Tag Archives: Ming Campbell

Ming’s resignation letter in full

Here’s the text of the letter Ming Campbell earlier today submitted to Simon Hughes, as President of the Liberal Democrats:

When I was elected Leader of the Party in March 2006 I had three objectives. First, to restore stability and purpose in the party following my predecessor’s resignation and the leadership campaign itself, second to make the internal operations of the party more professional, and third to prepare the party for a General Election.

With the help of others, I believe that I have fulfilled these objectives, although I am convinced that the internal structures of the party need radical revision

Posted in News | 17 Comments

PMQs: Ming v Gordon

If you missed today’s heated clashes in the House of Commons, you can watch them on the BBC website here, or listen to them on The Guardian website here.

The exchanges which will be replayed on tonight’s news bulletins are those between Gordon Brown and David Cameron. I was surprised once again by how poorly the Prime Minister performed – today was obviously going to be a tricky day, and it was unlikely he was going to come out of it looking best. But his replies were weak in content and uncertain in delivery. The Tory leader was his usual fluent and witty self, though his tendency to become shrill gave Mr Brown his only good line: “This is the man who wanted an end to the Punch and Judy show!”

The exchange between Ming and Gordon was much shorter – it’s about 12 minutes in, and lasts 90 seconds – and is reproduced below. Both questions are perfectly valid, and make good points. One thing I’ve noticed about Ming’s approach, though, is that he asks very short questions. This has three effects:

(i) What he says tends to get lost in the hubbub, as opposition MPs barrack him. He often ends up sitting down before anyone’s properly heard his question.

(ii) He speaks for a much shorter period of time than Mr Cameron. One of the Tory leader’s questions today was 125 words long, three times the length of Ming’s first question. As a result, Ming rarely gives himself the opportunity to give any context to what the Lib Dem approach would be. For instance, today he mentioned the party’s policy of cutting income tax to 16p. But without explaining that this would be paid for by increasing taxation on pollution and the wealth of the super-rich it handed Mr Brown the too-easy comeback that Lib Dem figures don’t add up.

(iii) A question is in itself unlikely to get replayed on the evening news. The Tory leader uses his time to preface his question with a couple of soundbites, so beloved by broadcast news editors as they can be easily spliced up for that evening’s news package.

Posted in News and PMQs | 13 Comments

Ming on Iraq

I had thought Ming’s House of Commons statement on Iraq yesterday would be up on his website, so wasn’t going to post it on LDV – but as it wasn’t here it is, verbatim, courtesy of Hansard:

Sir Menzies Campbell (North-East Fife) (LD): The Prime Minister began with a tribute to those who have died and been injured. Let me, on behalf of my right hon. and hon. Friends, associate myself with that tribute. Let me, too, as he did, salute the professionalism and bravery of our armed forces—something that is too often taken for granted. The truth is, though, that they were given an impossible task in Iraq. Who now in the Government takes the blame for what the Chief of the Defence Staff called the “false and inflated expectations” of what they could achieve in Iraq?

Posted in News | Leave a comment

General election news: what the Lib Dem bloggers say

Posted in General Election and News | Also tagged , , and | 2 Comments

What the pundits say

Ming can breath a sigh of relief. It’s not just the Lib Dem conference delegates and blogosphere which have lauded his speech – even the media, which has delighted in reporting a conference taking place in an alternative parallel universe all week, has been forced to admit his speech was pretty damn good:

… the moment he stalked onto the stage, dropped the niceties and got stuck in to the state of Britain under Labour, the Lib Dem leader reminded his party why they had chosen him 18 months ago, and why they would be mad to drop him now.

If the catch-all criticism is that he’s too old, then he was right to declare that he would make a campaigning virtue of his 66 years. That wisdom and experience come with age may be a truism, but the point remains valid. On stage he looked more relaxed and at ease with his party. This time he avoided the awkward change-a-lightbulb waves. The speech was fluid, built of complete sentences, and even if some of passages were hackneyed beyond belief, the overall effect was a powerful answer to the doubters. He remains true to himself, has a plan, a set of liberal beliefs in an illiberal age, and some policies.

