Author Archives: Stephen Tall

Stephen was Editor (and Co-Editor) of Liberal Democrat Voice from 2007 to 2015, and writes at The Collected Stephen Tall. He writes a fortnightly column for ConservativeHome and 'The Underdog' column for Total Politics magazine. He edited the 2013 publication, The Coalition and Beyond: Liberal Reforms for the Decade Ahead, and is a Research Associate for the liberal think-tank CentreForum. He was awarded the inaugural Lib Dem ‘Blogger of the Year’ prize in 2006, was a councillor for eight years in Oxford, including a year as Deputy Lord Mayor, and appears frequently in the media in person, in print and online. Stephen combines his political interests with his professional life as Development Director for the Education Endowment Foundation, though writes here in a personal capacity.

Nailing the Michael Brown smear

Iain Dale has, yet again, raised the issue of the £2.4m donation to the Lib Dems from Michael Brown. According to Iain this shows the party hasn’t a leg to stand on when we demand that Labour and the Tories clean up their act. So it’s interesting to compare the arch-Tory blogger’s take with the impartial Electoral Commission’s verdict:

“The Electoral Commission has previously made clear its view that it was reasonable for the Liberal Democrats – based on the information available to them at the time – to regard the donations they received from 5th Avenue Partners Ltd

Posted in News | Tagged | 16 Comments

London hustings – views from the blogs

Yesterday’s London leadership hustings has produced a fair few insta-reactions across the blogosphere – all judiciously fair-minded, too.

(An outbreak of civility among the blogging community! – what’s happening to us? It’s almost as if we’ve come to the conclusion we have two excellent candidates for the leadership, either one of whom could do a sterling job if elected.)

Anyway, here are the links:

Rob Fenwick on A Posh-Sounding Northumbrian: London hustings: my verdict
Gavin Whenman on The Whiskey Priest: EXCLUSIVE: London LibDem Leadership Hustings Report and my Voting Intentions
Tom Papworth on Liberal Polemic: Not candidates but

Posted in Best of the blogs and Leadership Election | 4 Comments

Top of the Blogs: The Golden Dozen #40

Welcome to the 40th of our weekly round-ups from the Lib Dem blogosphere, featuring the seven most popular stories according to click-throughs from the Aggregator (18th – 25th November), together with a hand-picked quintet you might otherwise have missed.

And the question you’re all asking is, I imagine… which leadership posting has made it to the top of this week’s list? So, here we go:

Posted in Best of the blogs | 4 Comments

Opinion: Uninspired? Don’t blame Nick or Chris. It’s our fault

I remain resolutely undecided, reliant on today’s London leadership hustings finally to make up my mind. But one thing I am sure about: I hope it’s the last time we as Lib Dems hold a leadership contest to such an abbreviated timetable.

Now some of you might be thinking, “What?! It’s already been twice as long as it needed to be.” And I have some sympathy with those who reckon the contest has failed to catch fire, except for a brief, phosphorescent flash on last week’s Politics Show.

Partly, that’s because some well-qualified MPs chose not to stand, instead throwing …

Posted in Leadership Election and Op-eds | 12 Comments

Sajjad Karim defects to Tories

That’s the story Sky News is carrying this morning, with an interview from Saj himself.

Alex Wilcock notes here that he had just been re-selected as a Lib Dem candidate for the European Parliament in the north-west – he finished second to Chris Davies:

Mr Karim – far from declaring his new-found Conservative vision – was an enthusiastic contender in this all-member Liberal Democrat election. I believe he was elected relatively narrowly last time, and that the number of seats in that region (as in most others) is being reduced. With Liberal Democrat members voting for him to be in

Posted in News | 120 Comments

Sarah Teather re-selected

Congratulations to Sarah Teather MP, who was unanimously re-selected on Sunday night as the Lib Dem prospective parliamentary candidate for Brent Central at the next General Election.

Posted in News and Selection news | 1 Comment

Lib Dem membership: who will reverse the decline?

Mark Littlewood’s latest ‘diary’ for the BBC’s Politics Show highlights one of the less welcome stats exposed by the current leadership contest:

The number of ballot papers issued – less than 65,000 – shows the party has lost more than 10% of its members since Ming Campbell was elected last Spring and now has less than 100 members per Parliamentary constituency.

Protestations from the Liberal Democrats that all political parties are witnessing declining membership and that last year’s total was artificially boosted – because it came so soon after a General Election – are not wholly convincing.

Back in 1999,

Posted in Leadership Election | Tagged and | 37 Comments

Peter Riddell: “the contest is tightening”

Thank goodness for Peter Riddell, the senior Times political columnist, and one of the few (only?) newspaper journalists who is both watching the Lib Dem leadership contest, and reporting it intelligently. His latest analysis appeared yesterday – do read it in full here, but for those who always skip to the end for the conclusion:

Mr Clegg is still the favourite, but only just, and there is a sense – more a mood – among leading Lib Dems that the contest is tightening and could be close.

