

    Remember, it’s good to talk.

  • Posted in Site news | 2 Comments

    Is Iain Dale being fair?

    As Mark Pack notes below, Tory uber-blogger Iain Dale has taken a bit of a swipe at Lib Dem Voice in his run-down of the top 100 Lib Dem blogs. Here’s what he says:

    One of the sadder developments in the LibDem blogosphere this year has been the decline of LibDem Voice. At one stage it looked as if it might disappear altogether when its creator, Rob Fenwick, decided he had had enough. In the end a collective of libdems bloggers including Mark Pack, Stephen Tall and Ryan Cullen came to the rescue. It does seem, however, to have

    Posted in Online politics | Tagged | 27 Comments

    Public split on EU reform treaty

    Well, here’s a turn-up for the books. According to an Ipsos-Mori poll in today’s Sun, the country is split about whether they would vote to back or reject the EU reform treaty:

    The result of a referendum would be a nail-biter with 46 per cent saying they would reject the Treaty and 44 per cent backing it.

    The poll also asked how people would vote if there were a referendum on whether Britain should stay in the EU. It showed 56 per cent wanting to stay in and 44 per cent wanting to get out.

    Given the fevered anti-EU press the treaty …

    Posted in News and Polls | 1 Comment

    Top of the Blogs: The Golden Dozen #31

    Welcome to the 31st of our weekly round-ups from the Lib Dem blogosphere, featuring the seven most popular stories according to click-throughs from the Aggregator (16th-22nd September), together with a hand-picked quintet you might otherwise have missed.

    And it’s all a little less conference-dominated than I expected. Here you go, in descending order of popularity:

    Posted in Best of the blogs | Leave a comment

    Telegraph: Tories in marginals tell unpopular Cameron to stay away

    The Daily Telegraph today details some of the internal unhappiness in the Tory party with their leader, David Cameron – the least popular national party leader according to recent opinion polls.

    The article is headlined ‘Tory pressure as David Cameron effect fades’, and claims:

    Mr Cameron’s standing in some marginal seats is so bad that some Tory candidates have requested that their leader does not visit them during an election campaign. It is an extraordinary turnaround for a man once hailed as the saviour of the party.

    The paper also reports on the latest activities of Lord Ashcroft, Tory deputy chairman, who …

    Posted in News | Tagged and | Leave a comment

    There’s a few Tory votes Boris has lost

    An interesting e-mail was sent to Lib Dem Voice a couple of days ago from the managing director of a top city firm. It’s fairly self-explanatory:

    Dear Liberal Democrats

    I am a fully paid up member of the Conservative Party and will NOT be voting for Boris Johnson who is very likely to get the Party’s nomination. He comes across an unkempt, bumbling journalist with just witty soundbites and NOT the Face of London we need to kick The Living Stone into touch. I and many of my Tory friends will be voting for your candidate .

    I thought this would please you

    Posted in News | Tagged | 1 Comment

    Opinion: Is political journalism broken?

    The Lib Dem conference felt united this year. I’m not talking about our policies – heaven forfend. No, we were united against the media’s reporting of our conference, which was, almost without exception, drearily inane, pathetically irrelevant and lazily inaccurate.

    Sitting on the train back from Brighton, I overheard one Hampstead-chic journalist talk about why she chose her profession. It was, she said, because she wanted to change the world, and the media is so much more able than politicians to make people sit up and take notice. Noble sentiments, indeed.

    But how far do she and her journalist colleagues live up to this enlightenment standard?

    I’m not going to indulge in a rant, tempting though it is, dissecting each and every injustice inflicted on the Lib Dems by the media in the past week.

    And I’m aware that the conference can sometimes become a self-deluding bubble, with party members snuggling up together in comfort-blanket group-think. Think IDS’s last Tory conference as leader in 2003, his speech interrupted by an absurd 20 standing ovations. Or think CK’s last Lib Dem conference in 2005, when members returned from Blackpool bemused by claims his leadership was being questioned by our MPs.

    However, I’m confident this time was different. Why?

    Posted in Op-eds | 7 Comments
    Advert

    Recent Comments

    • Matt (Bristol)
      I don't know whether I should tempt David Raw further into liberal history, but the clamour for Burnham as PM after a constituency election, to oust the leading...
    • Neil Hickman
      To an extent, I'm reminded of the line "Nothing became him in this life so much as his manner of leaving it". But like Jennie, I don't feel sorry for Starmer. ...
    • Jennie
      Mostly what David Raw said, but I don't feel sorry for Starmer. He promised change. He traded on people's hopes. And then in almost everything he's either conti...
    • Roland
      @David Raw - “ I didn’t expect to feel sorry for Sir Keir Starmer this morning but I’m afraid I do.” I agree, the winners in all this have been the me...
    • Ian Dixon
      Hi David. I mean that in a desperate attempt to find clear yellow water, and that looks a lot worse in print than I meant! She committed the party to overturnin...