Ben Brogan, Daily Mail

Sir Menzies is not a natural tub-thumper, but he is evidently decent and has gained in both experience and confidence. This was a better performance than last year. … Ming is a happy warrior and will go home content. It has not been a bad week after all.

Michael White, The Guardian

Today reminded his party that they picked him not despite his age, but because of his experience and judgement. … spoke today of his energy and determination, of his anger, and his unwillingness to be silenced. His party responded. … he spelt out detailed policies on the environment and taxation, and his commitment to protect civil liberties.

Nick Robinson, BBC

Posted in Conference | Also tagged , , and | 6 Comments

Ming’s speech: what did you think?

Ming Campbell has just finished his second speech to the Liberal Democrat conference as party leader.

My impressions… Ming seemed far more assured than last year. He opened strongly – no attempt to start with a scripted joke – and gave a defiant definition of his liberalism, and how the Lib Dems will translate that into action under his leadership. This year, too, he seemed confident enough to tear his eyes away from the autocue.

What pleasantly surprised me in particular was his emphasis on liberal values: “the price of freedom is the risk of offence”; “A truly liberal society guarantees the …

Posted in Conference | 10 Comments

The Grauniad – pathetic, just pathetic

I expect this kind of thing of downmarket right-wing tabloids like The Times. Naively I hold out slightly higher hopes for The Guardian. Alas.

Yesterday, Ming conducted an hour-long Q&A with Sandi Toksvig – it went down well in the conference hall (I heard several warm compliments from those who have been luke-warm about Ming). But for those outside the conference hall, of course, their verdict will be formed by the media verdict, which was as unkind as it was puerile.

The Grauniad’s Deborah Summers was ‘liveblogging’ the Q&A. Here’s a particularly emetic extract:

Asked about PMQs, Sir Menzies said everyone

Posted in Conference and News | 12 Comments

More Talking Coalitions

On Monday, it was Mark Oaten who was talking coalitions. The liberal think-tank Centre Forum is also joining in the conversation, and have just published a pamphlet, Lib-Lab: can Labour and the Liberal Democrats co-operate?, authored by Julian Astle and Alasdair Murray.

You can read the document as a PDF here. Here’s the abstract to whet your appetite:

Gordon Brown’s attempt in the summer of 2007 to bring a number of Liberal Democrat peers into his government reopened the debate about co-operation between the two parties. In the event, Menzies

Posted in News | Leave a comment

Ming speaks out on Euro referendum – “we must have a vote”

The Lib Dems have just issued a press release in which Ming Campbell has demanded in unequivocal terms a referendum on the UK’s position within the European Union. Here’s the full text:

Ahead of his Party Conference, which begins tomorrow, Liberal Democrat Leader Menzies Campbell, has called for the public to be given a real choice on the European Union.

Menzies Campbell said:

“It’s time for the political parties to end the shadow boxing on Europe and enter into an honest debate about the European Union.

“We will not know the final shape of the European

Posted in News | 30 Comments

Paddy was a spy, says Ming

According to the Glasgow Daily Record, anyway:

Ex-Lib Dem leader Lord Paddy Ashdown has been outed as a spy by successor Sir Menzies Campbell. Ashdown, a former Royal Marine who served with the elite Special Boat Service, was long suspected to have been a real life James Bond. Now Sir Menzies has confirmed he worked for MI6.

The North East Fife MP revealed: “Put it this way, when he was in the Foreign Office, I think he was in the more shadowy side of Foreign Office activity.”

And, indeed, the resemblance between Paddy and Daniel Craig is uncanny.