The Times also carried interviews-cum-profiles with both candidates, which can be read here

Posted in Leadership Election | 9 Comments

How close is the Lib Dem leadership race?

The short answer is: no-one knows.* And don’t expect to become any the wiser today as a result of The Guardian’s ‘sample of members’, despite the paper’s assertions of its significance.

The Guardian asked c.200 of the 300 Lib Dem members present at Wednesday night’s Cambridge hustings how they would vote. Here’s what they said: 85 backed Chris Huhne; 42 backed Nick Clegg; and 83 did not express a preference.

To be fair to the Guardian, they do enter some major caveats: this isn’t a representative sample of members; the east of England is, they say, a strong area for …

Posted in Leadership Election | 3 Comments

BBC Question Time: open thread

Former Liberal leader Lord Steel is one of the panellists on tonight’s edition of Question Time (broadcast on BBC1 and online from 10.35 pm GMT).

He’ll be alongside Scotland’s Deputy First Minister Nicola Sturgeon of the SNP, Scottish Labour leader Wendy Alexander, Scottish Conservative leader Annabel Goldie, and David Aaronovitch columnist for The Times.

If you’re watching, and want to sound-off, please feel free to use the comments thread.

Posted in Lib Dem TV and Scotland | Tagged | 13 Comments

Are you on your way to the Forum?

Don’t forget, if you’re a party member you can register for the Lib Dem Voice members’ forum – in which case you get to read and post on a rich variety of topics which don’t always make it into the public blog. Here’s a selection of the currently active threads to wet your appetites:

  • Private Eye and smutty councillors
  • Asking questions at Hustings
  • TV licensing
  • Charlie Brooker on the state of TV News
  • At the end of all this, we are all going to be friends again
  • Got my ballot paper this morning
  • Govt “loses” 25 million Child Benefit records
  • If the Lib Dems were an international
  • Posted in Site news | 1 Comment

    Oaten: I might quit early

    Ten years after his sensational 1997 election victory over Tory Gerry Malone was confirmed by a landslide by-election, Mark Oaten has said he might quit politics before the next election if a too-good-to-refuse job offer comes along.

    Speaking to the Hampshire Chronicle, Mark is reported saying:

    he did not intend to trigger a by-election but “couldn’t rule it out”. … if the “right job and the right move” came up for him and his wife, he would “give it serious consideration”. The father-of-two said: “I hope people understand. There is so much uncertainty over when an election will be, that I

    Posted in News | 15 Comments

    In the eye of the beholder

    The two Lib Dem leadership candidates could be found last night in Cambridge, husting for the top job.

  • Sal Brinton’s account can be found at Lib Dems for Chris;
  • Linda Jack’s take is over at her Lindyloo’s Muze blog.
  • Posted in Best of the blogs and Leadership Election | Leave a comment

    How the MPs are lining up (UPDATED)

    By popular request, here’s the current list of which Lib Dem MPs have declared for which leadership candidate so far. (Originally compiled with the help of Jonathan Isaby of The Daily Telegraph.)

    The list shows that Nick has attracted two MPs who supported Chris as leader in 2006: Greg Mulholland and Stephen Williams; and eight who supported Simon Hughes (all listed below). Chris has attracted one former Ming Campbell backer – Tom Brake – and three MPs who supported Simon Hughes last time.

    Eight MPs have stated they will not declare for any candidate; four have yet – so far as I’m aware – to state their intentions.

    As we continue to note, the number of MPs who declare for any one candidate is, in one sense, irrelevant: we are a one-member-one-vote party. Clearly, however, MPs’ endorsements will carry some influence with party members, especially among non-activists.

    The full list appears below:

    Posted in Leadership Election and News | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , and | 4 Comments

    Today’s leadership links

    Chris Huhne answers Daily Telegraph readers’ questions here (prompting this story, Chris Huhne backs UK constitution referendum).

    Nick Clegg writes in The Guardian here about Labour’s lost data crisis, and the impact on ID cards.

    And Lib Dem blogger of the year, James Graham, finally ends the mystery of who he’s going to vote for on the Guardian’s Comment Is Free blog here.

    Posted in Leadership Election and News | 2 Comments

    PMQs: Vince tackles Gordon on Treasury disasters

    Acting Lib Dem leader Vince Cable today took Gordon Brown to task – and after this week’s Government shambles he had plenty of choice of subject matter.

    Cunningly Vince rolled up both Northern Rock and the HRMC’s lost data into his first question; though trying to stir up the Blair/Brown row allowed Gordon easily to deflect Vince’s point. For his second question, Vince moved on to QinetiQ, raising a valid concern about another instance of Labour’s financial incompetence; but this wasn’t the issue uppermost in people’s mind today.

