Lib Dem MEPs’ ‘reform and transparency’ rankings

Ahh, the European elections – those of you who’ve been paying especially close attention to the news in recent weeks may have caught a nano-second of coverage of the issues which will be decided by voters across the EU next week.

If so, you might have come across an analysis by the Open Europe think-tank – more about whom here – who this week published a ranking of all 785 Members of the European Parliament, scoring their record on promoting transparency and reform in the EU over the last five-year term.

The criteria Open Europe used for their scoring system are published here, and you can view the full Excel spreadsheet of all MEPs by clicking here. We’ve extracted the information relating to the UK’s 11 Lib Dem MEPs (out of 78), as below:

  • (4th out of 78) Ms Diana Wallis MEP UK Liberal Democrats, score = 42 (out of a maximum 60)
  • (6th) Ms Fiona Hall MEP UK Liberal Democrat = 40
  • (9th) Ms Liz Lynne MEP UK Liberal Democrats = 39
  • (12th) Mr Andrew Duff MEP UK Liberal Democrats = 38
  • (12th) Mr Bill Newton-Dunn MEP UK Liberal Democrats = 38
  • (18th) Ms Elspeth Attwooll MEP UK Liberal Democrats = 37
  • (23rd) Mr Graham Watson MEP UK Liberal Democrats = 36
  • (28th) Mr Chris Davies MEP UK Liberal Democrats = 35
  • (48th) The Baroness Ludford MEP UK Liberal Democrats = 29
  • (53rd) Ms Sharon Bowles MEP* UK Liberal Democrat = 28
  • (66th out of 78) The Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne MEP UK Liberal Democrats = 23
  • * Sharon replaced Chris Huhne on his election to the House of Commons in May 2005.

    It is, I guess, to our group’s credit that more than half their number appear in the top 20. It’s certainly a relief to know that no Lib Dem MEP appears in Open Europe’s list of “MEPs arguably ‘Unfit for public office’”. However, two Tories and two Ukippers do make the EU-wide list of eight named and shamed:

    Mr Ashley Mote MEP – United Kingdom – Independent, elected as Ukip
    In 2007 Mote was convicted of 21 charges of benefit fraud84 for falsely claiming for than £65,000 in benefits. He was given a 9 month prison sentence, which he served, but because it was less than 12 months he was allowed to return as an MEP.

    Mr Giles Chichester MEP – United Kingdom – Conservative
    Giles Chichester paid more than £400,000 in European Parliament office expenses into a company of which he was a director.

    Posted in Europe / International and News | Tagged , and | 1 Comment
    Advert

    The loans that aren’t loans are no more

    It had become a quarterly habit of mine, pointing out how the Electoral Commission’s quarterly reports mixed up actual loans taken out by political parties with unused credit facilities, providing an inaccurate impression of parties being much more in debt than they really are.

    Last quarter I noted that the reporting was clearer, and it’s good to see that with this quarter’s figures and news release the two different issues have been fully separated out, with only the actual borrowing in the headline debt figures the media are reporting. Success at last 🙂

    Posted in News | Tagged | Leave a comment

    Lewes Lib Dem councillor defects to Tories

    Yesterday, my LDV colleague Mark Pack blogged of Labour-to-Lib Dem defector in Merseyside. Alas, this week’s defection news isn’t all cheery for the party:

    A Liberal Democrat councillor defected to the Conservatives saying his dedication to his town was not recognised by his old party. Robbie Robertson, who represents Newhaven Valley on Lewes District Council, announced his decision to cross the floor after his party raised council tax by 16% in Newhaven.

    He said: “I am a dedicated and hard working councillor but sadly in my present position my skills are not utilised.

    “Becoming a councillor was for me

    …

    Posted in Local government and News | Tagged and | 6 Comments

    Clegg to clamp down on Lib Dem Lords’ allowances

    Mea culpa, gentle reader, this is definitely not breaking news… After a bank holiday of back-breaking gardening and a Tuesday of work-fuelled meetings (my colleagues can add their own excuses), LDV failed to bring you news of Nick Clegg’s plans to clamp down on allowances claimed by members of the House of Lords – an issue of more-than-passing-interest to Lib Dems following the resignation of party chief executive Lord (Chris) Rennard amid allegations that he had profited personally from the scheme by designating his Eastbourne flat (rather than his London house) as his main residence.