Posted in News | Also tagged | 2 Comments

Ming says EU reform treaty referendum “not necessary”

In a pre-conference interview in today’s Financial Times, Lib Dem leader Ming Campbell has dismissed calls for the party to back a referendum on the EU reform treaty – but has kept open the possibility of a re-run of 1975’s ‘in or out’ poll:

… Sir Menzies, a “pro-European”, told the Financial Times the new EU reform treaty was “sufficiently different” from the original constitution to avoid the need for a plebiscite. He said the only case for a public vote would be on a much broader “in or out” question about Britain’s membership of the EU, to prompt a

Posted in News | Also tagged and | 24 Comments

Lord Bonkers’ Diary: 17th Anniversary Souvenir Special

It is only fitting for Lib Dem Voice to mark the 17th anniversary of the publication of Lord Bonkers’ diary with this special cut-out-from-your-computer-screen-and-keep souvenir special. Through the good offices of his literary secretary Jonathan Calder, who writes the blog Liberal England, Lord Bonkers writes exclusively for us.

I have been asked by the editors of this moving electric blog to share some of my long experience of Liberal politics with you. Many of you will already know me from my Diary in Liberator magazine, where it has appeared since 1990: those who do not should take out a subscription immediately.

First, let me introduce myself. I think my entry in Who’s Who in the Liberal Democrats puts it Terribly Well when it describes me as “Statesman, Soldier, Diplomat, Philosopher, Traveller, Industrialist, Author, Philanthropist and All Round Good Egg.”

Posted in Humour | Also tagged | Leave a comment

Lib Dems: about to collapse, or on the up?

Two very alternative takes on the party’s fortunes have appeared in the press in the last few days.

For those who like to drink from the glass half-empty, you can sup happily from today’s leader in the Tory-supporting Daily Telegraph:

Liberal Democrat support is quite simply collapsing. The party currently attracts only 14 per cent of voters, compared with 22 per cent in the 2005 general election. If there were a general election tomorrow, the Lib Dems would lose some of their most cherished West Country seats – to the Tories. Admittedly, Gordon Brown would be returned to office with an increased majority, but, for the first time in decades, Britain’s third party would have been reduced to insignificance.

There are several reasons for this state of affairs. When Mr Cameron rebranded the Conservatives as a green party, he pushed the Lib Dems off a patch of the ground that they had occupied, rather smugly, for years. But there is a more significant factor, which can be summed up in two words: Menzies Campbell.

But those who prefer their politics sunny-side-up can opt instead for Bill Jacobs’ upbeat assessment in The Scotsman:

Unexpectedly, Liberal Democrat leader Sir Menzies Campbell has had the most relaxed holiday of the three party chiefs. While Gordon Brown has been desperate to show that as Prime Minister he is just as much in control as he was as Chancellor, and David Cameron has been trying to subdue his unruly Conservative Party, Ming finds himself as ruler of all he surveys. …

As the wheels came off Mr Cameron’s new Tory bandwagon over the early summer and Mr Brown took over from Mr Blair, the Lib Dem leader’s performances at Westminster strengthened and his age ceased to be an issue in the press. The idea of a steady hand on the tiller of the Liberal Democrats as well as in the country took hold and the murmuring in the party subsided. …

Posted in News | 37 Comments

New poll: should the Lib Dems back an EU treaty referendum?

There’s speculation in today’s Telegraph that the Lib Dems might back calls from the Tories, and from some 120 Labour rebels, for a referendum on the European Union reform treaty:

Sir Menzies Campbell, the Lib Dem leader, refused yesterday to rule out backing a referendum before a Commons scrutiny of the treaty proposals. Even though he said his personal view was that it was not necessary this time, he added: “I don’t think you can make a final decision on that until we see what the final document looks like.”

A senior party source later disclosed that younger Lib Dem MPs

Posted in Voice polls | 34 Comments

OPINION: Fib Dems? A compliment!

It was well over 10 days into the Sedgefield By-election. Things seemed to be going well and it was clear that the Conservatives were in 3rd place. Then again – Sedgefield is further North than Watford so it was no surprise!

One thing was missing and the campaign team knew it.

High quality literature was being produced and delivered. Canvassing showed a move towards Greg Stone and the Lib Dems. Even the Northern media were on board. Then it came…

Posted in Op-eds | 30 Comments

Book review: how to make people remember what you say

A friend of a friend was on a business trip to London. He meets a beautiful lady in the hotel bar, and the next thing he knows he wakes up in a bath of ice, with his kidneys missing.

