David Cameron is Clegg-lite

Did you notice the almost audible gulping and stuttering from the chattering Tory websites after Ming Campbell’s sudden resignation when it was obvious that Nick Clegg would stand for the leadership? Not to mention their deeply unusual restraint since the leadership election results were announced.

I have a theory about all this and I think it deserves examination.

First of all, let us go back a couple of years.

David Cameron wins their leadership election but – for all his elan in the famous conference speech – Cameron, with his Eton/CCHQ/PR/Hooray Henry background is a recipe …

Posted in Op-eds | 12 Comments
Advert

Opinion: Do the Lib Dems need a gym membership as our New Year’s resolution?

When I sit down and draw up my New Year Resolutions I always think of St Augustine and his prayer “Oh Lord make me Chaste, but not yet”. Resolutions can be affirmative but more often than not we use them to try and break long term habits we don’t like. Even if we don’t last much past January 10th.

As Britain is awash with new gym memberships, nicotine patches and soon abandoned Diets over the next few weeks, are there any long term bad habits the Liberal Democrats could do with breaking? Here are my five suggestions for a fitter, leaner 2008 for the party. However I suspect some are as unlikely as me giving up chips.

Posted in Op-eds | 6 Comments

LDVUSA: All eyes on Iowa

It’s become a cliche for journalists writing about the contest to succeed George Bush that this is the longest Presidential race in history. Some of the politicians aspiring to win their party’s candidacy for the November general election have been fighting, literally, for years. As they seek the support of delegates in selection meetings across the 50 states, the 2008 hopefuls are held to a tighter and earlier calendar than ever before. States have begun competing to move their contests forward, all hoping to increase their national influence. This is the first article in our LDVUSA series – covering the American contest – and will hopefully be a bit of an introduction for those who’ve not followed a presidential race before.

In two days, we’ll have the first real vote of the race. I say vote – but the fascinating thing about the caucuses in Iowa is the fact that they’re not votes in any traditional sense. The selection meetings, held in each county in small halls or people’s homes, are very much live action events. To begin with, you have to arrive at the venue exactly between 6.30pm and 7pm. Any later, and you can’t participate. People then actually stand in a corner to support a particular candidate; it’s a very public affair. There’s no secret ballots, and no postal voting. If you don’t make it on time, you don’t get a voice. Here’s Joe Trippi (Howard Dean’s 2004 manager and a consultant to John Edwards this time) describing the first caucus he witnessed, when working for Ted Kennedy’s insurgent challenge to Jimmy Carter:

The night of my first caucus, in January 1980, I went to Jimmy Hogan’s house at 6.30pm, and watched his neighbours pull up in their pickup trucks and American sedans. Jimmy’s living room was packed. When it came time to call for the vote, the two sides began moving to opposite corners of the room, an old flickering chandalier demarking the line between them. I watched the people move to their corners, doing the math in my head. It was close; a few votes either way could turn it. And just as they were about to start counting

Posted in LDVUSA and Op-eds | 10 Comments

Guardian joins Clegg in savaging ID scheme

The Grauniad’s leader column is inspired by Nick Clegg’s New Year message to launch an eloquent polemic against ‘a pernicious piece of plastic’. They say:

Mr Brown previously let it be known that he saw big problems with Tony Blair’s pet ID card project. But when he moved into No 10, polls showing strong support for the scheme deterred an immediate change of course. That support has now slipped thanks to concern about lost data; it will slip further as the costs become stark. After a battering few months, Mr Brown must use the new year to define his government

…

Posted in News | Tagged and | 1 Comment

Brian Paddick interviewed by ePolitix

The interview is on ePolitix.com and covers topics such as Brian Paddick’s priorities for London, his views on Boris Johnson and what he would do with bendy buses.

Posted in News | Tagged and | 2 Comments
Advert

Nick Clegg’s new year message

You can also read the message on the Liberal Democrat website.

Posted in Lib Dem TV and News | 12 Comments

Top of the Blogs: The Golden Dozen #45

For the 45th time, we indulge in a round-up of the Lib Dem blogosphere, featuring the seven most popular stories according to click-throughs from the Aggregator (23rd-29th December), together with a hand-picked quintet you might otherwise have missed.