    This from Sunday night’s …

    Posted in News | Tagged , , , , and | 15 Comments

    At least the trains are running on time (Or are they?)

    The news isn’t all doom ‘n’ gloom, y’know – even in the Telegraph:

    Trains are more punctual than ever, Network Rail has claimed, with more than nine out of 10 arriving on time over the past year. The figures are the best since the industry started collating punctuality statistics in 1992. Last month the performance was even better than the yearly average, with 93.5 per cent of services classed as running on time. The industry’s definition of punctuality is based on commuter services operating within five minutes of the timetable and for longer distance trains, 10 minutes.

    However, Lib Dem …

    Posted in News | Tagged , , and | 7 Comments
    Advert

    Lib Dems tackle UKIP head on

    On Monday, the Lib Dem’s chair of Communications Edward Davey wrote to the leader of UKIP Nigel Farage MEP to challenge him on failing to publish his own expenses, on the disgraceful voting record of his European Parliamentary Party, and on the shameful track record of his fellow parliamentarians.

    “UKIP MEPs have attacked others over their expenses while living the high life in Brussels, charging the taxpayer, and hiding the true cost from voters.

    “One in six UKIP MEPs elected in 2004 has since faced criminal charges over their creative accounting. Meanwhile, UKIP turned up in the European Parliament to vote

    …

    Posted in News | Tagged , , and | 3 Comments

    David Boothroyd in Wikipedia sockpuppeting brouhaha

    From Dizzy Thinks:

    David Boothroyd has had to resign from the “Wikipedia Supreme Court”. David Boothroyd is a Labour councillor in Westminster who comments on a number of right wing blogs including this one. He has an anally retentive insistent on this blog of referring to me by my full name for some reason.

    I mentioned this simply because he’s had to resign after admitting to have multiple identities on Wikipedia and spending most of his time editing David Cameron’s page. He also used his multiple identities to get himself elected to the Wikipedia Arbitration Committee it seems.

    With more detail in …

    Posted in Online politics | 12 Comments

    Guardian mostly apologises to Jo Swinson

    From today’s Corrections and Clarifications column in the Guardian:

    A further correction to our graphic surveying the expenses of certain MPs: In the category Cheapest claims, we stated without qualification that cosmetics were included in receipts submitted by Jo Swinson, Liberal Democrat MP for East Dunbartonshire (23 May, page 6). Jo Swinson has denied claiming for these makeup items, telling the Telegraph, which originally reproduced one of her receipts, that the cosmetics appeared on a Boots receipt for other items she was claiming.

    (More on this story in James Graham’s weekend post – including his request that you send an …

    Posted in News | Tagged , and | Leave a comment

    Daily View 2×2: 27 May 2009

    2 big stories

    Much of today’s coverage is summed up perfectly by the Independent’s headline Brown v Cameron v Clegg, under which all three leaders set out their visions for the rebuilding of Britain’s broken politics. They are due to take party in cross-party talks according to the Guardian, talks to be led by that famed bastion of reform, Jack Straw. Perhaps that’s who Nick Clegg was thinking of when he said (to the Times): “There are prominent people in government who recognise that the game’s up.” Our friends in the Lords are

    …

    Posted in Daily View | Tagged , , , , , and | 6 Comments

    Labour councillor switches to Lib Dems on Merseyside

    From the Liverpool Daily Post:

    A RIFT among a Merseyside Labour group last night led to a shock defection to the Liberal Democrats.

    Cllr Paul Larkin, who represents Bootle’s Derby ward, crossed the divide after claiming Sefton’s Labour leadership is “deaf” to the concerns of voters.

    Posted in News | Tagged | 4 Comments

    Conservatives expel branch chair for saying vote UKIP

    Iain Dale has the story of Ralph Buckle, the chair of University of York Conservatives until he called for people to vote UKIP. He’s now an ex-chair and ex-member.