We’ve all heard a version of that story. Made to Stick investigates why people remember some ideas regardless of whether they are true.

All of us who have been involved with the Liberal Democrats know the frustration of meeting members of the public who don’t know Lib Dem policies that we’ve been banging on about for years. Or we’ve met voters confused by smear campaigns against us by other parties. For this reason everyone in the Liberal Democrats needs to read Made to Stick.

Made to Stick outlines six things that made an idea memorable.

Posted in Books | 5 Comments

Ming China

Liberal England’s Jonathan Calder points Lib Dems to the article by leader Sir Menzies Campbell on the Beijing Olympics in the Grauniad.

Mr. Calder thinks it’s a bit weak, and judging by the user comments most of the paper’s website readers agree. Personally, I’m surprised that Ming did not use his new ‘spikiness’ to take a stronger line. Freer markets must be aided in making lives freer for people in communist state.

Posted in Op-eds | Also tagged | 5 Comments

Martha Kearney on ‘Jackgate’

Here’s what the presenter of BBC Radio 4’s The World at One says about the programme’s focus on the Lib Dem leadership this week:

The Ealing by-election had been seen as a test of Sir Menzies Campbell’s leadership and there was relief in Cowley Street that the party didn’t do badly. But it certainly wasn’t the spectacular result that the Liberal Democrats have been famed for in the past and a BBC analysis of the last four months’ opinion polls show that the party has dropped from an average of 21% in April to 17% in July which must be

Posted in News | 2 Comments

Preston’s dead end?

I think it’s safe to say that former Guardian editor Peter Preston ain’t too enamoured of the Lib Dems, or of our leader, Ming Campbell:

The only certainty confirmed through the political ides of July is that Sir Menzies Campbell will lead the Liberal Democrats into the next election. Gordon Brown has to choose when to hold it; the Conservative party, chuntering over David Cameron, has to decide whether to commit suicide now or later. But, whenever it comes, featuring whoever’s still left at whichever helm, Ming will be there. The latest ICM polls may say that 41% of his own supporters aren’t keen on him, but those unexciting second places in Ealing and Sedgefield have made him unshiftable. No new faces, no new ideas. He’s staying.

At a national level, it puts the Lib Dems on the back foot, struggling to hold on rather than advance. Maybe the old dislocation of an equation – Labour losing ground in the cities of the north, the Tories still failing to make ground in the suburbs of the south – will come to their rescue: but don’t bank on it. Brown sets a formidable pace. Cameron is young enough to find a second wind. Only the old sprinter can’t raise a canter.

Mr Preston’s piece is worth reading in full.

There is a recitation of some tired old clichés which only a state-centrist Guardianista would make space for – “how difficult it is for Lib Dems to define consistent national policies. What plays well in Sheffield is a bum note in Tiverton, and vice versa.”

Well, I’m not sure how true that is…

Posted in News | Also tagged | 2 Comments

The Lib Dems on the floods

Quick round-up:

‘Lib Dem leader in flood-hit city’ (BBC Online)
Lib Dem leader Sir Menzies Campbell has criticised the government’s flood plans as he prepared to visit Hull to see the aftermath of last month’s deluge. He said a lack of government planning had led to a “summer of suffering”.

‘Row over disaster response deepens as flooding eases’ (The Scotsman)
Liberal Democrat environment spokesman, Chris Huhne, said: “The government has been far too slow to wake up to the potentially devastating effects of extreme rainfall overwhelming drains and sewers.”

Floodplains ‘not ruled out’ for new homes (24dash.com)
Liberal Democrat housing spokesman …

Posted in News | 2 Comments

Beware the curse of Rees-Mogg?

I’m feeling conflicted. A good rule-of-thumb is to believe the opposite of what Lord William Rees-Mogg, columnist for The Times, and one of the least acute of Tory political commentators, writes. Today he uses his column to praise the Lib Dems’ performance in last week’s by-elections as “excellent”. Twice. What’s going on?