In the last full week of 2007, these were the best-read posts:

Posted in Best of the blogs | 3 Comments

Nick Clegg on faith schools

From an interview given this week to The Jewish News:

If we are to create a society in which everyone has a fair chance in life, we need to focus on education, above all. Faith schools have an important role to play in that, and I am keen that they become engines of integration, not of segregation. I would like to see faith schools working together, so you get a network of different schools and faiths. That way children will grow up in an environment where they are aware of the plurality of faiths and views around them.

The interview also covers …

Posted in News | Tagged | 185 Comments

Jasper Gerard makes fun of Simon Jenkins

Sunday’s Observer brings an amusing tirade from Jasper Gerard, directed at Simon Jenkins – or rather Simon’s tendency to get rather worked up about the Liberal Democrats. As Gerard writes:

I enjoy a glow of familiarity whenever I read an article by Simon Jenkins on the Liberal Democrats. So last week, he dismissed Nick Clegg, their new leader, much as he had dismissed Ming Campbell and, for all anyone can remember, Archibald Sinclair and Lloyd George…

In all its essentials, the article is the same every year, explaining why Lib Dems are not worth writing about. Sometimes, it proves necessary to

…

Posted in News | 7 Comments

Clegg calls for a British Constitutional Convention (updated)

Writing on the party’s official website, Nick Clegg has challenged Gordon Brown and David Cameron to live up to their words on cooperation:

Shortly after I was elected as Leader of the Liberal Democrats, the Prime Minister phoned me to offer his congratulations and express his wish that we should work together on the issues that unite our country. Similarly, shortly before I was elected as Lib Dem Leader, the Conservative Leader made a posting on his website seeking support from the Liberal Democrats to build a “progressive alliance”. His approach was a little less personal and a bit preemptive,

…

Posted in News | 53 Comments

10 key Lib Dem questions for 2008

Sky News’s Adam Boulton has posted his rather more worldly ’10 Questions for 2008’ over at his Boulton & Co blog:

A lot will happen that I can’t predict, but working from the known unknowns of next year’s calendar, here are ten questions which I believe will shape politics at home and abroad in 2008.

Forgive Lib Dem Voice for being a little more parochial, and concentrating on the world of Lib Demmery:

1. Will Nick Clegg become as well-known and respected/liked as Paddy and Charles became?

2. Will the party manage to stake out clear and mainstream liberal policy lines while asserting …

Posted in News | Tagged , , and | 18 Comments

New poll: Long to reign over us?

The poll for Liberal Voice of the Year 2007 will soon be going live – but, in the interregnum, we thought we’d ask that timeless classic: do you think the British monarchy should be abolished?

The hook to hang the question on is provided by the news that 78% of British people want the monarchy to be retained, according to a poll by Gfk NOP commissioned by historian Professor Peter Hennessy, a guest editor of BBC Radio 4’s Today programme:

Some 78% of respondents agreed that Britain should still have a royal family and 19% disagreed. Asked if the monarchy

…

Posted in Voice polls | 16 Comments

Liberal Democrat History Group: volunteer Assistant Editor wanted

Posted on their behalf:

***

The Liberal Democrat History Group is looking for a volunteer to help with editorial work on the group’s web site.

The Group promotes the discussion and research of the histories of the Liberal Democrats, Liberal Party and SDP, and of Liberalism. We do this through meetings, our quarterly Journal of Liberal History, occasional books and our web site.

Originally established to carry news about our activities, the website has since grown substantially through the ongoing Liberal History Online project. As far as we aware, nothing anywhere else on the web makes available such a wide range of …

Posted in News | Leave a comment

LDV voted top Lib Dem blog

Some 2,300 of Iain Dale’s blog-readers voted in a wide-ranging end-of-year survey across 33 categories, including Lib Dem Blog of the Year. Here are the results:

1.
Lib Dem Voice 34%
2. Norfolk Blogger 21%
3. Lynne Featherstone 12%
4. Liberal England 8%
5. Quaequam Blog! 8%
6. Cicero’s Songs 6%
7. Peter Black 6%
Others 5%

We at LDV towers are, of course, touched to the hearts of our bottoms; congrats, too, to the other six blogs.