    (And, yes, yet again Gordon referred in his reply to ‘the Liberal party’ rather than the Liberal Democrats. I guess he must think we’ll be insulted or wound up by it; personally, I just find it bemusing. Does he really think it will make him sound more Prime Ministerial if he can’t get right the name of this country’s third largest political party?)

    Full PMQs transcript of the Vince-Gordon exchanges below (via Hansard):

    Posted in News and PMQs | Tagged | 5 Comments

    Newsnight leadership hustings: open thread

    Nick Clegg and Chris Huhne are standing at their podia waiting for Jeremy Paxman’s grilling on Tuesday’s BBC2 Newsnight. After last Sunday’s fireworks, I imagine we can expect a love-in tonight…

    Update: a good performance from both candidates. Interesting to see the fall-out from Sunday’s Politics Show… Nick Clegg was able to lead on the front foot, and looked at perhaps his most comfortable and authoritative of the campaign to date; a somewhat chastened Chris Huhne started on the back foot – apologising for the ‘Calamity Clegg’ briefing – but remained as articulate and in control of his …

    Posted in Leadership Election | 89 Comments

    Vince demands Labour comes clean on Northern Rock

    Acting Lib Dem leader Vince Cable has today been piling the pressure on Labour, launching a campaign to demand Gordon Brown tells the British taxpayer how much money has been loaned to Northern Rock, and when it will be paid back.

    Writing in today’s Guardian, Vince argues the case for temporary nationalization of Northern Rock to protect the public interest:

    neither the chancellor nor the prime minister have been able to give me an unequivocal assurance that the taxpayer’s money will be repaid in full, with interest, during this parliament. The likelihood is growing that billions may be lost. …

    possibility

    Posted in News | 1 Comment

    Government loses 25m records – would you trust them with ID cards?

    Is there a Richter scale for cock-ups? If so, the Government has just been hit by at least a Factor 9:

    Alistair Darling has blamed mistakes by junior officials at HM Revenue and Customs after details of 25 million child benefit recipients were lost. The Chancellor said information, including bank details of 7m families, had been sent on discs to the National Audit office by unrecorded delivery. Mr Darling said it was “an extremely serious failure”.

    Of course mistakes happen: you cannot eliminate error, either human or machine. All you can do is minimize it. The Lib Dems have

    Posted in News | 18 Comments

    Labour slashes £1bn from overseas aid budget

    That’s the rather shameful story which Lib Dem overseas development spokeswoman Lynne Featherstone has uncovered – and, what’s worse, the Government has hidden this budget cut from view.

    You can read Lynne’s blog article in full here, but here’s the nub:

    axed around £1 billion from the UK aid budget (official development assistance) – and then tried to keep it secret. … having promised in 2004 that aid levels would be at 0.47% in 2007-8, they’ve now cut that figure to 0.37% – which is equal to around £1 billion.

    As it was an international development debate in Parliament today,

    Posted in News | 2 Comments

    Who are your favourite (and least favourite) non-Lib Dem bloggers

    A new poll is coming to LDV: who are your favourite, and least favourite, non-Lib Dem bloggers. Nominations are now open, so please feel free to use the comments thread. (Self-nomination is allowed, Iain.)

    There’s still chance, by the way, to vote in the LDV poll asking who you would have voted for, given the chance, among those Lib Dem MPs who ruled themselves out of the leadership race. Eyes right, if you’ve not yet cast your ballot.

    Julia Goldsworthy and Charles Kennedy are currently neck-and-neck, with David Laws and Steve Webb not far behind. (I have to say I think Vince’s …

    Posted in Voice polls | Tagged , , and | 24 Comments

    Top of the Blogs: The Golden Dozen #39

    Welcome to the 39th of our weekly round-ups from the Lib Dem blogosphere, featuring the seven most popular stories according to click-throughs from the Aggregator (10th – 17th November), together with a hand-picked quintet you might otherwise have missed.

    Go on, guess which story’s dominated the last seven days’ blogs?

    Posted in Best of the blogs | 7 Comments

    The morning after the lunch-time before

    Today’s newspaper headlines are unsurprising:

    Clegg complains as Lib Dem leadership race turns ugly (The Independent)
    Lib Dem leadership contest turns nasty in TV studio clash (The Guardian)
    Chris Huhne targets ‘Calamity Clegg’ for Lib Dem leadership (Daily Mail)
    Lib Dem leadership rivals clash on TV (The Times)

    I hope in the cool, clear light of a Monday morning, both campaign teams will recognize that BBC1’s Politics Show clash generated a lot more heat than light, and act to draw a line under yesterday’s events.

    Chris Huhne needs to understand that yesterday’s display was overly belligerent; he’s right to show real …

    Posted in Leadership Election and News | 35 Comments

    Opinion: Not pretty, but does it matter?

