+++Now Sam Gyimah sings “The Land” at Glee Club

Sam Gyimah is the third recent defecting MP to get up on stage this evening at the Glee Club. He said that his wife had told him that under no circumstances should he try to sing. But, bless him, he joined in singing “The Land” as our video below shows. So he is now the third defecting MP to do his initiation and become a proper Liberal.

Congratulations to Sam!

* Paul Walter is a Liberal Democrat activist. He is currently taking a break from his role as one of the Liberal Democrat Voice team. He blogs at Liberal Burblings.

Read more by or more about or .
This entry was posted in Conference and Humour.


  • So Sam is a “proper Liberal” for singing a song about a policy the party formally abandoned in the 1920’s ? Is it a case of Luke 15:7 ???? “I say unto you, that likewise joy shall be in heaven over one sinner that repenteth, more than over ninety and nine just persons, which need no repentance” or is it a case of a bit of over excited purple hyperbole ? Time will tell, on Sam and what the Liberal Democrats will become.

    Interesting to look at the record on ‘They work for you “. How Sam Gyimah voted on Welfare and Benefits :

    Generally voted for reducing housing benefit for social tenants deemed to have excess bedrooms (which Labour describe as the “bedroom tax”)
    12 votes for, 0 votes against, 6 absences, between 2011–2018

    Consistently voted against raising welfare benefits at least in line with prices
    0 votes for, 5 votes against, in 2013

    Almost always voted against paying higher benefits over longer periods for those unable to work due to illness or disability 0 votes for, 11 votes against, 4 absences, between 2011–2016

    Consistently voted for making local councils responsible for helping those in financial need afford their council tax and reducing the amount spent on such support 4 votes for, 0 votes against, in 2012

    Almost always voted for a reduction in spending on welfare benefits
    47 votes for, 0 votes against, 7 absences, between 2012–2016

    Almost always voted against spending public money to create guaranteed jobs for young people who have spent a long time unemployed 0 votes for, 8 votes against, 1 absence, between 2011–2014.

  • @ Tim Hill I’m afraid I do live in the real world, Tim, as do all the people affected by those votes for whom it is a very cruel world with not much to sing about.

  • Thank you, David Raw – if ever I was tempted to support the LibDems, it would be people like you who would win me over.

    The Liberal Democrats – inverted commas now – are heading in a very bad direction at present.

    What the hell happened to having a set of principles, and sticking by them?

  • bob sayer 17th Sep ’19 – 9:08am…….The usual suspects……

    That appears to be the crux of your argument. I remember heaing that comment when Nick Clegg was destroying this party’s credibility. We were disloyal, lacking faith and we watched as the prevailing mood went from “too early” to change to “too late” without passing through the “right time”. Under Jo Swinson this party seems intent on making the same mistakes in who/what it embraces.
    You quote “A sinner repenteth seems to be a good place to start” ;may I respectfully point out that the old adage about ‘Leopards and Spots’might be more appropriate

  • Alex Macfie 17th Sep '19 - 9:41am

    @expats: FFS Just move on from Clegg. Our approach now under Jo is actually the exact opposite of the Clegg approach.

  • Whatever the merits or otherwise of our new recruits and I for one welcome them the original post from Paul was meant to be light-hearted and was just showing someone enjoying themselves at conference.

    Can we just lighten up a bit for goodness sake and save the more intense posts for other news items.

  • expats: I think you miss the point about the biblical quote concerning leopards and their spots; that being that humans can think and change their minds and behaviour whereas animals can’t. (May not be true but the bible was written a long time ago)

  • Sue Sutherland 17th Sep '19 - 1:08pm

    I think the Glee Club is the beating heart of Liberalism and, thus, Lib Demery because it expresses creativity, satire and the fun of laughing at ourselves. If we lose that we will have lost our political soul and all hope of speaking truth to power, especially when we wield it ourselves. A lot of people left the party in the Clegg years but we hear little about that from David Raw and Jayne Mansfield who comments on the previous post. I agree with them both that we let people down when we were in Coalition but we were dealing with the worst financial crisis since the 1930s and had no hope of persuading the Tories to adopt a different set of policies to deal with it. Indeed, there was little in the way of alternatives in economic practice to use to combat a crisis because Keynesian theory was discredited back in the 70s.
    I want to persuade our party that poverty represents the greatest threat to Liberalism at the moment and the party has made a start by passing the policy paper A Fairer Share for All. Perhaps David and Jayne would like to join or rejoin and get involved in furthering policies which will help people living on benefits. Our 2017 manifesto was better for the poor than Labour’s. I think we are building on that.

  • Andrew McCaig 17th Sep '19 - 3:00pm

    Well said Sue.

    I was a “rejoiner” in 2015. There is always plenty to criticise about our Party, but it is still my home..

  • Andrew McCaig 17th Sep '19 - 4:34pm

    Excellent speech by Jo. I like the idea of the wellbeing budget. We need to get away from the measures of economic growth that put things that are bad for people on the plus side of the scales.

    Takes me back to reading EF Schumacher as a student

  • Sean Hyland 17th Sep '19 - 4:47pm

    ” Austerity is the belief that the global financial crash of 2008 was caused by there being too many libraries in Wolverhampton ” – Alexei Sayle.

    I would welcome any relook about how our economy should work.

  • @ Paul Walter Thanks for the reassurance Paul. I hope it’s a long life bulb.

  • David Warren 17th Sep '19 - 5:38pm

    @Sue Sutherland Can I suggest that you put yourself forward in the forthcoming election for Party President.

  • Sue,
    Keynesian theories fell into disrepute because they made little sense when the factories were in Birmingham and the customers in China. Now it’s the other way round it’s economic suicide.
    But it’s all right because the world is going to be astonished by Britain’s economic miracle thanks to
    1. invest in skills and infrastructure
    2. support the latest techno doo-hickey, whatever it is.
    3. the National St Jude Investment Bank

  • David Raw presents a consistently dyspectic and curmudgeonly message on this site. He must be doing wonders for recruitment.

  • Paul Griffiths 17th Sep '19 - 8:21pm

    Alas, seeing some Glee Club videos now being shared on Twitter and the replies beneath, I fear it may be time for this tradition to be put to rest. Autre temps, autre moeurs.

  • Roger Harcourt 18th Sep '19 - 8:34pm

    I was Sam’s headmaster at his comprehensive school in Hertfordshire. Sam is a fine and principled man whom I met again recently at the House of Commons.

    I think we should all understand the constraints of party membership, and how occasionally we might need to vote against our better nature for the sake of party discipline.

    Sam is a brilliant addition to our party.

  • A broad-based Liberal party, with all its respectful debate, and ebb & flow of liberal perspectives and traditions can achieve so much more than a minor coalition partner or 3rd, 4th largest opposition party! If it’s worth fighting for, it’s worth uniting for!

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?


Recent Comments

  • Robert Hale
    Out of interest, is it possible when being sworn in as a new member of parliament to make a non-religious declaration?...
  • Steve Trevethan
    Stephanie Kelton’s book, “The Deficit Myth” is well worth reading, not least for its emphasis on the greater use-value of skilled/educated people rather t...
  • Mick Taylor
    I am puzzled by Steve Trevethan's reference to the deficit myth. The deficit myth, as I understand it from Stephanie Kelton's book of the same name, is the idea...
  • David Le Grice
    The first thing that should really be tackled is the inequity of pay within the public sector where many public sector bodies will pay less than others for role...
  • Mark ValladaresMark Valladares
    George, There is a limit to how much people are willing to sacrifice in order to work in the public sector, if their skillset is attractive to the private se...