Posted in Site news | Tagged and | 2 Comments

88% of Lib Dem MPs support fixed-term Parliaments (majority of Labour and Tory MPs opposed)

Iain Dale has highlighted a ComRes survey of 154 MPs – conducted in October this year – revealing that, though support for fixed-term parliaments is on the increase, a majority remain opposed. The breakdown of the poll shows:

88% of Lib Dem MPs support fixed-term Parliaments; as do
41% of Labour MPs; while only
25% of Tory MPs agree.

Overall, 44% of all MPs support fixed-term parliaments, and 49% oppose them.

The OurKingdom blog gives its reaction here, and ends with a delicious conclusion:

surely MPs realise the manipulation and short-termism brings them into disrepute. Why are the majority of both Labour and

…

Posted in News and Parliament | Tagged | 1 Comment

Elsewhere in the blogosphere

Post of the Week
Over at the “Post of the Week” website, voting has opened on a shortlist drawn from the winners of each week during the year.

The eight nominated posts are a snapshot of some of the best writing on blogs in the English-speaking world, but it’s a completely different world to our cosy aggregator based world of Lib Demmery.

Some of the winning posts are small-p political – individuals living their lives and changing their worlds – but it’s all very different to the party politics many of us live on …

Posted in Best of the blogs | 2 Comments

A look back at the polls: December

We tend not to be too poll-obsessed here at LDV – of course we look at them, as do all other politico-geeks, but viewed in isolation no one poll will tell you very much beyond what you want to read into it. Looked at over a reasonable time-span and, if there are enough polls, you can see some trends.

Here, in chronological order, are the results of the six polls conducted in December (hat-tip: Anthony Wells’ UK Polling Report Blog, which provides by far the best analysis of the polls on the web):

Tories 39%, Labour 34%, Lib Dems 18% – ICM/Guardian (19th Dec)
Tories 43%, Labour 31%, Lib Dems 16% – YouGov/Telegraph (19th Dec)
Tories 41%, Labour 30%, Lib Dems 16% – ComRes/Independent (16th Dec)
Tories 45%, Labour 32%, Lib Dems 14% – YouGov/Sunday Times (14th Dec)
Tories 40%, Labour 32%, Lib Dems 16% – Populus/Times (9th Dec)
Tories 42%, Labour 35%, Lib Dems 14% – Ipsos-MORI (7th Dec)

Which gives us an average rating for the parties in December as follows (compared with November’s average):
Tories 42% (+2%), Labour 32% (-1%), Lib Dems 16% (n/c)

Back in November, our poll round-up showed Labour plunging 5% following the debacle of the-election-that-never-was. It’s arguable Gordon Brown might be relieved that the bad press of the last month hasn’t resulted in an even sharper downturn than December’s 1% fall. What will concern Labour more is if the polls do not show any significant upturn in the coming few months, as May’s local elections approach. At the moment they seem locked in the 30-35% box where they were contained in the latter months of Tony Blair’s premiership. Six months after the Brown succession, and Labour’s back where they were.

The Tories have had a pretty good December. I commented last month – when the party was unchanged from October’s average of 40% – that “the drop in Labour’s support seems either to have transferred to the Lib Dems or Others, rather than to the official opposition. Again, we’ll have to wait to see if David Cameron is able to capitalise sustainably on Labour’s misfortunes.” The jury’s still out on whether Mr Cameron is building solid, election-winning foundations; but it would be churlish not to acknowledge that his party is gaining some momentum – albeit perhaps by default – in inverse proportion to the rate at which Labour is losing credibility.

The Lib Dems have stabilized since the nadir of October, when our poll average languished at 13%. In truth, we might have hoped to have done slightly better owing both to the fillip of Vince Cable’s impressive turn as acting leader, and the publicity surrounding the party leadership contest. Still, 16% is some kind of base for Nick Clegg to build upon, and does give the lie to those political commentators who still think that two-party politics is due some kind of pendulum-inevitable return. It isn’t. Two-party politics is dead.

Finally, as a Christmas treat, here are the previous December poll averages for the parties over the past decade:

Posted in Op-eds and Polls | 5 Comments

Gordon’s round-up of the year (minus the stinky bits)

Over at the Number 10 website, they’re reviewing the Prime Minister’s year (well, from June onwards). All the usual favourites are there: how Gordon single-handedly disarmed terrorists in Glasgow, personally mopped-up flooded Britain, and then laid hands upon F&M-infected cattle to cure them of all diseases.