    The Lib Dem leadership contest should be a fantastic opportunity for the party to display its wares, offering its most talented MPs the media spotlight to exhibit their vibrant view of liberalism, and how their leadership will elevate the party. At times – including last Thursday’s Question Time – that’s how it’s been. Today’s BBC1 Politics Show was a sad sight for anyone who wants our two would-be leaders to promenade the party in its Sunday best.

    Neither candidate has an unblemished record. Nick Clegg, for example, penned an article for The Guardian in February 2006 in which he levelled …

    Posted in Leadership Election and Op-eds | 19 Comments

    BBC Politics Show: Lib Dem leadership election special – open thread

    Are you ready for Round 2 of Clegg v. Huhne? Because today, at 12 noon, the two candidates for the leadership will go head-to-head once again in front of the cameras for BBC1’s Politics Show.

    If you’re tuned in, and want to let folk know what you think of the contenders’ performances, feel free to comment below. As ever, please do keep discussion reasoned and reasonable.

    Posted in Leadership Election and Lib Dem TV | 142 Comments

    Have you asked a YouTube question yet?

    Tens of thousands of folk have already watched Lib Dem chief executive Chris Rennard invite questions to Nick Clegg and Chris Huhne for the party’s YouTube hustings. And, at the time of writing, there have been 17 – how shall I say it? – eclectic responses.

    James Graham has posted his question over at his Quaequam Blog! here. Two other bloggers have posed their questions to the candidates:

    Paul Walter:

    And, erm, me:

    You have another week – until 25th November – to film yourself (whether on your phone, webcam, or camera) and post it to YouTube.

    Posted in Leadership Election and Lib Dem TV | Tagged | 1 Comment

    Opinion: The post-match QT analysis

    The post-match blog analysis on the Question Time leadership special has been pretty evenly split, with a tilt towards Chris Huhne having gained the edge overall.

    (Paul Walter linked through to the early reaction this morning; more have appeared since – check out the Lib Dem blog aggregator for the latest. And, if you haven’t watched the programme yet, you can see it online here.)

    Last night did little to help make up my mind: both candidates, I thought, performed equally well, and displayed almost to the full their respective strengths. Which is why I take with a pinch …

    Posted in Leadership Election and Op-eds | Tagged and | 20 Comments

    BBC Question Time: Lib Dem leadership election special – open thread

    The two contenders for the Liberal Democrat leadership – Nick Clegg and Chris Huhne – go head-to-head on tonight’s special edition of Question Time (broadcast on BBC1 and online from 10.35 pm GMT).

    The pressure will be on. Though Question Time’s audience is not large (a couple of million, or so), it’s likely that a high proportion of Lib Dem members will be tuning in; many times more than will attend all the hustings events combined. For many of the so-called ‘armchair membership’, their assessment of how each candidate has performed tonight will decide how they choose to cast their …

    Posted in Leadership Election and Lib Dem TV | Tagged | 121 Comments

    Video: Ed Davey on the train

    I flagged up last night that Lib Dem MPs Ed Davey and Susan Kramer were occupying Channel 4’s Political Slot:

    Edward Davey MP discusses rising train fares and talks about Liberal Democrat plans to fund investment in the railways through tolls on foreign lorries.

    If you missed it, don’t worry – here it is again, courtesy YouTube:

    Posted in Lib Dem TV | Leave a comment

    ‘Rocket Man’ Brian attracts Elton’s backing

    Sky News’s Jon Craig has the exclusive:

    Brian Paddick, the controversial former top cop chosen by the Liberal Democrats as their candidate for London Mayor, is being backed by rock legend Sir Elton John. …

    Revealing his celebrity backing from the superstar whose hits include “Rocket Man”, Paddick told me: “Before I got the nomination, I got a text from David Furnish (Sir Elton’s partner) saying ‘We’ll support you’.” He says there has been no pledge of financial support so far. But I’m sure big-spending Elton can afford to donate a few bob to a political campaign.

    Posted in London | Tagged | Leave a comment
    Advert

    Recent Comments

    • Anthony Acton
      Thank you Mary for your wise words. In the past adoption was indeed often in the best interests of the children concerned, given social attitudes to illegitimac...
    • Jason Connor
      It wasn't just the vote that collapsed but the massive loss of seats. The coalition wasn't popular and neither was austerity. Many of the MPs in cabinet were no...
    • Jason Connor
      People don't necessarily vote on tribal lines for parties. They also look at individuals, what they stand for and local issues. I know several people who vote i...
    • Andrew Tampion
      "@Jana – yes, of course we should treat people as individuals. But we have to marry that principal with the need to counterbalance past discrimination." Why?...
    • Roland
      >” I did see changes happen. In the 70s I was teaching in a secondary school and I was giving pastoral support to one of the pupils who was pregnant” ...