    Posted in News | Tagged , and | 6 Comments

    An easy way for by-election candidates to communicate with voters

    votewise.co.uk – the independent website which lists forthcoming by-elections and candidates (and which I blogged about here) – has recently started displaying page view figures on the biography pages for each by-election candidate. The numbers (even allowing for being page views rather than absolute unique visitors) are generally impressive, with a candidate’s page being typically viewed several hundred times.

    Given the number of votes it takes to win or lose an election, and the likelihood that a high proportion of those views are from (potential) voters, that’s not a number to be sniffed …

    Posted in Online politics | Tagged | 3 Comments

    Interesting use of YouTube

    A current Lords parliamentary inquiry is allowing YouTube submissions from members of the public.  The inquiry is on the topic of how people engage with the work of the House of Lords and Parliament more generally.

    One such member of the public who has shared her views is, erm, Jo Swinson, in an excellent short video that addresses many of their questions.

    You can see the video for yourself here on the Parliamentary YouTube channel, along with many other interesting shorts, including information about the clock that chimes Big Ben.

    Posted in Online politics | Tagged , and | Leave a comment

    ‘Tory bungs £22k for a leaflet’

    Thus writes The Sun:

    A TORY Euro MP paid her husband £22,500 to help her write a 15-page leaflet on waste management, The Sun can reveal.

    Caroline Jackson, 62, initially failed to declare the payment.

    She then disguised the size of the payout to hubby Robert by splitting it into three and listing each part as between £0 and £10,000”.

    Full story here.

    Posted in News | Tagged | 2 Comments

    Cometh the hour, cometh PR?

    It’s quiet in LDV Towers this afternoon as all the responsible editors have day job responsibilties.

    We can always tell when we’re not talking about something our readers want to have their say on, because you kindly have your say on it anyway on whatever was the top post.

    And today’s topic is clearly Call Me Dave’s speech on parliamentary reform, in which he sets out a series of Lib Dem policy proposals and pretends they’re new.  There’s no zealot like a recently converted zealot, but hang on a minute, Dave?  Power to the people?  Small government?  All of that is Liberalism 101, the first chapter from An Intelligent Person’s Guide to Liberalism.  We’ve long held it dear, and we simply don’t believe you when we hear it from your lips.

    As Lynne Featherstone said earlier today on her blog

    There is stuff that Cameron’s said which I agree with – as you would expect given that many of the ‘ideas’ he puts forward in today’s Guardian are long-standing Liberal Democrat policies! Fixed-term parliaments, reducing of the power of the executive, cutting the number of MPs, devolving power to councils and empowering individuals. Transparency and accountability – definitely. Shame Cameron has had to be dragged kicking and screaming on these. But – to be fair – at least he is going out there.

    Posted in News | Tagged , , , , , , and | 18 Comments

    Daily View 2×2: 26 May 2009

    As we all return to work after the Bank Holiday weekend, the big issues I’ve picked for today’s Daily View are about governance: specifically, how the British state should relate to its citizens or how the world should govern the nuclear ambitions of a rogue state.

    2 Big Stories

    David Cameron is making a bid for reformist credentials with a wide-ranging speech on democratic accountability and the nature of politics and the state. Previewed in The Guardian, his remarks later today thoughtfully ponder ‘the post-bureaucratic age’ and try to appropriate liberal principles:

    The Tory leader, who has in the past week ended the

    …

    Posted in Daily View | Tagged , and | 13 Comments

    Opinion: Why the sensible candidate is now the outmoded one

    It’s hard to keep pace with the news of the number of MPs who are leaving the Commons at the next election owing to the expenses scandal. This is only likely to rise, as deselections start and even safe seats start coming available. We are going to be in a situation where even the unlikeliest of prospects become possible wins for the Lib Dems, so how do we capitalise on this?

    Firstly, we have to recognise that contests for those seats shall not be for the faint of heart. Big hitters with safe seats such as Hazel Blears and Alan Duncan …

    Posted in Op-eds | Tagged | 39 Comments

    Scientology goes on trial in France

    From France 24:

    A high profile trial against the Church of Scientology opens in Paris Monday amid questions about whether the latest legal battle could threaten Scientology’s operations in France.

    This time, the organisation faces a fine of up to 5 million euros and even the prospect of dissolution.