The observant – and the Daily Mail – have noticed some things are missing, though: any reference to the election Gordon flunked, for example. Or HM’s Revenues & Customs’ loss of the personal details of 25 million families. Or the fundraising scandal that seems likely to result in the arrest of …

Posted in News | 1 Comment

Opinion: We don’t do God?

As millions of Britons make their annual visit to church and we learn that our new leader, Nick Clegg, “Doesn’t do God” (so to speak), is it time for the Liberal Democrats to rethink their relationship with faith communities?

Liberalism and religion have not always been happy bedfellows. However, even as Richard Dawkins tops the best-seller lists, and we unwrap our gifted George Bush ‘countdown calendars’ this Christmas, I believe we should re-think and embrace our churches, mosques and temples as allies in the liberal cause, albeit for rather different reasons than we usually do. Before I suggest three reasons for this, let’s consider what use our campaigning makes of faith communities at the moment. It’s not always very liberal…

Posted in Op-eds | 39 Comments

Clegg on Bhutto’s assassination: “This is a dark day”

Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg has issued his response to the shock assassination of Pakistan’s former prime minister, Benazir Bhutto:

“This is a dark day for everyone who believed in a stable and democratic future for Pakistan.

“Benazir Bhutto was a courageous politician known throughout the world, not just Pakistan, for her forthright and sometimes controversial views.

“Her tragic death is a hammer blow against the dream of pluralism and tolerance in modern day Pakistan.

“In the light of her brutal assassination, the need for the full restoration of democracy in Pakistan in now paramount.”

Posted in News | 3 Comments

Opinion: What should the new leader do in his first 100 days? #7

Dear Nick,

If you and you staff have the time, I’ve made many comments over the past two months about how the party needs reforming and reorganising.

But that’s not the object of today. I want to talk to you about the most important meeting of your first 100 days. A meeting, of course, that according to its to principle protagonists will not take place. A meeting, we will not be able to read about until one of you publishes your memoirs. I refer to your first meeting with David Cameron.

It’s important that you set out our stall. Point …

Posted in Leadership Election and Op-eds | Tagged | 4 Comments

Merry Christmas – and let us know your Liberal Voice nominations

A very merry Christmas from the Lib Dem Voice collective to all readers, contributors and comment-makers.

Christmas is a time of peace, joy, and the perfect opportunity to nominate your Liberal Voice of 2007. Suggestions so far include Mitch Benn, Simon Jenkins and Al Gore. Have your say this Christmas day.

Posted in News | 4 Comments

Who’s your liberal voice of 2007?

Lib Dem Voice want to find out, and we’ll be running a New Year poll to find the liberal voice in British politics which has most inspired you in the last year. But as a little twist, we want to look outside the Liberal Democrat party – and find the greatest liberal who’s not a member of our party.

So, who would you pick? It could be a member of another party or one of the majority of Britons who belong to no party. It could even be someone who isn’t British themselves, but has had a big impact on liberalism …

Posted in LDV Awards and Polls | Tagged | 70 Comments

Opinion: What should the new leader do in his first 100 days? #6

Five Lib Dems have so far taken up the challenge to tell Nick Clegg what he should do in his first hundred days: Paul Walter, Linda Jack, David Morton, Mary Reid and Mark Valladares. Now we turn to Simon Titley…

The previous contributors to this series have bombarded the new leader with laundry lists of demands without setting out clear, objective criteria for their choices.

And that’s the problem. Everyone will want a piece of Nick Clegg. He will face persistent and conflicting demands from the party, from parliament, from constituents, from the media, from lobbyists, from …

Posted in Op-eds | Tagged | 8 Comments

Top of the Blogs: the Golden Dozen #44

Welcome to the 44th of our weekly round-ups from the Lib Dem blogosphere, featuring the seven most popular stories according to click-throughs from the Aggregator (16th-22nd December), together with a hand-picked quintet you might otherwise have missed.

An end to Lib Dem leadership speculation, at last… Here are the top-rated stories in descending order:

Posted in Best of the blogs | 2 Comments

What the Sunday papers say about Nick Clegg

Today’s Times and Torygraph both carry generous copious coverage of the Lib Dems following Nick Clegg’s election as leader last Tuesday.