Last week’s by-election results were satisfactory for Labour, excellent for the Liberal Democrats and a disaster for the Conservatives. That was the almost unanimous verdict of the weekend’s press, except for Alan Watkins in The Independent on Sunday, who warned Gordon Brown against an early election. This general assessment is not likely to be overturned, but it is mistaken. Although Labour held two of its safer seats, these by-election results should be regarded as satisfactory for the Conservatives, excellent for the Lib Dems and very bad for Labour.

Posted in News | 4 Comments

What the media says

Two good results for the Lib Dems on Thursday with swings against Labour and two embarrassing third places for David Cameron’s Conservatives. That’s our line – but what does the press think? Here’s a handy guide…

Daily Express, Saturday 21st
“Leading Britain is a grown-up job for a serious politician. Voters have had quite enough of windmills, bicycles, sledges and huskies. They do not care for the dilettante Notting Hill Set which surrounds Mr Cameron. Part-time spokesmen who prefer to make money moonlighting rather than mastering their briefs should be swept away.”

Simon Heffer, The Daily Telegraph, Saturday 21st
“Frankly, if you can’t even come second in by-elections halfway through the third term of another party’s time in power, things aren’t just wrong. They are catastrophically wrong. The worst mistake Dave can make now, though, is to imagine they can’t get worse. They can. They can get a lot worse.”

Tania Branigan, The Guardian, Saturday 21st
“The third-place finish is a personal blow to David Cameron, who toured the west London constituency five times with political newcomer Tony Lit. The Liberal Democrats also squeezed the Conservatives into third place in Sedgefield.”

Posted in Parliamentary by-elections | Also tagged and | 19 Comments

The morning after the night before

What to make of last night’s by-elections?

Well, for the Labour Party there is evident relief that they have held on to both Ealing Southall and Sedgefield, albeit with considerably reduced majorities, and swings to the Liberal Democrats of 6% and 11% respectively.

There is probably a nagging sense of disappointment among Lib Dems that our achievements were not more spectacular – but that is at least as much due to the very high expectations we set ourselves. No, neither Ealing Southall nor Sedgefield rank will alongside either Brent East or Dunfermline. But the circumstances were quite different, not least because …

Posted in News and Parliamentary by-elections | Also tagged and | 7 Comments

Razzall and Littlewood on Ming’s future

The Guardian reports on today’s BBC World at One interviews with former Lib Dem campaign manager, Lord Tim Razzall, and former head of communications, Mark Littlewood, here. Both suggest Ming Campbell’s future would come under the spotlight if the party were to under-perform in the Ealing Southall and Sedgefield by-elections this Thursday.

Posted in News and Parliamentary by-elections | Also tagged , , , and | 6 Comments

Lib Dems propose lowest rate of income tax since last Liberal government

Ming Campbell has today announced the Lib Dems would cut income tax by 4p in the pound, to 16p, the lowest rate of income tax since the 1916 Asquith government.

The full party press release – with further details of the proposals, and comments from both Ming and Lib Dem shadow Chancellor Vince Cable – is on Ming’s website here.

In his analysis of the announcement, the BBC’s Nick Assinder concludes (albeit, in typically tired left-right terms):

… what the Lib Dem policy offers is a genuine shift in the basis of taxation which will create many more winners than

Posted in News | Also tagged | 22 Comments

OFFICIAL: Gordon Brown names Ming Campbell Leader of the Opposition at PMQs

If it’s in Hansard, then it must be true:

Sir Menzies Campbell (North-East Fife) (LD): What is the Prime Minister’s assessment of the sums wasted by fraud, error and overpayment in the tax credit system he set up three years ago?

The Prime Minister: It is very interesting that the leader of the Conservative party did not ask anything about the married couple allowance or tax credits and that it has been left to the leader of the Liberal party to pick up the baton. Tax credits are the most successful policy in removing child poverty in this country: 6 million

Posted in News and PMQs | 1 Comment

Campbell unveils new shadow cabinet (copy of a party Press Release)

Liberal Democrat Leader Menzies Campbell today showed his confidence in the strength of his front bench team as he unveiled his new Shadow Cabinet.

