There has been no shortage of criticism directed at Carl Cashman over the past few days following his appearance as the cover star of Attitude magazines Pride edition. Yet, looking at much of the reaction, I cannot help but conclude that there is more than a hint of the green-eyed monster at work.
The truth is that many of those complaining would love to have Carl’s reach, his charisma and his ability to connect with audiences far beyond the traditional Liberal Democrat bubble. His interview is an excellent one. He speaks about the importance of promoting positive masculinity to young men, something desperately needed in an era when too many are being lured towards toxic online influences. He stands unapologetically alongside trans people at a time when far too few politicians – sadly, even within our own party – seen prepared to do so publicly. He criticises former leader Tim Farron’s stance on gay sex after losing the leadership, reflects honestly on the shortcomings of the Conservative-Liberal Democrat 2010-15 Coalition government, and consistently roots his politics in the liberal belief that individuals should be able to live their lives without unnecessary interference as long as doing so doesn’t stop others from doing the same.
That is liberalism with conviction.
When I sat down with Carl in Liverpool late last year for what became the first longform interview that he gave – available in three parts on this site – I came away convinced that his political future looked to be exceptionally bright. Nothing that has happened since has changed that judgement. If anything, it had reinforced it.
Of course Carl is undeniably photogenic. Politics has always rewarded people who communicate visually as well as verbally. But reducing his success to his appearance misses the point entirely.
The real reason he is becoming such an effective communicator is that he does not look, sound or behave like what many peoplr imagine a Liberal Democrat politician to be. He reaches parts of the electorate that the rest of us often struggle to engage. He’s authentic, comfortable in his own skin and able to communicate liberal values in a language that resonates well beyond Westminster or party conference. That is a gift.
Rather than grumbling abour his prominence or trying to ignore it, the party nationally should be asking itself a very simple question: how do we get Carl Cashman onto our TV screens and radio more often?
Politics is ultimately about persuading people. If someone is capable of doing that, we should celebrate it rather than resent it.
I very much hope he becomes Leader of Liverpool City Council next year. But I also hope that, before too very long, he is elected to Westminster and who knows where things go from there? Maybe one day he’ll lead our great party.
Liberalism needs compelling advocates who can take our message to audiences we do not usually reach. Carl Cashman is proving to be exactly that.
Keep soaring, Carl.
Who Speaks for the Victims?
I like Max Wilkinson, our Home Office Spokesman. He has much to offer the party.
But I believe he’s got this one badly wrong.
Calling for longer pub opening hours for England’s World Cup matched may sound like a harmless boost for hospitality, yet it seems to overlooked the wider consequences. Police leaders have warned that England games are associated with increases in violence and domestic abuse linked to alcohol consumption, while extended licensing places additional pressure on already stretched emergency services.
Supporting our pubs matters. But so does asking what happens after the final whistle. Who is thinking of the police officers working longer shifts? The A&E staff? Above all, who is thinking about those who may face violence behind closed doors?
Liberalism should always champion freedom, but it must also recognise responsibility and protect the most vulnerable. On this occasion, I fear our party has focused too narrowly on the one and forgotten the other.
Keep Cool, Keep Safe
This week’s expected heatwave is no joke. Drink plenty of water, avoid the strongest midday sun, check in on older or vulnerable neighbours, and don’t overdo it. Heat can be dangerous, especially for those with health conditions. Enjoy the sunshine, yes – but stay sensible, cool and well.
* Mathew Hulbert is a former Councillor, is a regular commentator on TV and Radio, and is Co-Host of the Political Frenemies podcast.