The Sunday Times lines up an out-of-her-depth Rosie Millard to quiz Nick – fortunately she quotes Nick extensively, which makes for more interesting reading than her insipid questions. Meanwhile, her ST colleague Simon Jenkins dusts off his perennial ‘the Lib Dems are pointless’ article for yet another airing, indulging in his favourite form of binary political reductionism:

If Clegg really means to be radical, then he must choose which radicalism. He must become more Labour than Labour or more Conservative than Conservative. In traditional terms, he must outflank one or other from their wings.

For an intelligent, liberal polemicist like Jenkins this is pretty desperate stuff; but, then, he has always had a blind spot when it comes to the Lib Dems, and it’s clear that’s never going to change. A shame, as he is one of the most eloquent exponents in favour of the decentralisation of public services as a means for breathing back life into Britain’s communities and public realm. But he seemingly cannot cope with the fact that the only political party which agrees with him is the one he simply cannot stick.

The Sunday Telegraph reveals Tory central office’s concerns about Nick’s election:

Posted in News | 1 Comment

Labour’s swing to puritanism

Since the departure of Blair the most noticeable change in the nature of policy statements and proposals have been on the classic battlegrounds of social liberalism versus social conservatism.

First we had the U-turn on Super Casinos. Then we had the proposals to re-reclassify Cannabis. We now have a suggestion to reverse the liberalisation of the licensing laws including pub opening times. This was followed by suggestions that the Police should be scouring the pubs trying to find drunks. There is the proposal to criminalise bar staff with hefty fines for serving drunken people. We have a criminal justice bill that includes very poorly thought out proposals to ban ‘violent porn’ that include provisions that would effectively criminalise perceived immoral thoughts. You can be in possession of a film that has been passed by the Classification Board but if you view it ‘principally for sexual gratification’ you are committing an offence. And now there is a suggestion by Harriet Harman to make it illegal to pay for sex.

In Brown and Harman we have a nightmare combination – the traditional religious puritan tendencies of Brown and Harriet Harman’s political correctness gone mad. And what makes matters worse is that both have very strong state interventionist tendencies.

Posted in Op-eds | 24 Comments

How powerful a campaigning tool is Facebook?

Pretty powerful, at least in Canada it seems.

Posted in Online politics | Tagged | 7 Comments

Something for the Weekend: Little Saint Nick

In the words of the legendary Noddy Holder, IT’S CHRISTMAS!!!

I love everything about this time of year: angels playing in the snow, logs atop the Christmas tree, kids on the fire. And everyone struck down with wintry viruses.

Still, it’s Saturday so I’ve dragged my flu-ravaged self from my sickbed to bring you 2007’s penultimate Something for the Weekend.

Under the tree today: Christmas comes early for Nick Clegg; Christmas comes too late for Queen Victoria; Santa breaks the news that Steve Webb doesn’t exist; and more!

Posted in Something for the Weekend | 1 Comment

A triple dose of Nick Clegg in the media (updated)

Let’s hope Nick Clegg got all his Christmas shopping finished before he was elected leader, because he looks just a mite busy getting lots of media coverage at the moment.

This morning, he was on Radio 4′ s Today in the coveted 8:10am slot (listen again here for up to seven days or read about it here), whilst The Voice hears that there are interviews set to appear in the Sunday Times (on … Sunday) and then Monday’s Daily Telegraph.

UPDATE: Make that a quadruple dose: he is also in the news over the latest Al Yamamah revelations.

Posted in News | Tagged | 5 Comments
Advert

Recent Comments

  • Chris Rennard
    Great recollections. I joined a few years before Simon but we overlapped and worked together in ULS when we both shared a commitment to the distinctiveness and ...
  • Tony Robertson
    Well said, I'm with you and think your assessment is spot on. Too much treading water, not enough radical Liberalism. I've been a member since 1980 and fear we'...
  • Alex Macfie
    Not all vapes contain nicotine. What I really don't understand is the decision to tax all vapes the same, whether or not they contain nicotine. Also it isn't th...
  • Brigid Gardner
    @ Sarah: absolutely...
  • PM
    @ David, "I assume you refer to the people of England, Andrew..." Maybe Andrew will correct me, but I took him to mean the people of the UK. Or...