    The latest case centres on a complaint made by a 43-year-old Parisian woman, who claims the organisation persuaded her to spend at least 20,000 euros for various fraudulent cases including medication for “self-purification”, books and an “electrometer”, a device used to measure galvanic skin response in patients…

    The Church of Scientology says money can

    …

    Posted in News | Tagged and | 21 Comments

    Blogging the revolution: Let a group of ordinary voters fix the expenses mess

    Last week, we called for readers to set out the reforms they felt were most desperately needed to our moribund political system – familiar and new ideas alike. Antony Hook responds.

    Liberal Democrats have traditionally supported the idea of Citizens’ Juries and reforming MPs’ funding is a perfect case to apply this policy.

    A citizens’ jury is empanelled in the same way as the juries who decide thousands of our criminal cases and civil disputes every year: 12 people at random from the electoral register. They can hear evidence and arguments from every interested

    …

    Posted in Op-eds | 4 Comments

    LDV Members’ Survey – MPs’ expenses (6): your views about the Speaker

    Almost a week ago, LDV emailed those Lib Dem party members signed-up to our private discussion forum inviting them to take part in a survey focusing on MPs’ expenses. Many thanks to the 240+ of you who completed it; we’ve published the results in full on LDV over the last few days. You can catch up with all our past exclusive LDV members’ surveys by clicking here.

    1.

    LDV asked: Now that the Speaker of the House of Commons, Michael Martin, has resigned a handful of Liberal Democrat MPs have been suggested as the new Speaker. It has …

    Posted in LDV Members poll | Tagged , , and | 1 Comment

    Daily View 2×2: 25 May 09

    Say what you like about the banks: they give great holiday.

    A day for making plans, maybe catching up on a few of those odd jobs – like electoral reform, for example…

    2 Big Stories

    Alan Johnson writes in the Times, recommending the adoption of the Alternative Vote Plus system: this came out of the Jenkins Report (Independent Commission on the Voting System) over a decade ago.

    “The adoption of AV+ would shift the political focus currently concentrated almost exclusively on a few swing voters in a handful of marginal seats. It would end the perversity of the party with the most

    …

    Posted in Daily View | Tagged and | 3 Comments

    What they said about the Commons

    Following up my piece on what they said about the Speaker in the nineteenth century, here’s what the Quarterly Review wrote in 1830:

    There is something in the very atmosphere of the House unfavourable to bold and uncompromising conduct. It is, de facto, a sort of overgrown club. This is the worst part of the business. Things are every day admitted in private among the members, which are studiously denied or concealed in the speeches reported from the gallery. (January 1830, p.271-2)

    Posted in Parliament | 2 Comments

    How much should an MP spend on a website?

    I’m all for MPs spending money on websites* and, just because you can set something up for free in five minutes, that doesn’t mean an MP can’t sensibly spend a reasonable chunk of money on a website. Good MP websites contain a wealth of content, design and functionality for which it is reasonable to pay something.

    But the news that Conservative MP Angela Browning’s spent £9,635 for a pretty basic website plus 30 months hosting/support does look very odd. From what I’ve seen, I can’t see how that price is justified: it is substantially more than a range of …

    Posted in News | Tagged | 9 Comments

    A Conservative, a Facebook profile, an expulsion

    From the Sunday Mirror:

    A Tory activist has been expelled from the party for posting a picture of himself with a Hitler moustache on Facebook … And beside it, in the “My Favourite Quotes” section, he allegedly made racist and sexist comments, including one saying: “I don’t hate everyone, I just hate women …

    A spokesman said: “These comments are disgusting. He has no place in the party. He is being expelled immediately.”

    Daniel O’Docherty had been chair of the Birmingham University Conservatives until a few weeks ago.

    Posted in News | Tagged , and | 3 Comments

    Jo Swinson’s expenses: why you should write an email today

    I’ve been very gratified by the entirely positive feedback my articles about the Daily Telegraph and Jo Swinson yesterday have received.  This is entirely in keeping with the broadly sympathetic reaction Jo has received on both the blogosphere and on Twitter.

