Nick Clegg’s speech on NHS reforms: “We’ve listened, we’ve learned”

Nick Clegg has given a speech today at a joint press conference with David Cameron and Andrew Lansley, on NHS reform and the results of the listening exercise.

This comes on the morning that a Telegraph leader declared:

The Lib Dem conference changed everything. Grass roots activists made it clear to Nick Clegg that they would not accept the wider involvement of the private sector championed by Mr Lansley or what they considered to be his undue emphasis on competition. Ever since, the reforms have been in trouble and the three-month “pause” ordered by Mr Cameron sealed their fate. The NHS Future Forum established to review the proposals has now recommended changes that essentially neutralise the central intent of the Bill, which was to remove Whitehall from decisions that should better be made by clinicians on the front-line.

Nick’s speech in full:

We all know how important the NHS is to the British people. It isn’t just a system; it’s isn’t just a service. The NHS says something about who we are: A nation that cares for its citizens when they need it, whatever their means.

It’s a people’s health service. Paid for by the people, owned by the people, and dedicated to the people.

So the NHS debate has never just been about policy. It’s about our values, our identity. That’s why there’s been so much passion, so much feeling, throughout this exercise. And that should give us all reason to be proud. Because it shows we care.

Where we do all agree is that the NHS needs to change. For all the reasons David talked about, the question has never been whether to reform, but how to reform. We didn’t get that right straight away. But, you told us what to do differently. We listened. And now we have a plan I hope we can all get behind.

You told us you were worried about privatisation through the back door. So we have made that impossible.

Yes, diversity can drive up quality and increase choice. And the NHS has always had a mix of providers. But competition will not be encouraged for its own sake. Only where it clearly benefits patients.

We’re introducing additional safeguards on price competition and cherry-picking. As well as making it illegal, now and in the future, to favour the private sector – or indeed any type of provider. What matters is what works for patients – getting the right provider, doing the best job.

You told us the different bits of the NHS need to be better joined up. So we’re putting integration at the heart of our reforms.

Patients aren’t happy being sent here, there and everywhere for the same condition. Feeling like no one has a handle on the overall picture. That’s why integration will now be at the top of Monitor’s agenda. And there’ll be a strengthened duty on GPs and other professionals to work closely with other local services, like, importantly, social care.

You also told us services should be more accountable to local people. More responsive to local needs. So they will be.

GPs are an important part of the answer, but not all of it. That’s why we wanted elected councillors to sit on Health and Wellbeing boards. And why we will now be giving those boards much more influence over care in their areas.

I also strongly welcome the NHS Future Forum’s recommendation yesterday. That local commissioning boundaries should not normally cross those of local authorities. Helping us to join up local health and social care services as well.

Finally, you told us not to rush. The NHS isn’t a machine. You can’t flick a switch and turn it on and off. It’s a living, breathing part of our lives. The NHS is all of us, millions of us – patients, doctors, nurses. It exists in every single community. At some point it touches every single one of us.

Reforming an institution like that takes time. We have to be careful and considered. It’s too important to get this wrong. So change will happen at the right pace. And that’s why the arbitrary deadlines have gone.

No switch-on-switch-off date for clinician-led commissioning. Clinical commissioning groups will only take on responsibility for budgets by April 2013 if they are ready and willing. If not, the NHS Commissioning Board will do so on their behalf, until they can do it themselves. No overnight, universal extension of Any Qualified Provider. Any Qualified Provider gives patients their pick of licensed providers within the NHS. And, where it exists already, it’s working well. Providing much greater choice, for example, for hundreds of thousands of patients needing operations every year.

But we shouldn’t pretend it works everywhere. And we should extend it in a more phased, more sensible way.

And, while we’re on deadlines: No rushing the legislation through parliament. We paused the Bill to get this right. Now that we’ve changed it, the Bill will go back to Committee in the House of Commons. So that MPs – who represent millions of patients – can scrutinise it properly.

We’ve listened, we’ve learned, and we’re improving our plans for the NHS.

Yes to patient choice. No to privatisation. Yes to giving nurses, hospital doctors and family doctors more say in your care.

No to heavy-handed, top-down restructuring of the NHS.

The right reforms – much needed reforms – at the right pace.

Evolution, not revolution.

I want to thank the NHS Future Forum for the excellent report they produced for the three of us. Professor Field’s opening letter is the best description I have read in a long time of everything we cherish about our NHS. As well as the task we face in meeting the challenges ahead.

And I want to thank every patient, every clinician, every NHS manager, every nurse who told us where we didn’t quite get it right the first time. And where our proposals could be improved.

I know that many of those people are now eager for us to get on with this. Pausing the legislation was an unusual step. But this is a Government that won’t take risks with something as important as our NHS.

And it’s a different kind of Government too – a coalition. Where different voices are heard. Where we’re not afraid to disagree, to have the debate, to bring together the best of our ideas. That’s coalition; that’s good government. It’s how you take the right decisions. And it’s how we’re protecting our NHS.

Read more by or more about , , , or .
This entry was posted in News and Speeches.


  • Jedi… I disagree. The only way to sensibly reduce the amount of direct treatment required by people is through early prevention and holistic methods of care. More collaboration and integration with social care is vital for this to work.

    Competition doesn’t always make things cheaper in the long run. Where it has happened already within the NHS there have been plenty of cases where the lack of overall co-ordination, or just shoddy performance has led to the NHS having to re-treat many patients who have reached a worse state than they should have needed to.

  • Matthew Huntbach 16th Jun '11 - 9:46pm

    Nick Clegg

    For all the reasons David talked about, the question has never been whether to reform, but how to reform. We didn’t get that right straight away. But, you told us what to do differently. We listened.

    No, no, NO! Can’t this man get anything right? With his role in this he was just beginning to win back some of the support he lost, but now he’s using just the wrong words.

    We don’t want to give the impression that we NEED to listen to what the people say before getting things right. What we want is for people to believe we are close enough to them that we ALREADY get it right – and in this case we knew that all along and pushed for it in government for that reason. Clegg here is now throwing away the good work done in distancing ourselves from the Tories. These words give the impression we are some sort of aliens who need to be told what ordinary people think. No, no, NO!!! We must give the impression of being a party OF THE PEOPLE!!

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • User AvatarDavid 21st Aug - 5:57pm
    Good article, but disagree the Liberal Democrats don't have radical policies - we do need to push them more - ending the Benefits Freeze, will...
  • User AvatarDavid Raw 21st Aug - 5:44pm
    @ TCO "Yet in 1980 Jo Grimond wrote “Liberals must stress at all times the virtues of the market, not only for efficiency but to...
  • User AvatarMichael BG 21st Aug - 5:24pm
    TCO, On the 19th August you suggested five policies which I assume think should be the core of our message once Brexit has been dealt...
  • User AvatarDavid Raw 21st Aug - 5:23pm
    @ Geoffrey Dron Yes, Geoffrey, I've read the Due North Report..... not surprising given I was brought up in West Yorkshire. As a former Convener...
  • User AvatarInnocent Bystander 21st Aug - 5:21pm
    Joe, Elliot is right on the problems but offers the usual trite and feeble solutions in response. "Invest in infrastructure and whatever is the latest...
  • User AvatarJohn Marriott 21st Aug - 4:39pm
    @Tom Harney Bonn became the provisional capital of West Germany as it was hoped that reunification would take place within a few years, with Berlin...
Sat 24th Aug 2019
Thu 29th Aug 2019
Mon 9th Sep 2019