Sarah Teather on “deeply upsetting” report on pregnant women in asylum system

Sarah Teather has been speaking in Parliament today about a new report by Maternity Action and the Refugee Council which highlights the treatment of pregnant women and their new babies in the asylum system. You can read her whole speech here, and I warn you it will make you upset and angry in equal and consuming measure. The description of a woman who had just given birth being made to carry her newborn baby home by foot in the snow was harrowing. There are many such similar stories in the report.

These vulnerable women suffer both poor physical and mental health and their pregnancies can be higher risk because they often don’t see a midwife until later in their pregnancies than is recommended.

I have referred to the deeply upsetting report, “When Maternity Doesn’t Matter”, which the Refugee Council and Maternity Action produced this week. They submitted evidence to our inquiry that the impact of dispersal on women’s lives is catastrophic if they are pregnant. The four weeks’ protected period that UKBA agreed to introduce is an advance, but still woefully inadequate. Women are moved away from their partners so they may have no one with them when they give birth and no one to look after their other children. A single mother in the study reported that she was separated from her partner so she had no one to look after her children and she considered leaving her children with a local shopkeeper before she went into labour because she had no other options for child care. Midwives told us that it makes their lives incredibly difficult because they are unable to provide continuity of care.

We would not expect any British woman to experience such conditions, but these women have specific extra difficulties and they should receive more support, not less. Many have suffered female genital mutilation and sexual violence in their own country as well as torture, which exacerbates the risk of flashbacks when giving birth. They have a much higher rate of maternal death than we expect in the general population. They make up 12% of all maternal deaths, but only 0.3% of the overall population. Those figures are staggering and worrying, and the Government must get to grips with them.

She went on to talk about the need to give people enough money for a basic standard of living:

Given the complexity of section 4 and section 95 support—it took us some considerable time to produce the spreadsheet to work out exactly what families in different circumstances would get—it beggars belief that someone in a situation of war, violence or persecution would spend a couple of days researching that on the internet before deciding which travel company to book their flight with. We need to get that into perspective. The answer must surely be to set levels in line with other benefits. Deducting accommodation costs if necessary, we should make a clear commitment to uprate benefits so that people who have fled war, persecution and violence can live—as the hon. Member for Scunthorpe said—a basic, dignified life.

I understand the political difficulties of raising benefit levels for asylum seekers, in particular when there is much debate about wider benefit levels—full stop. Surely it would be more sensible and take an awful lot of political grief away from the Minister if they were simply pegged to other benefit levels and automatically uprated each year. Ministers would then not have to go through the agony of having to work out on which full-news day to introduce a measure; they could simply get on with doing the right and humane thing.

The Minister said that he would look feed this report into the Government’s own review. Sarah Teather needs to ensure he lives up to his word.

* Caron Lindsay is Co-Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings

Read more by or more about , or .
This entry was posted in News.
Bookmark the web address for this page or use the short url http://ldv.org.uk/33429 for Twitter and emails.

6 Comments

  • Helen Dudden 27th Feb '13 - 7:43pm

    Very recently in the EU I saw and elderly woman curled up in a heap on a pavement area. I have just been writing on the bedroom tax, housing, and various other issues. Suicide is not uncommon in the EU as things get very tough. Yet on line here, there are comments on the behaviour of MPs, if they are guilty, they should know better. I do not judge because I do not know the true picture.

    For too long , not enough time has been given to the subjects that concern human misery, I am being homest tonight, I think time for honesty and a real effort to lesson the wrongs in our country as well as the EU. We do not forget others who are suffering too.

  • Helen Dudden 27th Feb '13 - 7:44pm

    It should have read honest, sorry touch typing.

  • Hellen you are right, of course. But do you think there is any merit in the following argument: the abuse of power suggested by the revelations of the last week have deterred women from advancing in the Party, hence we have far fewer women MPs than we should. If we had more women in Parliament, they would ensure that enough time was “given to the subjects that concern human misery” . So whilst in the short time it seems a distraction to be focusing on the behaviour of MPs and others, in a broader sense it’s quite a critical issue.

  • Tony Greaves Tony Greaves 27th Feb '13 - 10:50pm

    Well done, Sarah. This is scandal of a very high order but will we see it on the front pages of the Mail, Telegraph, Times Independent and Guardian for the next five days?

    If we do see it, perhaps in the Express they will run a front page on the “scandal” of asylum seekers abusing the NHS by having babies here. Or perhaps they’ve done that already and I’ve missed it.

    Tony Greaves

  • The welfare of asylum seekers during this Government in particular has been one of the big untold stories which would upset anyone with a sense of human decency. They suffered a lot in the cuts to public expenditure.

    Some voluntary groups have stepped into the breach and provided aid and vital services. In this case for expectant mothers but also for children and those suffering mental health issues. The very worst of Government has brought out the very best in people in these charities. That should deserve our support.

  • Well done Sarah. I want to see more of our MPs working to alleviate suffering and doing the right and humane thing, to care about people.

    Thank you Caron for writing about this.

Post a Comment

Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.

If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.

Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *

*
*
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?




Recent Comments

  • User AvatarHelen Tedcastle 23rd May - 8:09pm
    @ Charlie: "What matters are the opinions of the admissions tutors at top universities and future employers ." Of course, their opinions matter but they...
  • User AvatarEddie Sammon 23rd May - 7:58pm
    Stuart, terrorism will not be reduced by censoring its motives. We need to raise awareness and educate the public about what is going on and...
  • User Avatarjenny barnes 23rd May - 7:55pm
    It was a hate crime. There are unfortunately many hate crimes every year - why did this one get wall to wall coverage? Does the...
  • User AvatarBen Jephcott 23rd May - 7:54pm
    Good stuff. Suitably emboldened, perhaps David could cast his eye over a number of other large and threatening jet-powered things parked in the Gove hangar...
  • User AvatarA Social Liberal 23rd May - 7:52pm
    Not so good if Laws only vetoed it on the grounds of cost. It would have been better to tell it straight and say that...
Sun 26th May 2013
Tue 28th May 2013
Wed 29th May 2013
Thu 30th May 2013
Fri 31st May 2013
Sat 1st Jun 2013
10:00
Mon 3rd Jun 2013
Thu 6th Jun 2013
Fri 7th Jun 2013
Sat 8th Jun 2013
Sun 9th Jun 2013
Thu 13th Jun 2013
Sat 15th Jun 2013
Tue 18th Jun 2013
Thu 20th Jun 2013