    That the story has had such a positive backlash is of course a good thing.  The trouble with such stories however is that they often grow in the retelling.  I’ve already cited how the BBC and Guardian have contributed to this.  What if a candidate opposing Jo in the general election campaign were to base a dirty tricks campaign …

    Posted in News | Tagged , and | 3 Comments

    Which party leads online?

    Social Media Affairs has just released a report looking at the political social media landscape in the UK (with, ahem, myself being one of the four people contributing introductory remarks about politics and social media).

    Any report like this has to deal with all sorts of issues of definition and categorisation but there are some striking broad trends they’ve found.

    Liberal Democrat councillors are the keenest bloggers

    7% of Liberal Democrat councillors are bloggers (a number boosted significantly by the ALDC MyCouncillor system), compared to 2% of Labour councillors and 1% of Conservative councillors.

    This keenness to blog also has a significant …

    Posted in Online politics | Tagged | 26 Comments

    Weekly catchup to 23/05/09

    And goodness, what a fortnight it’s been for politics and the party.  Since we at Weekly (hem hem) Catchup left  your screens a fortnight (hem hem) ago we’ve seen a lot of movement on the political front led by the Telegraph’s sensational coverage of the “Cash for Cushions” constitutional crisis that John Stewart’s chromakey team dubbed “Scamalot“.

    We kicked off our coverage with a triple bill of Norman Baker’s contributions on the matter, but it was to be a gift that keeps on giving.  Stephen ranted, then questioned; you answered in spades. Clegg weighed in. Alix …

    Posted in A weekly catchup | 1 Comment

    LDV Members’ Survey – MPs’ expenses (5): how Nick Clegg’s performed

    On Tuesday evening, LDV emailed those Lib Dem party members signed-up to our private discussion forum inviting them to take part in a survey focusing on MPs’ expenses. Many thanks to the 240+ of you who have so far completed it; we’ve been publishing the results on LDV over the last few days. You can catch up on the results of all our past exclusive LDV members’ surveys by clicking here.

    Today we’re publishing the result that always prompts a bout of nerves in the leader’s office – how LDV’s party member readers view Nick Clegg’s performance. LDV …

    Posted in LDV Members poll | Tagged and | Leave a comment

    Daily View 2×2: 24 May 09

    Welcome to the Sunday outing for The Voice’s new daily post series highlighting two big stories from the media and two “must read” blog posts from Liberal Democrats. As it’s a Sunday, there’s also a bonus extra supplement. If you spot anything for future posts, do let us know on [email protected]

    2 Big Stories

    MPs’ expenses
    Heading into its third week, the MPs’ expense story shows no sign of abating. The latest scalp is that of Andrew MacKay, again. The story has been running for so long that not only was he one of its first victims (losing his Conservative Party job) but …

    Posted in Daily View | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , and | 2 Comments

    An unusual election poster

    Spotted in Brentwood, where David Kendall is standing for the Liberal Democrats in the local elections.

    Brentwood election posterOne of his leaflets has stuck on a resident’s door with “I’m voting for you Davey baby” and “Get these idiots out” written on it.

    On the door next to it, a piece of paper which says:

    I’d rather remove my nipples with a rusty tin opener than vote Labour or Conservative. I will only open my door to Dave Kendall’s crew.

    All in all, it’s probably quite a good thing David got his nomination …

    Posted in Humour | Tagged , and | 7 Comments
    Advert

    Recent Comments

    • BigTallTim
      Congrats Simon. I can only claim 45 years activism, having joined the SDP at its launch. Including the pleasure of being a Councillor for 26 years - 1986-96 and...
    • Geoff Reid
      Interesting to hear of Simon being Treasurer of the Union of Liberal Students. I was the North Regional Treasurer of ULS in 1967. After my appointment the bank ...
    • Ruth Bright
      How lovely Simon. Congratulations. Here's to the next 50!...
    • Pawel Urbanski
      The comments have moved to how we pay for it, but I think there is an prior question. The triple lock was our policy and it had a clear job: to catch up after t...
    • Chloe
      Well said Rees. I've seen no drop off in youngsters vaping obviously due to old school proxy sales. Far better to vape than to smoke , this tax will just make e...