The SNP are holding their Conference in Aberdeen this weekend. Next weekend, the Scottish Liberal Democrats hold our Conference in Dunfermline. These are very different events, not least in terms of scale. The SNP’s event is massive this year, for obvious reasons. They are not used to the presence of the BBC’s UK political editor.
I’ve been looking over the agenda for both events tonight and have a few reflections to make:
The SNP’s motions are much simpler
Have a look at the SNP agenda. It’s pretty bland. Compare it with ours. Our motions tend to be longer and contain a whole load more detail.
Our motions also tend to challenge our leadership more. The first thing Conference will discuss on Saturday is something that will be a little more radical than the leadership was thinking about for our manifesto – a motion to put a penny on income tax with money raised to go towards our underfunded and failing NHS. I have no doubt that there will be an amendment from the Policy Committee, but there will be a good and genuine debate.
Meanwhile, the SNP’s former Deputy Leader Jim Sillars has criticised their leadership for stifling debate, particularly over the question of a second referendum. He told the Telegraph:
Since 1993, the leadership has had a firm grip upon the SNP as a party and the conference has over those years degenerated into a happy, clappy outing for leadership speeches – good, bad or indifferent.
Liberal Democrats challenge their governments more
If you look back to when the Liberal Democrats were in Government, there were many more Conference motions which directly challenged the leadership. One thing you won’t be finding at SNP conference is someone telling the leadership that “there are some things you just can’t polish” as I did when I proposed a motion opposing secret courts to the Scottish Conference on 2012. You can read my speech here – it didn’t pull any punches. That link also contains a video clip of part of my speech and one by Glasgow’s Hugh Waterfield, also opposing secret courts, in which he said something pretty surprising.