Commenting, he said:

“We are fortunate in having some of the brightest and most able people in the House of Commons. I am confident they will continue to hold the Government to account and develop Liberal Democrat policy.

 “We must continue to attack Labour and the Conservatives for their cosy consensus on key issues from the environment and civil liberties to nuclear energy and the war in Iraq.

“This is a winning team which will take the fight to the other parties as we head toward the next election.”


Leader
The Rt Hon Sir Menzies Campbell, QC, MP

Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer and Deputy Leader
Vincent Cable MP

Shadow Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs
Michael Moore MP

Shadow Secretary of State for Justice and Lord Chancellor
David Heath MP

Shadow Secretary of State for the Home Department
Nick Clegg MP

Posted in News | 17 Comments

Liberal Democrats select Nigel Bakhai for Ealing Southall

Nigel BakhaiLocal choice Nigel Bakhai is set to challenge Labour once more in Ealing Southall, after being selected by Ealing Southall Liberal Democrats. Nigel Bakhai doubled the Lib Dem vote at the 2005 General Election.

The Liberal Democrats are the main challengers to Labour in the seat. They were second at the last General Election.

Local Liberal Democrat Nigel Bakhai said:

“Living in the heart of the constituency I know the issues that local people face. Labour has taken our area for granted for too long.

“This election is about local people electing …

Posted in News and Parliamentary by-elections | Also tagged and | 2 Comments

Party releases ‘holding statement’ from Shirley Williams

“I met Gordon Brown at 6:30pm on Wednesday evening. We had a friendly and constructive discussion. I was not offered a Ministerial position and would not have accepted one.

“The Prime Minister and I talked briefly about the dangers of unsecured nuclear materials and nuclear proliferation, subjects I have worked on as a member of the Board of Directors of the Nuclear Threat Initiative in Washington DC.

“NTI is a private organisation established by Senator Sam Nunn of the Democratic Party, former chairman of the Senate Armed Service Committee, and Ted Turner, founder of CNN. Senator Richard Lugar of the Republican Party, …

Posted in News | 9 Comments

Why Lib Dems should support the Citizens’ Convention Bill

Today, Unlock Democracy has launched its campaign for a Citizens’ Convention Bill. The Bill will be presented to the House of Commons today by Lib Dem Treasury Spokesperson Julia Goldsworthy MP, and it is set for its second reading debate this Friday.

The idea behind this Bill is simple: there is now broad, cross-party support for the principle that Britain’s democracy needs to be renewed, and that the people themselves must be at the centre of any new reform.

Gordon Brown launched his leadership bid pledging to “build a shared national consensus for a programme of constitutional reform.” Sir Menzies Campbell subsequently called on Brown to establish “a broadly-based Convention” which “should involve not just the political parties but also members of the public.”

Last week, the Power Inquiry launched its new campaign calling for just such a process in a statement that was signed by 101 individuals and organisations, including – among others – Baroness Shirley Williams and prominent Lib Dem supporter Claire Rayner.

Posted in News and Op-eds | Also tagged | 1 Comment
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Peter Martin
    @ Iain, There is common ground on the federal question insofar as we agree that it could work. A federal system works well in Australia. The Aus...
  • Iain Donaldson
    Thanks Mim, That's fair as a description of the counting process, but I think it's worth separating the voter experience from the administrator experience. ...
  • Peter Martin
    @ Kira, I don't think many, if anyone, are seriously suggesting that we should all be exactly equal regardless of the effort we might put in. The question...
  • Iain Donaldson
    I think the main point of disagreement concerns the relationship between fiscal autonomy and monetary sovereignty. It is certainly true that only a currency ...
  • Iain Donaldson
    I think there is actually significant common ground between the comments by both Petyer and Kira, and the original article. The article does not argue that c...